On mySimon: Classic V-Neck Cardigans for Fall
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

June 18th, 2009

PC makers are lying to you about battery life

Posted by Andrew Nusca @ 10:16 am

Categories: Computers, Laptops

Tags: Battery, Battery Life, Engineering, Andrew Nusca

…well not exactly, but they’re certainly not giving you an accurate picture of how long it will take for your laptop battery to run down next time you’re using it.

A post on the Bits blog yesterday asks a great question: “Why can’t we get an accurate battery life test for laptops?” In the post, writer Ashlee Vance notes that the very people that are — how should I say this, stretching the truth? — about how long your notebook battery will last under normal use are actually making moves to offer consumers a more accurate rating.

The problem, it seems, is that many manufacturers use the MobileMark 2007 test, which includes “having the screen at just 20 percent brightness, Wi-Fi turned off and no music, video, games or Web pages running.”

Typical real-world usage, right?

(Here’s an indication of how off-the-mark that is in 2009: I’m currently using my laptop at 85% brightness with Wi-Fi on. I’m streaming music from Last.fm in one of three tabs of Safari, have another five tabs of Firefox open and have Microsoft Entourage open to receive mail. All while chatting over IM with ZDNet’s West Coast editor Sam Diaz.)

The plan, according to AMD (whose genial marketing VP Pat Moorhead was interviewed in the post), is to try to develop a dual battery life measure to post on machines: one that reflects MobileMark test results and one that shows battery life under video and gaming duress.

Think of it like mileage for your car: highway and city. (In this scenario, however, the highways are mostly barren.)

The problem, of course, is that it will take years to get all manufacturers on board. And the sniping that Intel and AMD are privvy to (evident in the Times post) won’t help them get any further along, either.

So let’s have ourselves a bit of a poll, shall we?

Post your observed battery life in the comments and a summary of what you’ve typically got running on your system, home or work.

Perhaps if enough people contribute, we’ll get a better sense of how people — ZDNet readers, at least — really use their computers.

Andrew NuscaAndrew J. Nusca is an associate editor for ZDNet and SmartPlanet. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.


Email Andrew NuscaFollow on Twitter

Subscribe to The ToyBox via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 38 Talkback(s)
Reviewers should use a dual battery life measure. To hell with sales hype.
At least the customer can make some kind of informed decision based on repeatable tests.

Sign on ZDNet or be part of the problem.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: softwareFlunky Posted on: 07/15/09  (Edited: 07/15/09 @ 09:47) You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
I get about 30-45 minutes  jdbukis@... | 06/18/09
No wonder, when you have power hungry quad-cores and sli graphics  NeoGeneration | 06/18/09
Newer machines are better  alsoran | 06/21/09
On my Sony Vaio, i get about 5 hours under normal use (nt)  NeoGeneration | 06/18/09
5.5 hours, 5900 mAH battery  Ad Astra | 06/18/09
Now lets go educate users  kitko | 06/18/09
don't use batteries  nospam@... | 06/18/09
PC makers stretching the truth? Never!  terry flores | 06/18/09
I've gotten 2 hours out of my MBA  mlindl | 06/18/09
Toshiba and MSI  Daniel Breslauer | 06/18/09
Laptops suck for battery use - get a netbook  BillDem | 06/18/09
I wholeheartedly agree  Ashtonian | 07/07/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  rdhalsteatzd | 06/18/09
In flight laptop...  3wheelrig | 06/19/09
Inflight Laptop  rdhalsteatzd | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  Linux User 147560 | 06/18/09
It's a tough problem  oldbaritone | 06/19/09
Macbook Pro 15" Unibody (late 2008)  doh123 | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  antonio_castro@... | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  stephenvb | 06/19/09
Alienware M17  masonwheeler | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  Z06Racer | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  3wheelrig | 06/19/09
Yes, we should be using those on our hybrids...  JCitizen | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  jminifie@... | 06/19/09
My Battery life  billyb1122 | 06/19/09
I get about 3.5 hours on my HP 17"..  JCitizen | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  bertie91@... | 06/19/09
New or Old...?  Ashby | 06/19/09
No! Really!  mikifinaz1@... | 06/19/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  sunny.3mysore | 06/20/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  ChaitanyaV | 06/20/09
About 30 mins or so  D2 Ultima | 06/20/09
Whoops...  D2 Ultima | 06/20/09
Buy the RIGHT battery!  SteelTrepid | 06/22/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  wez@... | 07/09/09
RE: PC makers are lying to you about battery life  justlk | 07/13/09
Reviewers should use a dual battery life measure. To hell with sales hype.  softwareFlunky | 07/15/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More