On mySimon: North Face Elkhorn 0 Degree Sleeping Bag
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

August 23rd, 2007

Vista Media Center takes over the living room

Posted by Ed Bott @ 2:38 pm

Categories: Digital media, Windows Vista

Tags: Media Center PC, PC, System, Microsoft Windows Vista, Microsoft Windows, Vista Media Center, Ed Bott

[Update 24-August, 2:00PM: By popular request, I've assembled a list of the parts that went into this system, including specs and prices.]  

In June, I recounted my out-of-the-box experience with a new Dell PC running Windows Vista, starting with a failed BIOS upgrade, undergoing a successful repair, and establishing that the basic hardware and software setup was rock-solid.

Vista Media Center from 10 feet

The reason I bought this PC in the first place was to use it as the hub of a home theater system, integrated with a 5.1 surround sound setup and a 50-inch Sony HDTV with Vista Media Center as the front end. So, at the beginning of July, I took the plunge and moved this system out of the office and into the living room. It took about two weeks to assemble all the pieces I needed and get everything working together correctly, but today I am thoroughly pleased with everything about this system. If you’ve considered doing the same thing, I have some advice in this post, and I’ve documented the whole thing with an image gallery so you can see what it looks like.

Image Gallery: “Using Windows Vista as a home theater hub” 

My goal with this system was to consolidate all of our digital media - photos, music, and home videos - into a single location accessible over the network. I want to be able to play back any album or song, create playlists on the fly, launch slide shows, and view home movies, all using a remote control. I had no doubt that the Media Center interface would work, because we’ve been happily using Windows XP Media Center Edition 2005 for the past two years, with an Xbox 360 in the living room as an extender. Bringing the PC into the living room simplifies the equipment lineup, reduces the cost, and potentially offers better performance because it’s not bound by network speeds.

The bottom line: It works. Spectacularly well, in fact. I originally approached this as a proof-of-concept experiment, and I was half expecting to run into at least one roadblock that would cause me to give up and go back to my old setup. Surprisingly, the only obstacles were minor ones.

Next –>

Pages: 1 2 3

Ed BottEd Bott is an award-winning technology writer with more than two decades' experience writing for mainstream media outlets and online publications. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Ed Bott

Subscribe to Ed Bott's Microsoft Report via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 258 Talkback(s)
sorry
Sorry I keep posting, but I was trying to respond to someone elses comments and I kept pressing the wrong button.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: cacoleby@... Posted on: 09/24/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Success Story  Harry Bardal | 08/23/07
RE:Success Story  ruped24 | 08/23/07
MythTV  Protector | 08/24/07
I have to MythTV is better  voska | 08/24/07
Myth is easy to set up  Sabz5150 | 08/28/07
Ed should test this too  otaddy | 08/24/07
I have no problem playing encrypted movies  tracy anne | 08/24/07
Re: Ed should test this too  none none | 08/26/07
Will Linux support HD-DVD and Blu ray?  otaddy | 08/26/07
Yes... Either directly and/or indirectly.....  LazLong | 08/26/07
Addendum  LazLong | 08/26/07
A Non-OS package...  Sabz5150 | 08/28/07
Re:Non~OS pkg  LazLong | 08/28/07
LinuxMCE  tracy anne | 08/24/07
Linux alternatives  w_c_mead | 08/27/07
Debatable Success Story  Mikael_z | 08/23/07
It didn't take two weeks to fix  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/23/07
Quoting Ed Bott  Mikael_z | 08/24/07
Try this English.  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
totally and utterly inconceivable  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
I could have done in two days  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
"I tackled small bits of the project over the period of another week"  raycote | 08/24/07
Yes, project  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
the time it takes  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
Oh God grow up....  fr0thy2. | 08/24/07
good one.. i could have never though of that response.  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
I have the same setup without the hassle for over 2 years now  cacoleby@... | 09/24/07
you could make a pretty penny setting this up for ppl  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
Someone beat you to the idea  soonerproud | 08/24/07
"with a high def entertainment center"  Ole Man | 08/24/07
Huh?  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
Well ...  ruped24 | 08/23/07
RE: Well ... Ed, try this out and let us know  ruped24 | 08/23/07
Multimedia Class Scheduler Service  Jhaks | 08/24/07
Right  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
Thought it was deliberate QoS  Patanjali | 08/26/07
Not a problem here  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/23/07
So Typical.  Bozzer | 08/23/07
The question was:  ye | 08/23/07
Because  Bozzer | 08/24/07
And?  ye | 08/24/07
You are mistaken  Jhaks | 08/24/07
those are the typical stages of any issue in life  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
RE: Not a problem here  ruped24 | 08/23/07
... I Knew He Was Going TO Say That happy  TheBoyBailey | 08/24/07
The purpose of this machine  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Can you provide results of your testing of this issue....  mrlinux | 08/24/07
I sent them to Adrian  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
So you are making claims you cant back up with data...  mrlinux | 08/24/07
i just love to get in the middle of a good debate  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
Your experiences are not representitive  soonerproud | 08/24/07
got both  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
Mate, I never said they was  TheBoyBailey | 08/24/07
finally someone that has a clue  krg1975 | 09/18/07
Three letters.. PS3  jparrott@... | 08/23/07
It was $440  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/23/07
Message has been deleted.  nomorems | 08/23/07
You must be smoking a little crack yourself  soonerproud | 08/23/07
compaq and emachines  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
Do you ever have anything useful to add?  James T. Kirk | 08/24/07
No Crack  Webmoron99 | 08/24/07
You are only showing the price of ....  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Living Room  algzdnet | 08/23/07
That's a great idea.  Ben_E | 08/24/07
POLL:  nomorems | 08/23/07
80 million copies of Media Center in market  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/23/07
Hey, MS Bott...heres a clue...post a link if you want to be believed!  nomorems | 08/23/07
Are you just stupid?  mdemuth | 08/23/07
He is not stupid but you are definitely deluded! - NT  raycote | 08/24/07
After you post the link to support your ....  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
You didn't  rapson | 08/24/07
I'll chime in on this...  jparrott@... | 08/23/07
If you've got some facts to support this then...  ye | 08/23/07
what a stupid response  mdsmedia | 08/23/07
A stupid response is one where...  ye | 08/24/07
The facts..  jparrott@... | 08/23/07
Ironic logic (considering you posted that on ZDnet)  Ben_E | 08/24/07
Say What! - NT  raycote | 08/24/07
If you've got some facts to support this then...  ye | 08/24/07
His point is well taken and you've got to know it! - NT  raycote | 08/24/07
He has a reasonable hypothesis but...  ye | 08/24/07
It's at least a sample of 4  Freebird54 | 08/24/07
and my question to you is why buy a media center pc if you don't know how  SO.CAL Guy | 08/23/07
... Duh.... Because users don't have a choice??  TheBoyBailey | 08/24/07
2 cents more!  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
MC Portion Unused...  jparrott@... | 08/24/07
Not having a reason to launch it is quite ....  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
other statements...  jparrott@... | 08/24/07
And you haven't made up yours have you?  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Apple iTV is a joke.  soonerproud | 08/23/07
So you have an appleTV tell us more details? - NT  raycote | 08/24/07
The joke is on you  atomicsupergeek | 08/24/07
Unless...  Ben_E | 08/24/07
Nope, the joke is decidedly on you!  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Other way round?  Ben_E | 08/24/07
You are correct sir.  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Actually, that's not correct  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
I stand corrected! (NT)  Ben_E | 08/25/07
Media Center Software comes with Vista home premium DORK  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
$440 plus  jparrott@... | 08/23/07
60GB hard drive  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/23/07
Why the post is relevant...  jparrott@... | 08/23/07
I was already doing that  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/23/07
Didn't mention that in your post in the quote below...  jparrott@... | 08/23/07
not if he does not want a PS3 or if he does not want to use nero  SO.CAL Guy | 08/23/07
Um.. yeah hesaid that  aep528 | 08/24/07
Ever heard of Tiger Direct.com?  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
Why the heck  Michael Kelly | 08/23/07
He used what he already owned  soonerproud | 08/23/07
..No He Didn't..  TheBoyBailey | 08/24/07
Correct  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
I stand corrected  soonerproud | 08/24/07
"Monster of a PC"?  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Don't forget that the Mac would be cluttered and ugly with messy wires  NonZealot | 08/24/07
Yes, You have made it clear you are only capable about writing about Micro  LazLong | 08/24/07
Do you even have a point?  Scrat | 08/24/07
Me and My Arrow?  LazLong | 08/24/07
Contact ZDNet  soonerproud | 08/24/07
The name of my column is  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Wow Ed....  James T. Kirk | 08/24/07
Yup  Sabz5150 | 08/24/07
The biggest problem with Myth TV is  soonerproud | 08/24/07
No. MythTV's biggest problem right now  Sabz5150 | 08/28/07
Well..... in response.. I guess?  LazLong | 08/28/07
No Linux bloggers?  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/29/07
Message has been deleted.  fr0thy2. | 08/24/07
Message has been deleted.  pcguy777 | 08/24/07
only the PS3 for you  scole3@... | 08/24/07
Read the other comments first  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Dr. Johnson's dog...  Jeremy W | 08/24/07
Flame Suit ON!  supercharlie | 08/24/07
I don't think so  voska | 08/24/07
Sorry, can't resist it!  Ben_E | 08/24/07
My whole point in response on using the PS3  jparrott@... | 08/24/07
Except that the PS3 cannot do some of the functions ....  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Exept there is no need to add in price of other PC  jparrott@... | 08/24/07
No, you don't get it.  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Then your Vista PC is best suited for you...  jparrott@... | 08/24/07
My #1 concern  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
No... I didn't say go get a PS3...  jparrott@... | 08/24/07
Make up your mind, JP  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
PS3 Streaming is cranky at best  tanstaafl99 | 08/24/07
Depends on codecs used....  jparrott@... | 08/24/07
media center takes over your living room,...only!  Linux Geek | 08/24/07
"It won't take over mine"  James T. Kirk | 08/24/07
Wow, Nice Comeback  itanalyst | 08/24/07
Intelligence has nothing to do with it as ....  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Extrapolating too far...  Freebird54 | 08/25/07
See where you've gone wrong?  Ben_E | 08/24/07
Fully DRM'd  rolf.ernst@... | 08/24/07
So are you....  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Linux  rolf.ernst@... | 08/24/07
Think you can play anything you want with Linux?  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
LMCE please  lefty.crupps | 08/24/07
BS  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Possible explanation of the blue screen comment  Ben_E | 08/24/07
I haven't seen the blue screen in years  balsover | 08/24/07
That's becasue  frgough | 08/26/07
Hell would freeze first  jackie40d@... | 08/24/07
Nice!  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Why? You can find better alternatives for everything MS  ITGuy04 | 08/24/07
If you are not willing to try the Microsoft product ...  ShadeTree | 08/24/07
Better/Worse is JUST an opinion nothing more...  fr0thy2. | 08/24/07
Why do you read these blogs  balsover | 08/24/07
Got we don't care  fr0thy2. | 08/24/07
Sorr.. GOT IT - we still don't care...  fr0thy2. | 08/24/07
hey....  xuniL_z | 08/25/07
Fully wired home  rolf.ernst@... | 08/24/07
re: Fully wired home  Ben_E | 08/24/07
Use wireless or  soonerproud | 08/24/07
Why professionally?  Freebird54 | 08/25/07
More Details on the specs?  number1tech | 08/24/07
Follow the original links  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
I've added a follow-up post with full specs and prices  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
Thanks for the article, Ed. It was helpful.  terry flores | 08/24/07
Options.  Ben_E | 08/24/07
Buy OEM  soonerproud | 08/24/07
Why not wait for HDTV  brittonv | 08/24/07
Too expensive, too big  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
DIY not Pre-built  leegee | 08/24/07
Nicely done...pretty slick.  fr0thy2. | 08/24/07
You COULD do that....  spstanley | 08/24/07
Apple TV  soonerproud | 08/24/07
Meaningful functionality  frgough | 08/26/07
Nope, it's not "butt ugly"  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/27/07
Can't resist, either  rolf.ernst@... | 08/24/07
Ed Botts Vista Home Media Center  ddunker | 08/24/07
I asked her the same question  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
WORTHLESS  XweAponX | 08/24/07
Vista MCE Woes -- HELP!!!  Jeff Hayes | 08/24/07
Two things  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Thanks, Ed... Already been through ONE Escalation, though, lol...  Jeff Hayes | 08/24/07
Different escalation group  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
I just don't WANNA HAVE TO REINSTALL VISTA AGAIN!  Jeff Hayes | 08/27/07
Stop whining, please  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/28/07
Want Microsoft to respond quickly to this issue?  johnf76@... | 08/29/07
Except this is about Dell  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 09/01/07
And with a set top box...?  roberto_maietta@... | 08/24/07
Al Gore would be mad that you're not using a Mac. However,  HypnoToad72 | 08/24/07
High-end PC?  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Vista = Waste of Power  PinnacomX | 08/24/07
PS3=Waste of Power  otaddy | 08/24/07
What is this? Story or AD?  Update victim | 08/24/07
It's not a "news article"  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
Did the same with Apple TV  pointzerotwo@... | 08/24/07
Give Ed a break, he writes about Microsoft  otaddy | 08/24/07
Awesome Blog  GeiselS@... | 08/24/07
Like me...  NoFlamesPlz | 08/24/07
Vista Media Center takes over the living room...  Jeremy W | 08/24/07
Great Article  Jhaks | 08/24/07
Loss of sound  william.brunell@... | 08/24/07
Microsoft's latest sales tools  Ole Man | 08/24/07
My Mini Mac don't do all that but a lot of it.  amaref | 08/24/07
One confusing thing  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/24/07
NO  amaref | 08/24/07
Not arguing  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
Sorry you were not arguing but asking  amaref | 08/24/07
Great article Ed!  derekgore | 08/24/07
Elgato  frgough | 08/26/07
Oh goody, another $300 and another box!  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/27/07
Typical  frgough | 08/27/07
"likely costs less"?  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/27/07
Don't forget the extra cables!!  NonZealot | 08/27/07
I forgot  amaref | 08/24/07
Please clarify  Freebird54 | 08/25/07
$50 for a cable?  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
My experiance not so good.  jim@... | 08/25/07
DirecTV  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
Not in HD  brittonv | 08/27/07
You are correct  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/27/07
Finding Nemo  johnfenjackson@... | 08/25/07
Snark without substance  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
sans snark  johnfenjackson@... | 08/27/07
That's better (but only a little)  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/27/07
... still trying ...  johnfenjackson@... | 08/28/07
Thank you!  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/28/07
MCE is great  mtifo@... | 08/25/07
Generally Favorable  fasin8 | 08/25/07
It took TWO weeks to set up.  Alasdair Mckenzie | 08/25/07
Oh good heavens  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/25/07
Old news  real_tt | 08/25/07
Have you seen LinuxMCE? Look out Microsoft  usarcomputertec | 08/25/07
Please justify...  bpolhemus@... | 08/25/07
RE: Please justify...  ruped24 | 08/26/07
I'd rather use something like a Tvix / tomacro  kraterz | 08/26/07
"Streaming media from a remote server"  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/27/07
Number of Inputs?  ceh4702 | 08/27/07
Dubito, ergo cogito, ergo sum  TSGlassey | 08/27/07
All that work and gear  ds5929 | 08/27/07
i am sure that wasn't the reson for the set up,  krg1975 | 09/18/07
i am sure that wasn't the reason for the set up,  krg1975 | 09/18/07
Cheaper, Better, Smaller  wjgrimm | 08/28/07
No HD, no surround sound, limited storage  Ed BottZDNet Moderator | 08/28/07
Cheaper way- no $$ to M$  wjgrimm | 09/04/07
RE: Vista Media Center takes over the living room  viruserZDNet Moderator | 09/04/07
HP Entertainment center does is all, and I've had it 2 years now  cacoleby@... | 09/24/07
I've had the equivalent to Eds setup for 2 years now  cacoleby@... | 09/24/07
sorry  cacoleby@... | 09/24/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Meet Doc

  • Here to help you with your Document Management Needs
  • Doc is an enigma. Born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer, he grew up in various locations in the United States. He’s seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone.
  • To learn more about this mysterious figure check out his blog on ZDNet and his Workspace on TechRepublic. You’ll be glad you did.
  • Produced by
    ZDNet and