October 24th, 2008
The best way to download photos from your digital camera to computer
With multiple generations of digital cameras in use in my household, memory card readers are our method of choice for downloading photos. I find it much easier to pop the memory card out of a camera and into a card reader than keeping track of all those camera cables. Plus, a card reader makes it easy to drag and drop photos off the memory card and onto any of our computers, Mac or PC.
Of course, not all card readers (or memory cards for that matter) are created equal, but with so many on the market it’s hard to tell which one is best. Fortunately, Canadian photojournalist Rob Galbraith has taken a lot of the guesswork out of the equation by testing the transfer speeds of a number of memory card readers using a slew of memory cards. Check out his database of performance results for SD card readers, which he has tested with 47 different SD cards so far. (He also has a CompactFlash reader database here.)
Based on his benchmark testing, unless you use a 4GB or 8GB SanDisk Extreme III 30MB/s Edition card, you’ll get the fastest transfers with the Lexar Professional UDMA Dual-Slot USB Reader, which will set you back about $50 and includes both an SD card slot and a CompactFlash slot. If you do have one of the 30MB/s SanDisk Extreme III cards, you’ll get the best performance from the SanDisk ImageMate Multi-Card USB 2.0 that’s slated to ship for just $19.99 in November 2008 and was designed for faster throughput with SanDisk’s Extreme III 30MB/s Edition SDHC cards.
Of course, speed isn’t everything. Though it consistently performs slower in Galbraith’s tests, I like the Kingston 19-in-1 Media Reader because it supports–you guessed it–19 different card formats (you can get it for just $13 after a $4 instant rebate from Kingston’s online shop. I also like the short USB cable that tucks away neatly when not in use (and is not detachable and therefore can’t be misplaced) as well as the sliding design that lets you tuck the card slots safely away for storage or travel.
Also check out Galbraith’s excellent CompactFlash/SD Performance Database to find out how fast various memory cards perform using Canon, Nikon and recently-added Sony digital SLRs.
Janice Chen has been covering technology for almost two decades. She got her hands on a Nikon Coolpix 900 back in 1998 and has been a digital camera enthusiast ever since. See her full profile and disclosure of her industry affiliations.
Subscribe to Digital Cameras via Email alerts or RSS.
