On CBS MoneyWatch: 5 Things You Should Buy at Walmart
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

August 22nd, 2008

PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverup (updated)

Posted by Jason D. O'Grady @ 5:00 am

Categories: Display, PowerBook

Tags: Apple PowerBook, Complaint, Apple PowerBook G4, Apple Inc., Manufacturing, Notebooks, Hardware, Notebooks & Tablets, Jason D. O'Grady

PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverupApple appears to be censoring discussion of a display manufacturing defect in theĀ  PowerBook G4 17-inch and have not acknowledging that the defect even exists. Notebook computers, especially 17s, are an expensive investment to have just go belly-up shortly after they come out of warranty. Some people have had their machines die right after the one-year warranty expires.

One factor that may be hampering Apple’s ability to identify and track such manufacturing and/or production problems is that international AppleCare complaints aren’t tracked on analyzed in a central database. Instead it’s a patchwork of databases kept by individual countries that isn’t shared amongst the group. This renders Apple unable to detect worldwide complaint patterns that would alert them to defects.

Read more about the complaints and censorship and decide for yourself.

Update: A Web site was posted yesterday with uncensored discussion of this problem and loaded with specific, up-to-date advice on what people can do if they have this defect.

Jason D. O'GradyJason D. O'Grady is the editor of PowerPage.org, which has been publishing daily mobile technology news since December 1995. For disclosures on Jason's industry affiliations, click here or to view Jason's full profile click here.

Email Jason D. O'Grady

Subscribe to The Apple Core via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 81 Talkback(s)
There's censoring and then there's censoring
When I go to a company's forum, it's to discuss issues I have with a product and hopefully find some help. If they delete posts regarding the problem, how would I (or anyone else) be able to share in... (Read the rest)
Posted by: mdsock@... Posted on: 08/29/08 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
And yet Apple is rated highest ....  ShadeTree | 08/22/08
or maybe the rest of them really....  mrlinux | 08/22/08
Explain just how exactly ....  ShadeTree | 08/22/08
Probably because  frgough | 08/22/08
What Apple has a history of ....  ShadeTree | 08/22/08
Look up non-sequitir  frgough | 08/22/08
Were it not for the RDF factor ....  ShadeTree | 08/22/08
Following that logic  mdemuth | 08/22/08
Apple's Deniability  flhu | 08/25/08
Hahaha  tikigawd | 08/26/08
Your description is painting with a rather large brush, eh? (NT)  snberk341 | 08/23/08
The American way..  mjdurango | 08/26/08
How to offer but not help  dddavids@... | 08/27/08
Points valid...except  laura.b | 08/22/08
well...  doh123 | 08/22/08
Of course they "censor", like everybody else...  snberk341 | 08/23/08
Easy, now  laura.b | 08/25/08
Hilarious  tikigawd | 08/26/08
There's censoring and then there's censoring  mdsock@... | 08/29/08
I wonder  tikigawd | 08/26/08
How?  fairportfan | 08/25/08
Or maybe  Crestview | 08/25/08
Maybe that's because  frgough | 08/22/08
There was nothing impartial or scientific ....  ShadeTree | 08/22/08
foaming at the mouth  frgough | 08/22/08
Sorry to hear ....  ShadeTree | 08/22/08
Rushing to defend the queen...?  Wolfie2K3 | 08/22/08
You've forgotten about censorship  eMJayy | 08/25/08
A=B and C=D therefor A=D  dragon@... | 08/22/08
True they do have the highest rating...  RicD_ | 08/22/08
I see that you are a fan of censorship.  ShadeTree | 08/22/08
Not a good example  snberk341 | 08/23/08
They've been sucking lately  rpmyers1 | 08/22/08
True, but what about this...  gwzap2008 | 08/22/08
Ah yes, the give and take of adult conversation...  snberk203 | 08/22/08
There is something fishy about this  James Quinn | 08/22/08
Which begs the question  laura.b | 08/22/08
Interesting question here....  James Quinn | 08/22/08
This issue is still relevant now  jayk_z | 08/22/08
I replied to you below....  James Quinn | 08/22/08
Maybe a bit odd  laura.b | 08/22/08
Well according to Jayk-Z  James Quinn | 08/22/08
You are making bad extrapolations from my statements  jayk_z | 08/22/08
No I quoted your statements I did not know  James Quinn | 08/22/08
Some mysteries don't come to light until much later...  Wolfie2K3 | 08/22/08
Which makes me nervous about buying a MacBook Pro  jayk_z | 08/22/08
Nerves...  Wolfie2K3 | 08/22/08
ROFL!!  laura.b | 08/26/08
Apple forums?  frabjous | 08/25/08
Because that's the forum most Apple users use?  jayk_z | 08/26/08
Just curious.  Badgered | 08/22/08
Saying that "IF" this is the situation then  James Quinn | 08/22/08
Some facts, folks  frabjous | 08/25/08
Irrelevant facts  jayk_z | 08/26/08
Re: No I quoted your statements I did not know  jayk_z | 08/22/08
RE: PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverup  ubingc | 08/22/08
Initial quality high, Long term??  jscott418 | 08/22/08
Just like Syntax-Brillian TV's  NotMSUser | 08/22/08
Fishy, Indeed!  QueenMama | 08/22/08
If you have the display defect, here's what to do:  jayk_z | 08/22/08
Story is relevant in 2008  jayk_z | 08/22/08
Another interesting questions here...  James Quinn | 08/22/08
If it were a few random failures...  jayk_z | 08/22/08
In the computer industry I've never heard of this...  James Quinn | 08/22/08
Ok, it's a manufacturing defect  jayk_z | 08/22/08
Take a deep breath  frabjous | 08/25/08
IF Apple is doing something they're taking WAY too long  jayk_z | 08/26/08
Well...  dracolich_prgrm | 08/25/08
RE: PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverup  wcallman@... | 08/22/08
RE: PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverup  tim.c@... | 08/23/08
RE: Perspective please?  vikingnyc@... | 08/25/08
It's happening right NOW for some of us!  jayk_z | 08/25/08
RE: PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverup  szheart@... | 08/25/08
RE: PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverup  Laraine Anne Barker | 08/25/08
A rash of defects is NOT "to be expected"  jayk_z | 08/25/08
I totally agree  ol_pip | 08/25/08
WHAT!?  Crestview | 08/25/08
RE: PowerBook G4 display manufacturing defect coverup  sdicenso | 08/25/08
I was not going to respond to this at first...  vilppuu@... | 08/26/08
WHAT IS THE DEFECT, MORONS?  dgurney | 08/26/08
The defect is dead pixel columns up and down your pretty screen  tikigawd | 08/26/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here