On MovieTome: The 10 worst movies of 2009 so far!
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

September 23rd, 2008

Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting

Posted by Sam Diaz @ 5:00 am

Categories: AT&T, Apple, General, Google, Mobile, iPhone

Tags: Apple iPhone, Google Inc., Phone, Mobile, Advertising & Promotion, Marketing, Sam Diaz

There’s a feeling of excitement around today’s expected launch of Android, Google’s long-anticipated mobile operating system. But when I drove past a few electronics stores last night, I didn’t see anyone camping out the way people were lined up for Apple’s iPhone.

[See our live coverage of the launch.]

I suspect there’s some confusion about what Android is, exactly. Early on, it was dubbed the gPhone - but that’s somewhat misleading if you try to do an Apples-to-apples comparison with the iPhone. In the case of Apple’s iPhone, it was an operating system, too, but for one phone only - Apple’s. Google’s operating system, which also encourages the development of mobile applications, is eventually expected to land on a variety of devices. And now, there’s some buzz that the Google’s open-source operating system might eventually reach beyond phones and land on other products - maybe set-top boxes, TVs or even cars.

For now, the emphasis is on mobile phones. A growing number of mobile phones - beyond the iPhone - are already Web-capable. Google wants to supply those mobile surfers with the information they’re seeking from a mobile Web connection.

To a certain extent, Google is already doing that by enhancing its mobile offerings. Applications like Gmail, Reader and, of course, search are already available through a mobile Web browser. In addition, a number of other operating systems - iPhone, Blackberry, Windows Mobile and others - are supporting Google Apps for Mobile, a much more attractive and user-friendly version of Google’s most popular services. Last week, Google Maps for Mobile was upgraded to include Street View images. In addition, Google has been offering for some time now an SMS version of its search functionality. Send a SMS text message to GOOGL (46645) with a simple search such as “pizza, 94105″ and you’ll receive a text listing of pizza joints in the San Francisco zip code.

I’ve been running Google services on my phone (a Blackberry) for some time now so the excitement around a gPhone - err, Android - just isn’t all that exciting to me. I’ll certainly check out an Android phone as soon as I can - but I don’t think I’ll consider a switch to T-Mobile the way I considered a switch to AT&T for the iPhone.

Why would I? In many ways, I feel like my phone is already a Google phone.

Sam Diaz

Sam Diaz is a senior editor at ZDNet. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Sam Diaz

Subscribe to Between the Lines via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 65 Talkback(s)
Not that others won't and aren't doing the same thing
The current edition of Windows For Mobile when you end up using a Microsoft server.

Time for a reality check, though. This is a T-Mobile product that will use thier networks and isn't tied to ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: TtfnJohn Posted on: 09/26/08 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Not IPhone then what?  Gongu Greg | 09/23/08
Not Supposed To Be An IPhone  volatile900@... | 09/23/08
Well, true, but he was spot on that they can NOT generate the excitement of  DonnieBoy | 09/23/08
Not exactly  tBuggR | 09/23/08
I disagree, I think that Google would love to have people lined up  DonnieBoy | 09/23/08
Someone pass Donnie some Beano...  Wolfie2K3 | 09/23/08
Their Real Plan  jfreedle2@... | 09/25/08
Not that others won't and aren't doing the same thing  TtfnJohn | 09/26/08
Kool-aid  daengbo | 09/23/08
Re: The Apple Cider Kool-aid Gang? Drunk again! wink  i2fun@... | 09/24/08
I just don't get that line of reasoning  josephmartins | 09/23/08
Good points, and probably the way that Google wants it. They WANT Google  DonnieBoy | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  Helio99000 | 09/23/08
True, us nerds understand the value of a truely open phone, and as people  DonnieBoy | 09/23/08
Never  diom1982 | 09/23/08
iPhone = 1 Closed Company! Android = A Google of Companies!  i2fun@... | 09/24/08
Alot of people are missing this...  storm14k | 09/23/08
Diss the iPhone  frgough | 09/23/08
Obviously....  storm14k | 09/23/08
Easy to make money?  warren@... | 09/23/08
What SDK has Apple put OUT for iPhone Specifically? grin  i2fun@... | 09/24/08
Google and open  Synthmeister | 09/23/08
You can't wait in line for a product not yet in stores  goldeneyes | 09/23/08
Exactly...  storm14k | 09/23/08
Lead paragraph  SamDiazZDNet Moderator | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  wilex75 | 09/23/08
Me too, I might line up just for the excitement, but, I am not sure if the  DonnieBoy | 09/23/08
They have set a release date...of sorts...  Wolfie2K3 | 09/23/08
Camping out for an iPhone was more to do with...  iTeaBoy | 09/23/08
FAFF Wins  Stoshie | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  sikhi | 09/23/08
Well, it IS the nerds that understand the significance of Android right now  DonnieBoy | 09/23/08
Excitement?  aj.redmond@... | 09/23/08
I agree this might bechanging the mobile market permanently.  richhand@... | 09/23/08
Spoken like a true Kool-Aid swilling, Elitist Apple Fanboi SNOB...  Wolfie2K3 | 09/23/08
Bravo @Wolfie2k3! Yep...StinkyClosedBoxApple or Fresh n Open!  i2fun@... | 09/24/08
Apple has yet to release an iPhone SDK!!! Why?  i2fun@... | 09/24/08
Why is the toy iPhone held up as a standard?  regis_z | 09/23/08
Come on, the iPhone is the the leader for cool and trendy, and was VERY  DonnieBoy | 09/23/08
Sure it is a neat device, but not a business tool  regis_z | 09/23/08
Change of topic?  Leroy Hefty | 09/23/08
you got it about right  iTeaBoy | 09/23/08
Cool and Trendy?  Stoshie | 09/23/08
You can buy  frgough | 09/23/08
Toy?  aj.redmond@... | 09/23/08
Toy? What's wrong with that  drobinow | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting  andrevr | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Simplicity of apple  GodWish | 09/23/08
Purchases Based on Buzz?  Stoshie | 09/23/08
Iphone? doesnt do nothing but look nice  salamone27 | 09/23/08
This article is borderline flame-bait  subl33t | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  tburzio | 09/23/08
Well to say it isn't exciting...  storm14k | 09/23/08
Android is just a gateway to google cloud.  magallanes | 09/23/08
Why did an Apple zealot review this?  Narg | 09/23/08
It's all about screen size  chris.srt@... | 09/23/08
iPhone users aren't switching  coffeeshark | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  richhand@... | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  erniem1970@... | 09/23/08
Microsoft is DOA  Synthmeister | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  ManoaHI | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  tim.c@... | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  Service@... | 09/23/08
A GPL SDK for Android can make the difference  Sameer Dubey | 09/23/08
RE: Android: Exciting, but not iPhone exciting  jfreedle2@... | 09/25/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here