On CBS.com: Exclusive video from MEDIUM
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

July 24th, 2007

Congress and the Feds should clean up their own act

Posted by George Ou @ 10:16 pm

Categories: Desktop, Infrastructure, Security, Technology policy

Tags: Software, Lime Wire, P2P, U.S. Congress, Congressman, George Ou

Every once in a while you’ll get a political hearing on capitol hill where elected Government officials will grand stand and politicize issues that should have nothing to do with politics.  Sandy Berger stole secret documents from the National Archives by shoving them in to his socks so will Congressman Waxman propose a new law against socks?This time it’s Government Reform Committee Chairman Henry Waxman who says he is considering new laws against P2P (Peer to Peer) software citing the possibility that P2P software may compromise National Security and can be used by organized crime.  The problem is that Mr. Waxman hasn’t a clue what he’s talking about and this new round of political grandstanding is absurd.

The Federal Government should clean up their own security act because year after year they get failing or near failing grades.  Mr. Waxman is slamming Lime Wire for producing software that may circumvent Federal Government security, but the real question is why are Federal Government IT departments allowing Federal employees to install Lime Wire or any other piece of software on Government computers?  The mere fact that Government Employees have administrative access to install software on their computers let alone computers with access to sensitive information is absurd.  If you can’t even keep employees from installing Lime Wire, you’re sure as hell not going to prevent them from installing root kits which are infinitely more destructive.

Why pick on Lime Wire?  Sandy Berger stole secret documents from the National Archives by shoving the documents in to his socks so will Congressman Waxman propose a new law against socks?  Will Congressman Waxman call the CEO of Fruit of the Loom to the hearings and grill him about the dangers of socks?  If we’re afraid that Federal Employees with use P2P software to divulge national secrets, shouldn’t we be afraid they’ll use the fax machine too?  Shouldn’t we be more worried about the type of employees we place in to sensitive positions?  While we’re at it, why not make Malware illegal?  Oh yeah, they’re already illegal but that hasn’t stopped them.  The onus is on the IT organization to lock down their end points and network resources so that malicious software doesn’t get in to their infrastructure in the first place.  The onus is on the Government or any organization to lock down their infrastructure from the physical layer to the application layer to the people working for them.

Is Congressman Waxman right about blaming P2P software for National Security?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

George Ou is Technical Director of ZDNet. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 75 Talkback(s)
authoritarian attitude
So you think that belongs to
the "President", eh?

I don't think it belongs to ANYBODY. The
government, all three branches (including
Cheny's fourth branch), is supposed to be a
... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Ole Man Posted on: 07/28/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
I agree  beatphreek | 07/24/07
The socks thing was just something that popped up in my mind  georgeou | 07/24/07
oh and the author forgot  pcguy777 | 07/25/07
Look at what the Fed freaks did when PGP came out  SpaceCowboyNJ | 07/24/07
I remember that  Leria | 07/25/07
Its the Clipper Chip all over again.  Xwindowsjunkie | 07/25/07
Based on your side...  nucrash | 07/25/07
Bet you a Core 2 Quad that...  nucrash | 07/25/07
How Ironic  nucrash | 07/25/07
they were there nutcrash if not in person in spirit  SO.CAL Guy | 07/25/07
I don't doubt this  nucrash | 07/25/07
I don't know what they want. Maybe a few campaign contributions will make  georgeou | 07/25/07
$100 from 1 million  nucrash | 07/25/07
Problem is that $100 from 1 million people will neutralize each other  georgeou | 07/26/07
Another reason to be Libertarian  nucrash | 07/26/07
RE:Campaign contributions...  GreyGeek | 07/26/07
I am not sure that would work.  B.O.F.H. | 07/25/07
Socks  rapson | 07/25/07
And, Fruit of the Loom makes socks?  Anton Philidor | 07/25/07
I believe they do  rapson | 07/25/07
Why blame a company that produced software?  Grayson Peddie | 07/25/07
What the government SHOULD do...  gdstark13 | 07/25/07
Quite true  Leria | 07/25/07
Okay I am sorry but that is just  Linux User 147560 | 07/26/07
Read the Constitution  atasman@... | 07/27/07
How to support the content companies...  Anton Philidor | 07/25/07
"Security" is in the eye of the beholder  gary@... | 07/25/07
gary this is a Democrat witch hunt not a Republican one this time  SO.CAL Guy | 07/25/07
Umm...  rapson | 07/25/07
The good news is...  Anton Philidor | 07/25/07
Waxman  j.m.galvin | 07/25/07
ZDNet filters  j.m.galvin | 07/25/07
a lady of the evening  sackbut | 07/25/07
sackbut to answer you question all politicians do (NT)  SO.CAL Guy | 07/25/07
Precisely why I want to run for politics  nucrash | 07/25/07
That's no lady . . .  critic-at-arms | 07/25/07
Heck, the White House leaks the secrets directly to the press!  WiredGuy | 07/25/07
it was not the whist house it was a staffer get your facts striate (NT)  SO.CAL Guy | 07/25/07
Just a clarification, there was never anything secret about Mrs Wilson  georgeou | 07/25/07
The CIA disagrees with you  WiredGuy | 07/25/07
The special procecutor disagrees with you  georgeou | 07/25/07
Much ad[Ou] about nothing!  wmlundine | 07/25/07
Nobody made you read it, did they?  James T. Kirk | 07/25/07
Is it time for...  wmlundine | 07/25/07
I guess, since you're already here. happy  James T. Kirk | 07/25/07
John E Wahd ???  wmlundine | 07/25/07
DAMN - I am getting MAD HELLLO !!! DUMBO !!!  linux_is_next | 07/25/07
RE: Nobody made you read it, did they?  gdstark13 | 07/25/07
Does anyone know...  wmlundine | 07/25/07
Try an article that isn't a blog  nucrash | 07/25/07
Found one...  wmlundine | 07/25/07
You are dangerous  TripleII | 07/25/07
You're absolutely right, this should be a nonpartison nonfanboy issue  georgeou | 07/25/07
Hey fanb[ou]y...  wmlundine | 07/25/07
"stupidity of the idea ...is newsworthy"  wmlundine | 07/25/07
So who voted he is right?  TripleII | 07/25/07
His staff  critic-at-arms | 07/25/07
LOL, must be right  georgeou | 07/25/07
Dangerous 2%  nucrash | 07/25/07
It is the person, stupid.  phatkat | 07/25/07
screw this guy  swizz216 | 07/25/07
yep  swizz216 | 07/25/07
And yet you contribute nothing  nucrash | 07/25/07
More reasons the government should stay far away from our daily lives  daMan25 | 07/25/07
Why ban socks?  adrenalineaf@... | 07/25/07
Ban Idiot Congressmen  Weldon@... | 07/25/07
This story is totally bias!!!!  zigzag312@... | 07/25/07
Let me guess, you're one of the 2% that voted Waxman is right?  georgeou | 07/25/07
Write what Wrong?  nucrash | 07/25/07
You missed the point  boony | 07/26/07
Wow, this Lib's on something...  nix_hed | 07/26/07
ZigZag, you done Zugged, boy (or girlie)  Ole Man | 07/28/07
Lets Ban Windows, Linux, and Apple  chessmen | 07/26/07
Not Just being Bought Off  lmenningen | 07/26/07
authoritarian attitude  Ole Man | 07/28/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here

Recent Entries

Top Rated

    advertisement

    Archives

    ZDNet Blogs

    White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads