On mySimon: Nikon D3X Black SLR Digital Camera
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

October 30th, 2008

A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?

Posted by Sam Diaz @ 6:10 am

Categories: AT&T, Apple, General, Mobile, RIM, iPhone

Tags: Apple iPhone, Customer Service, Verizon Communications Inc., AT&T Corp., David, Product Marketing, Customer Relationship Management (CRM), Handhelds, Marketing, Enterprise Software

Verizon Wireless and Research in Motion should be thanking one particular customer service rep for stopping at least one customer - me - from defecting to AT&T and the iPhone this week. I had called in to find out about altering my existing family plan and porting my phone over to AT&T when she asked me if I’d heard of the Blackberry Storm. Of course, I had - but I let her go through her pitch as to why I should wait for its arrival before making a decision.

The Blackberry Storm, you see, is supposed to be a real contender for the iPhone, she said. And though a date hasn’t been announced for the release of the Storm, the customer service reps are expecting it to become available anytime now. Nothing is official, of course -Verizon is being quiet about details of the release. But my rep, a veteran who has seen excitement around new phones in the past, said that when the advertising and marketing campaigns kick into high gear and when details about some of the phone’s features start trickling down to the agents, the launch date is getting close.

The launch isn’t getting as much attention as the iPhone did - but there’s clearly a lot at stake here for both Verizon - which is starting to feel the iPhone churn - and Research in Motion, which was outsold by Apple this most recent quarter.  Earlier this week, Verizon Wireless said it wasn’t worried about churn, but customer service folks, who seem to have a ready script to keep customers from jumping to AT&T and the iPhone,  telegraph a different story. Editor-in-Chief Larry Dignan, senior editor David Grober and I called placed calls to Verizon - not as journalists but as legitimate customers - to dig up some details on the Storm.

My Verizon rep’s best guess on the availability of the Storm was maybe 2-3 weeks, she said. Pushing further, I asked if early 2009 was a more realistic target. Her quick answer: “very unlikely.” I even asked: “If you were a gambling type of gal, would you bet that it would be before Thanksgiving?” After a pause, she said yes.

David’s rep gave a pretty clear “I have no idea,” but added that it couldn’t be soon enough. His rep offered to take down his name and number and call when the Storm becomes available. (You can also sign up for e-mail alerts.)

Larry’s rep, on the other hand, wasn’t making any promises or offering much hope of an upcoming announcement. “We don’t have a date but it may not be available until Christmas,” she said. She also noted Verizon’s LG Voyager experience last year, which seemed to slip. The rep remembered the Voyager rollout because a lot of folks ordered them for Christmas.

Of the three of us, he’s the only one serious about staying with Verizon and getting the Storm (he’s done with the Motorola Q, he said.) His contract is up in November so he would be free to pick another carrier - but he has no interest in an iPhone or an account with AT&T.

As for me, I’m even more undecided now than I was before. If you have strong thoughts on the iPhone, the Blackberry, AT&T or Verizon, I’d love to hear your reasons. Please take a minute to vote in this poll and maybe even share some of your thoughts in the Talkbacks.

Which smartphone should I get?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Sam Diaz

Sam Diaz is a senior editor at ZDNet. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Sam Diaz

Subscribe to Between the Lines via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 131 Talkback(s)
No Storm for ATT? Please say it ain't so!
I'd buy a blackberry every day of the week over the Iphone. For my area, I've tried the rest and ATT is the best. Please can we have the STORM!... (Read the rest)
Posted by: girlinthemiddle Posted on: 11/12/08 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
I always find this fascinating  frgough | 10/30/08
Must Agree  steeldestroyer | 10/30/08
must agree  dspeers@... | 10/30/08
Actually, the mentallity is to...  iTeaBoy | 10/30/08
True, but...  steeldestroyer | 10/30/08
The future is fluid  frgough | 10/30/08
It already exists!  iTeaBoy | 10/30/08
How logical of you  tony.antonakas@... | 10/31/08
a bit two-dimensional?  maferious | 11/03/08
What did you do with your old iPhone?  WiredGuy | 11/11/08
It is not the hardware, it is the coverage.  Patric714 | 11/11/08
If Apple Wouldn't Be So Damn Restrictive  itanalyst2@... | 10/30/08
Totally Agree...I would have already switched  kevmark58@... | 10/30/08
Me 3  ddawsonb@... | 10/30/08
The exclusive contract  xshakes | 11/01/08
Why the exclusive agreement?  Ken_z | 10/30/08
total domination  parabyte | 10/30/08
They aren't restrictive... here  Fred Fredrickson | 11/02/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  Voltaic Shock | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  rkmoray | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  L8erG8er | 10/30/08
Backberry IT  gregs01 | 11/11/08
Sam...  Sleeper Service | 10/30/08
re: Sam....  SamDiazZDNet Moderator | 10/30/08
OK...  Sleeper Service | 10/30/08
drag and drop is in the APP store  cartoonasaurus | 10/30/08
Yeah, I know...  Sleeper Service | 10/30/08
AT&T coverage  j.m.galvin | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  NatSang | 10/30/08
I think...  steeldestroyer | 10/30/08
I believe ALL Carriers have to give you a trial run...  Wolfie2K3 | 10/30/08
30 day trial run...  maferious | 11/03/08
iPhone is overrated  andrewjg | 10/30/08
THE iphone is Fantastic does way more than Windows mobile based phones  johnpall@... | 10/30/08
Wow.. lay of the tripple shot espresso's man!!  iTeaBoy | 10/30/08
I own an Omnia...  Sleeper Service | 10/30/08
weh?  U53r | 11/01/08
Sigh... First I have to believe that you bought one  James Quinn | 10/30/08
re: Sigh  Badgered | 10/30/08
People don't complain in talking points (nt)  frgough | 10/30/08
No  Badgered | 10/30/08
Usually its in terms of a personal story not a list...  James Quinn | 10/30/08
Well  Badgered | 10/30/08
Read below... I respond to him.  James Quinn | 10/30/08
Invalidate all negative comments to fight buyer's remorse.  NonZealot | 10/30/08
How can I prove it to you?  andrewjg | 10/30/08
This is my problem and you seem to know your  James Quinn | 10/30/08
Why indeed  andrewjg | 10/30/08
Ah just like me and women..... The looks drag me  James Quinn | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  hparaizo | 10/30/08
Apple does not outsell RIM overall  kdarling | 10/30/08
Exactly!  parabyte | 10/30/08
I'm not buying a cell phone until they quit having two year contracts.  CobraA1 | 10/30/08
grow up, pay the money  Wirelessdude | 10/30/08
ever heard of prepaid?  maferious | 11/03/08
My BlackBerry is the best computing device I've ever owned  mrdatahsZDNet Moderator | 10/30/08
Well put Chris  iTeaBoy | 10/30/08
2 year Blackberry User disagrees....  boehncke_klaus@... | 10/30/08
You have fallen into Apple's trap  parabyte | 10/30/08
They're not called traps...  mrdatahsZDNet Moderator | 10/30/08
Service and the big providers  HeadScratcher7 | 10/31/08
RE: Music or function  pinnacle_ls | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  rjm99999@... | 10/30/08
Why would you be afraid  frgough | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  lborsato | 10/30/08
iPhone or Storm?  trm1945 | 10/30/08
LG Prada anyone?  Sleeper Service | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  MJLawson1 | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  Marita_T | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  Marita_T | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  LarryClark | 10/30/08
Not here Larry...  corymcnutt | 10/30/08
May or may not help but.....  bonespiel@... | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  nmensah@... | 10/30/08
Larry is done with the Q because...  maferious | 11/03/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  StoneKolde | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  ianalyzrisq@... | 10/30/08
Wait for the Storm  pettis360 | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  tracy_dilossi@... | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  jbjtkbw00 | 10/30/08
Was expecting reasons for waiting other than "how long"  jlongino@... | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  steffes | 10/30/08
Increase Poker Skills???  Rev AJ | 10/30/08
Poker...  SamDiazZDNet Moderator | 10/31/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  yammii@... | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  wil2liv | 10/30/08
HTC TOUCH PRO  sonnyb4u@... | 10/30/08
wat do you like about touch pro?  me.arghya | 11/11/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  karimrg | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  igneousquill | 10/30/08
No WiFi are you kidding!!!  PMUP | 10/30/08
ONE WORD WIFI  PMUP | 10/30/08
...but cut & paste isn't a problem?  parabyte | 10/30/08
They're easy software fixes  marthill | 10/31/08
Blackberry WIFI  gregs01 | 11/11/08
Not a tough decision - no Wifi, no buy  no_axe_to__grind | 10/30/08
Are you slow?  parabyte | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  PMUP | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  nanciwolf@... | 10/30/08
Wait for the storm  motor5622@... | 10/30/08
RE: Wait for the storm  pettis360 | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  zd3v@... | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  Wirelessdude | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  vics43 | 10/30/08
Mobility is such an important feature that is lacking in the iPhone.  NonZealot | 10/30/08
Of course...  rynning | 11/03/08
Um...  richard.wilson@... | 10/30/08
The Phones today (in-a-way) remind me of computers of the mid~late '80's..  LazLong | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  billbryan516 | 10/30/08
How much for the Storm???  3dtodd | 10/30/08
Between the 2, STORM. But...  Narg | 10/30/08
Oh, you didn't know?  parabyte | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  cartoonasaurus | 10/30/08
If you have Verizon already it makes more sense to wait and see.  T1Oracle | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  SnoBoy | 10/30/08
Remember the network  jorjitop | 10/30/08
Are you sure it doesn't support GSM?  notsofast | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  blangton | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  null | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  deasthom@... | 10/30/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  slobodan.hajdin@... | 10/31/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  shizin | 10/31/08
Release Date is Nov 15  bbben | 10/31/08
Looking Forward  chunterg | 11/01/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  bjaybush@... | 10/31/08
A tough decision... NOT  MrViklund | 11/01/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  gentryfunk | 11/11/08
Verizon, devision of the CIA  sheeco10 | 11/11/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  oceancrossingcorp@... | 11/11/08
RE: A tough decision: Grab an iPhone or wait for the Storm?  gennx30 | 11/11/08
No Storm for ATT? Please say it ain't so!  girlinthemiddle | 11/12/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads