On TV.com: Who's Absent From LOST's Final Season?
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

May 11th, 2009

Shame on you, Facebook!

Posted by Dave Greenfield @ 4:08 am

Categories: Social Networking

Tags: Denial, Facebook, Social Networking, Online Communications, Marketing, Advertising & Promotion, Dave Greenfield

How far ought organizations go towards censoring what’s published on their social networks? Here at ZDNet we have pretty stern view on racist language in our comments section and certainly in our articles. That’s not just smart business. It’s just common sense.

Yet as Michael Arlington points out today, Facebook seems to be lacking that sort of common sense. The social network censors photos of lactating mothers, but allows holocaust denial in the spirit of “open discourse.”

Something’s seriously wrong with that sort of view and Dallas attorney, Brian Cuban, is making it a personal crusade to get Facebook to change its way. The attorney has pointed out that as a private business, freedom of speech doesn’t apply. Holocaust denial violates Facebook’s terms of service and should be stopped.

This isn’t about providing an open forum of ideas. Whether it’s Holocaust denial, gay-bashing, or overt racism there are some things that just don’t belong in social discourse. ZDNet is smart enough to realize that. TechCrunch gets it. Let’s hope Facebook wakes up as well.

David GreenfieldDavid Greenfield is the principal in STAnalytics. a global technology-marketing consultancy where he advises enterprises on emerging technologies. See David Greenfield's full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email David Greenfield

Subscribe to Team Think via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 112 Talkback(s)
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!
Don't be so naive as to think the "western
world" is the only place where double standards
exist. If you think that's the case, you're very
uninformed. That's what I love about discussions... (Read the rest)
Posted by: SippyCup Posted on: 09/29/09  (Edited: 09/29/09 @ 05:39) You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
The Double Standards of the Western World  Tech_Explorer786 | 05/11/09
Nonsense  nizuse | 05/11/09
Nonsense?  bilihor | 05/11/09
Try again  nizuse | 05/11/09
What is the freedom of speech then?  Tech_Explorer786 | 05/11/09
Read  nizuse | 05/11/09
omg  TechProsSD | 05/12/09
indeed  shh_shodan | 05/11/09
It's the difference between  macadam | 05/11/09
prejudice  shh_shodan | 05/11/09
Don't press ENTER on each line,  nizuse | 05/11/09
He's not  macadam | 05/11/09
Viewing in Safari  j.m.galvin | 05/11/09
not sure what's wrong  shh_shodan | 05/11/09
chrome  TechProsSD | 05/12/09
OUr government defends freedom of speech  macadam | 05/11/09
freedom of speech  jtiner | 05/11/09
True  macadam | 05/11/09
drawing lines  shh_shodan | 05/11/09
Well said  macadam | 05/11/09
Good argument  Loggies | 05/12/09
our (US) government (OT)  fsjjunkie | 05/12/09
Way off topic: Do you mean the "Truth Commisions" that are...  PollyProteus | 05/21/09
Freedom of speech is not at issue here ...  dkawalec | 05/11/09
the answer  TechProsSD | 05/12/09
Muhammad is not holy  konkreet | 05/12/09
Demons? Satan?  Timothy (TRiG) | 05/13/09
Demons, satan  dhays | 05/14/09
Muhammad is as holy as his followers believe him to be.  Caggles | 05/22/09
For good reason  Caggles | 05/22/09
Free speech for me but not for thee  j.m.galvin | 05/11/09
Limits on Freedom of Speech  Dave GreenfieldZDNet Moderator | 05/11/09
The problem is...  Henrik Moller | 05/11/09
oh please..  TechProsSD | 05/12/09
it's a pathetic thing...  kckn4fun | 05/13/09
It's not the best response  macadam | 05/13/09
Despite the fact that I don't agree...  Caggles | 05/22/09
there should be no limits  Linux Geek | 05/11/09
Irrelevant  j.m.galvin | 05/11/09
The inarticulate beauty of free speech  Timothy (TRiG) | 05/13/09
Re: Limits on Freedom of Speech  jtiner | 05/11/09
memories and adversaries  dhays | 05/14/09
The feeling is irrelevant  superbus | 05/11/09
free speech  dhays | 05/14/09
re: Denying the holocaust...  Loggies | 05/12/09
you hit the nail in the head  Linux Geek | 05/11/09
It?s Not About Free Speech, It?s About Common Decency  JohnMayer | 05/12/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  mr1972 | 05/11/09
Good point  Dave GreenfieldZDNet Moderator | 05/11/09
Clarification  mr1972 | 05/11/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  Dave GreenfieldZDNet Moderator | 05/11/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  klaus2go | 05/11/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  llama13 | 05/11/09
That would be fine  macadam | 05/11/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  tfraymond | 05/11/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  jtiner | 05/11/09
Which one is more likely to get you "stimulated"?  HypnoToad72 | 05/11/09
If by "stimulated" you mean "fired up"  macadam | 05/11/09
Inconsistency  ThePrairiePrankster | 05/11/09
You really want free speech? or not?  techboy_z | 05/11/09
Haven't crossed the line yet happy  Dave GreenfieldZDNet Moderator | 05/11/09
Keeping it to principles  zeblonite | 05/11/09
What does ZDNet consider this:  nizuse | 05/11/09
Prostitute or not?  Dave GreenfieldZDNet Moderator | 05/11/09
Haven't crossed the line yet  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
No, but  macadam | 05/11/09
Free speech  jtiner | 05/11/09
Valid points  macadam | 05/11/09
Re: Valid points  jtiner | 05/11/09
Hmmm  nizuse | 05/11/09
I stand corrected  macadam | 05/11/09
I agree  nizuse | 05/11/09
As a former screamer  macadam | 05/11/09
What Jesus said  cburkitt2 | 05/12/09
Good point  macadam | 05/12/09
What Jesus said  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
Right (sarcasm)  macadam | 05/12/09
Its not Free speech (as in free beer)  Aussie_Troll | 05/11/09
Re: Its not Free speech (as in free beer)  zeblonite | 05/11/09
You are absolutely correct...  jtiner | 05/11/09
selective definition of racism  Loggies | 05/12/09
What?  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
wow, thought police?  JoeMama_z | 05/11/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  dakshinamurti | 05/11/09
Wholeheartedly agree  Roger Ramjet | 05/11/09
Give me a break Stalin!  devlin_X | 05/12/09
What?  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
You start limiting and it will be gone...  devlin_X | 05/13/09
I disagree  underseer@... | 05/12/09
I agree with "I disagree"  Robby! | 05/12/09
Disagree all you want. . .  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
Well Daiv  macadam | 05/12/09
Revisionists at the ready  ftbragg | 05/12/09
Utter Nonsense  hiraghm@... | 05/12/09
Drivel. . .  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
I think you missed the point  macadam | 05/12/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  ftbragg | 05/12/09
HOW TO POST - 101. . .  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  ca1ic0cat | 05/12/09
Only one side of the problem  macadam | 05/12/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  jhand47201 | 05/12/09
Innocuous?. . .  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  dasprem@... | 05/12/09
Shame on you, David Greenfield!  jiagebusen | 05/12/09
Swing and a MISS. . .  Daiv_Skinner | 05/12/09
I agree but ...  macadam | 05/12/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  xrayangiodoc | 05/12/09
Cool....  GudHart | 05/13/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  gunner221 | 05/18/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  sonoffar@... | 05/26/09
Not shame to you FaceBook  sababa9 | 06/05/09
RE: Shame on you, Facebook!  SippyCup | 09/29/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

  • Thought-provoking progressive ideas on diverse topics that intersect with technology, business, and life, and matter to the world at large. Visit SmartPlanet
  • More from IBM
  • Innovate your business' process model, play against the market, compete against others on our scoreboards and WIN! Try INNOV8 2.0: A BPM Simulator
  • Enabling Real-World Business Transformation through IBM Service Management Read the EMA Analyst Report
Click Here