On mySimon: Body Solid EXM 3000LPS
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

June 22nd, 2009

Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET

Posted by Jason Hiner @ 4:00 am

Categories: Apple, Palm, iPhone

Tags: Apple iPhone, CNET Networks Inc., Palm Inc., Apple iPhone 3G, Corporate Communications, Networking, Marketing, Jason Hiner

In a special episode of CNET Prizefight, Briant Tong, Bonnie Cha, and Nicole Lee pit the iPhone 3G S against the Palm Pre in three speed tests: boot up time, loading a Web page, and taking and sending a photo. They also included the second-gen iPhone in the tests for further comparison.

Watch the six-minute video to see the Palm Pre win two out of the three tests. Keep in mind that this is a non-scientific test that takes place in the CNET studios in San Francisco, a city where the iPhone suffers from widely-reported network problems. Nevertheless, the Pre showed very impressive performance and the iPhone 3G S showed solid improvement over its previous generation hardware.

.

For more insights on iPhone, Palm Pre, and other tech topics, follow my Twitter stream at twitter.com/jasonhiner

Jason HinerJason Hiner is the Editor in Chief of TechRepublic, ZDNet's sister site. Read his blog Tech Sanity Check at hiner.techrepublic.com. You can also find him on Twitter, LinkedIn, and JasonHiner.com.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 64 Talkback(s)
You really hate logic don't you?
The time to complete the task was OBVIOUSLY faster on the iPhone 3G
S from the USERS perspective. Don't tell me that when you press the
"send" button on an email, you sit and wait for it to a... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Bruizer Posted on: 06/27/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Why measure boot time  frgough | 06/22/09
I don't know, but all of my friends iPhones have to reboot from crashes  T1Oracle | 06/22/09
get it looked at!  Geuseppi | 06/22/09
this is a reason  krikus050 | 06/22/09
I would have called the last one a tie.  Bruizer | 06/22/09
I agree, rerun the tests.  NonZealot | 06/22/09
Be fair  Michael Kelly | 06/22/09
Let me clarify  NonZealot | 06/22/09
You guys realize these phones will not work on the other's network, right?  bubbatex | 06/22/09
Or the Pre on AT&T.  Bruizer | 06/22/09
Typical Apple Bigot  quixel | 06/24/09
You really hate logic don't you?  Bruizer | 06/27/09
typical Apple fan  nessrapp | 06/22/09
Not at all.  Bruizer | 06/22/09
Or another look...  Bruizer | 06/22/09
BullSh!t  quixel | 06/24/09
Anandtech's controlled tests with Wifi, iPhone beats Pre 20+%  Davewrite | 06/22/09
Apple announces 1 MILLION 3GS' SOLD! 10 times Pre.  Davewrite | 06/22/09
Good job Apple!!  NonZealot | 06/22/09
hey morning NZ! happy BUY ONE and...  Davewrite | 06/22/09
I suppose I could!  NonZealot | 06/22/09
'least popular' could also means it Sucks! No? happy -nt  Davewrite | 06/22/09
It could!  NonZealot | 06/22/09
But let me guess  rtk | 06/22/09
Well....  Davewrite | 06/22/09
Good job Apple!!  MnDude1971 | 06/22/09
hehehe, yeah.  rtk | 06/22/09
eheehehheeh OH YEAH  Geuseppi | 06/22/09
Clearly you are  rtk | 06/22/09
Missing the whole point on the numbers thing  Geuseppi | 06/22/09
Why should we compare it to iPhone 1? This is 2009 not 2007  Davewrite | 06/22/09
Those iphones were sold in ***8 Countries***  scorpeo | 06/22/09
So what? Fact is Apple installed base gets BIGGER gets the DEVELOPERS!  Davewrite | 06/22/09
Your opinions do not equal the facts!  scorpeo | 06/22/09
FACTS: AT&T already said on first day it's sold hundreds of thousands  Davewrite | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  Ben_rockwood | 06/22/09
Depends on the point of the test  NonZealot | 06/22/09
RE: RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  scorpeo | 06/22/09
You guys basing Cell networks on ONE test?  Davewrite | 06/22/09
Networks speed matters!  scorpeo | 06/22/09
Neither Sprint nor Verizon had a 1,000,000 weekend activation spikes.  Bruizer | 06/22/09
RE: Neither Sprint nor Verizon had a 1,000,000 weekend activation spikes.  scorpeo | 06/23/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  mafuman | 06/22/09
cough cough  quixel | 06/24/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  tdibble | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  mafuman | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  apfer | 06/22/09
A major flaw in the test...  heres_johnny | 06/22/09
No... SPRINT beat AT&T is 2 out of 2 tests...  smitsc05 | 06/22/09
Going to vary greatly depending on where the tests are run  timothyt@... | 06/22/09
Who cares about startup time???  Narg | 06/22/09
Startup Time  Christo295 | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  remonl | 06/22/09
Missing the whole point on the numbers thing  Geuseppi | 06/22/09
It's obvious you're missing the point!  scorpeo | 06/22/09
Once again, people not reading...  Geuseppi | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  tlkunz@... | 06/22/09
Are you kidding me?  NonZealot | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  krikus050 | 06/22/09
Used Both... Like the Pre  fortitermac | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  cc92260 | 06/22/09
Comparing Networks  enovikoff | 06/22/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  Niiro13 | 06/25/09
RE: Palm Pre beats iPhone 3G S in 2 out of 3 speed tests by CNET  phonelover | 06/26/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Essential Topics Click Here

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More