May 1st, 2008
Psystar's Open Computer review: Is it worth it?
There are a few things you need to know before hopping on the Psystar Mac clone bandwagon: You can’t download a software update, which means patching is impossible. You’ll never be a card-carrying member of the Apple ecosystem. And the hardware doesn’t come close to the designs Apple offers. Those caveats aside the Psystar Open Computer isn’t so bad.
That’s the takeaway from a CNET review. Here’s the gist (also see Techmeme):
The good: Faster, more affordable, more upgradable Leopard OS X-based system than anything currently offered by Apple in this price range.
The bad: With limited software updates, you’re effectively cut off from all future Apple products, at least for now; no Bluetooth or IR receiver; no Front Row or iLife.
The bottom line: Its hardware isn’t made by Apple’s design team, it will likely never work as a full member of the greater Apple ecosystem, and one ill-intended software update could turn it into a $750 brick. Get past all of that, and you’ll find Psystar’s OS X-based Open Computer a fast and otherwise compelling lower midrange desktop.
That software update issue is the dealbreaker for many folks. For instance, my source in Miami who took the pictures of Psystar’s latest headquarters, was all prepped to buy a Psystar. But the software update issue derailed his plan.
CNET’s Rich Brown notes that the Psystar lacks the polish and doesn’t feel like a Mac. Overall, the Psystar is comparable to the Mac Mini you just need to know the limitations.
Overall, the Psystar performed better. A look at the benchmarks:
What this buying decision ultimately comes down to is how much you value design, the importance of the software update and whether you’re willing to take a few calculated risks. Everyone will be different. If the Psystar turned into a brick due to some software hangup you could install Windows or Linux. That said a lot of us don’t want to be bothered with installing a new OS on the weekend. 
More reading that may help you make the Psystar call:
- Is Psystar Mac clone using the Kalyway boot hack?
- Why I won’t be buying a “Hackint0sh” system
- PC Industry Episode II: Attack of the Mac Clones
- Exclusive: Pictures of Psystar’s corporate home; Clone maker’s store is open
- Pystar gallery (right)
- All Psystar content
Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and Editorial Director of ZDNet sister site TechRepublic. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.
For daily updates, follow Larry on Twitter.
Subscribe to Between the Lines via Email alerts or RSS.
