On CHOW: Throw parties like a pro
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

March 13th, 2009

Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue

Posted by Andrew Nusca @ 9:25 am

Categories: Apple, Offbeat news

Tags: Apple iPod, Child, Apple Inc., Apple iPod Touch, Cheng, Digital Music, Digital Media, Personal Technology, Consumer Electronics, Andrew Nusca

In another shocking-but-true post by Jacqui Cheng on Ars Technica, the mother of a child in Cincinnati, Ohio is suing Apple and 10 unnamed retail employees from a nearby Apple Store “over an iPod touch that allegedly exploded in the child’s pocket.”

According to the complaint filed yesterday in the Southern District of Ohio (PACER: 1:09-cv-00170-HJW), the child had the “iTouch,” as the suit calls the device, in his pocket during school. The iPod touch was in the “off” position when it unexpectedly popped and caused the child to feel a burning sensation. At that time, he stood up and noticed that his pants were, in fact, on fire.

“Plaintiff A.V. immediately ran to the bathroom and took off his burning pants with the assistance of a friend,” reads the complaint. “On said date and at said time, the Apple iTouch had burned through Plaintiff A.V.’s pants pocket and melted through his nylon/spandex underwear, burning his leg.”

This obviously resulted in hospital bills, the loss of the kid’s clothes and — oh yeah, his iPod touch.

It this a reasonable possibility? Cheng writes that the lowest melting point of nylon is approximately 374 degrees Fahrenheit, but with fire involved, nylon can indeed melt, and an explosion may provide the ability for a device to reach such temperatures before he could notice (and, you know, scream).

The child was declared by a doctor to have received second degree burns to his leg, as well as the physical and mental conditions and distress that comes with the incident.

The plaintiff’s mother says that the family was not warned in advance of the potential risk that the device would cause serious bodily injury, and that Apple’s 10 retail employees had a duty to not only test for this, but also warn customers.

Thus, Apple and co. are accused of gross negligence and recklessness, allegedly conducting themselves maliciously and fraudulently when selling the iPod touch. The mother asking for compensatory damages of more than $75,000 plus punitive damages of more than $75,000 and attorney fees.

Andrew NuscaAndrew J. Nusca is an associate editor for ZDNet and SmartPlanet. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.


Email Andrew NuscaFollow on Twitter

Subscribe to The ToyBox via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 139 Talkback(s)
re: another phony story
Hi-
I was just catching up on my e-mail, I've never e-mailed anyone directly. I'm a lawyer and that story gave me enough information to look the case up on my Westlaw software (which follows cas... (Read the rest)
Posted by: dariced@... Posted on: 04/16/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Not related, probably, can children constantly bullied in schools sue  HypnoToad | 03/13/09
Wii Fit tells 10-year-old she's fat  ejhonda | 03/13/09
Thanks, yet another reason not to buy Apple products  NonZealot | 03/13/09
Yes, of course ...  dkawalec | 03/13/09
Apple never takes responsibility for the damage they cause  NonZealot | 03/13/09
You're delusional and lying again. [nt]  olePigeon | 03/13/09
iPods aren't allowed in school  tobenning@... | 03/16/09
They are in some schools  p0figster | 03/17/09
What they?  ​ | 03/24/09
~  3monkies | 03/26/09
But ..  eMJayy | 03/13/09
If you can't stand the heat . . .  fionncreagh@... | 03/13/09
I prefer this one...  eMJayy | 03/13/09
Where is the grown-up version of this thread?  Power Natto | 03/13/09
Good Riddance  eMJayy | 03/13/09
Toodle-ooo  tikigawd | 03/16/09
Funny. What if one exploded in your child's face?  xuniL_z | 03/13/09
Guffah!  MSFTWorshipper | 03/13/09
You talk like you know me.....  xuniL_z | 03/16/09
 xuniL_z | 03/16/09
What if your child got in a car accident?  dkawalec | 03/13/09
Very bad analogy. Here is what that really says.....  xuniL_z | 03/16/09
Very good analogy. Very odd thinking on your part.  dkawalec | 03/16/09
What if your lack of accurate information blew up in yours?  DeusExMachina | 03/16/09
Oh, let's play name games.  xuniL_z | 03/18/09
..What if...  wolftalamasca | 03/18/09
"The world's an imperfect place ...  dkawalec | 03/13/09
A none-issue?  eMJayy | 03/13/09
Yes, it's a non-story  dkawalec | 03/15/09
"In other words, why should I care? "  MGP2 | 03/15/09
Yet you cared enough ...  dkawalec | 03/15/09
330 million Americans. Guns, including those used by Police, kill 19,000/yr  invmgr@... | 03/16/09
Where Else Has This Happened?  macpipkin | 03/14/09
MSFT zealot  IronMan1968 | 03/16/09
Most expensive compared to what?  DeusExMachina | 03/16/09
Chernobyl, & Space Shuttle Columbia come to mind,  Intellihence | 03/14/09
Re; Columbia  reziol | 03/16/09
NZ: Were you touched by a Mac as a child?  caburlingame | 03/13/09
It's not a party of one, in case you're wondering...  MGP2 | 03/13/09
bridges  caburlingame | 03/13/09
NZ lives up in Canada  jaypeg | 03/14/09
Your title was the only thing correct in your post  NonZealot | 03/15/09
If you are sincere, you will prove it by being even handed  xuniL_z | 03/16/09
Burden of proof  DeusExMachina | 03/16/09
"micro-encephalic malcontent'  Jkirk3279 | 03/17/09
Chastised  DeusExMachina | 03/17/09
Could you please explain one thing.....  xuniL_z | 03/18/09
data are  ​ | 03/24/09
MGP2:  macpipkin | 03/14/09
Another reason?  futuredirected | 03/13/09
o_O  3monkies | 03/16/09
Let's not buy Microsoft...  Arm A. Geddon | 03/13/09
You carry an XBox in your pocket?  NonZealot | 03/13/09
LOL....  MGP2 | 03/13/09
Some people keep Lenovo and Toshiba laptops on their lap...  olePigeon | 03/13/09
Get a PS3  tikigawd | 03/16/09
I wanted to want a PS3  NonZealot | 03/16/09
What the ?  Arm A. Geddon | 03/13/09
Addendum  Arm A. Geddon | 03/13/09
The Battery on my  JLHenry | 03/13/09
I do. Asus & Linux and learn how to use the bloody thing!  HypnoToad | 03/14/09
Ouch  Jkirk3279 | 03/17/09
So I can choose the battery when I buy an Apple product?  NonZealot | 03/17/09
No, we don't need lithium batteries.  ​ | 03/24/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  SystemVoid | 03/13/09
You know who's next?  MGP2 | 03/13/09
WARNING: Wear cotton drawers with our product  JT82 | 03/14/09
Agreed  tikigawd | 03/16/09
Blame the Sandex perhaps...  RicD_ | 03/13/09
Yup, blame the victim, blame ANYONE but don't blame Apple!  NonZealot | 03/13/09
Of Course Blame The Victim  Erroneous | 03/13/09
Yeah, it's the kid's fault . . .  fionncreagh@... | 03/13/09
Sounds like a legit arguement to me!  GameOvR | 03/13/09
I think your saying "blame the victim"  daMan25 | 03/15/09
Actually, you're right...  vulpine@... | 03/13/09
Pathetic or not...  RicD_ | 03/14/09
You blame Apple easy enough with limited or no facts  oncall | 03/14/09
Apple is HOT!  fpayan@... | 03/13/09
And maybe you're an idiot  MGP2 | 03/13/09
Apple products are not so great  Linux Geek | 03/13/09
I've tried Macs hands-on and have read many reviews...  HypnoToad | 03/14/09
Hands-on and Reviews...  vulpine@... | 03/16/09
Counterfeit electronic conponents to blame?  Verical | 03/13/09
Serious problem  fionncreagh@... | 03/13/09
How do you know story is true?  Davewrite | 03/13/09
If it wasn't true they would want more money!  michaelxray | 03/13/09
?  Davewrite | 03/13/09
See my post below this . . .  JLHenry | 03/13/09
the bigger crime  stevenjlindsay@... | 03/14/09
At the bottom of the ARS TECH report . . .  JLHenry | 03/13/09
what does that prove?  Davewrite | 03/13/09
First off . . .  JLHenry | 03/15/09
whether or not = whether or not whether  ​ | 03/24/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  Insight Driver | 03/13/09
So...  MGP2 | 03/13/09
Yup...  vulpine@... | 03/13/09
Reasonable risk  fionncreagh@... | 03/13/09
Why?  vulpine@... | 03/13/09
RE: "shocking but true"  alan.douglas@... | 03/13/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  THavoc | 03/13/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  netzd | 03/13/09
SKINNING your knees . . .  JLHenry | 03/13/09
Put it in your  GSavage777 | 03/13/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  tahoediver@... | 03/13/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  blaze1024 | 03/13/09
By the way how much is being physically scared for life worth nowadays ?  JUKE179r | 04/07/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  smr1106 | 03/13/09
Not the first time an ipod has exploded  eMJayy | 03/13/09
Stop your bickering!  bendib | 03/14/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  Thguns | 03/14/09
Accidents happen  rhon@... | 03/14/09
reasonable  mojorison67@... | 03/14/09
Sue Apple, sure. But the retail employees? D'oh!  Javalon | 03/14/09
Even more embarrassing  Ken_z | 03/14/09
I think . . .  JLHenry | 03/15/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  mojorison67@... | 03/14/09
Uhmmm...  Jkirk3279 | 03/17/09
Fault  mojorison67@... | 03/14/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  rj_wilson@... | 03/16/09
Manufacturer's warranty  michael.tindall@... | 03/16/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  bigtoewossi | 03/16/09
"Apple?s 10 retail employees had a duty to not only test for this"  midenginedrift | 03/16/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  colinmeister | 03/16/09
could happen  ca1ic0cat | 03/16/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  kenmacallister | 03/16/09
Back pocket???  emcee2 | 03/16/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  emcee2 | 03/16/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  vaughanm | 03/16/09
Apple treats its user-base like Weasel-spit  Darryl_Gittins | 03/16/09
Just Stop It  mahlon | 03/16/09
nauseam  ​ | 03/24/09
Uh Oh!  3monkies | 03/26/09
RE: Apple iPod touch sets child's pants on fire; parents sue  Not A Blind Sheep | 03/16/09
Did the small male biped abuse the Ipod?  softwareFlunky | 03/17/09
Not worth the reply but..  xuniL_z | 03/18/09
 xuniL_z | 03/18/09
electical things can catch fire? she should have been warned! Then shot.  shadfurman | 03/19/09
RE: Another phony story  Sophlady | 03/26/09
re: another phony story  dariced@... | 04/16/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

  • Thought-provoking progressive ideas on diverse topics that intersect with technology, business, and life, and matter to the world at large. Visit SmartPlanet
  • More from IBM
  • Innovate your business' process model, play against the market, compete against others on our scoreboards and WIN! Try INNOV8 2.0: A BPM Simulator
  • Enabling Real-World Business Transformation through IBM Service Management Read the EMA Analyst Report
Click Here