On mySimon: Elvis Robot
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

November 8th, 2006

Why Linux will never go mainstream on the desktop

Posted by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes @ 4:23 am

Categories: Linux, Thoughts

Tags: Desktop, PC, Linux, Microsoft Windows, Operating Systems, UNIX, Open Source, Software, Adrian Kingsley-Hughes

I really didn’t expect the post I wrote last week about Linux (The world just isn’t ready for Linux) to generate the interest that it did.  After all, it was written by someone who’s been using Windows since DOS and who is currently sitting in front of two screens - one with Windows Vista in it, the other running XP Pro.  But the post obviously struck a chord with some people (and a nerve with others).  I also have people offering me copies of nearly every version of Linux imaginable!

I’ve read as many of the comments as time allows (currently the count stands at over 500) and watched the poll results come in (more than 10,500 of you voted - thanks for sharing your thoughts) and I think that the time is right for a follow-up post.

Will Linux ever go mainstream on the desktop?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Ultimately, people are willing to pay for simplicityThe first thing that struck me were the poll results.  Fully 28% of you claim to be running Linux on all your systems while another 50% are planning to increase the number of Linux systems you run.  Those are incredible numbers but I think that they have more to do with the type of audience that the post drew, rather than being representative of the kind of growth in users that Linux is going to experience over the next 12 months (although I expect that someone will use the data to say just that).  Currently the desktop Linux user base stands at about 1% (the figure varies wildly depending on what source you look at), so if 28% of you are already running Linux then that means that the readership here is made up of a large number of users that fall into that 1% user base. 

Some of the comments made in response to the post I made were very interesting too, and some of the points are worth picking up on.  The rest of this post consists of my thoughts and feeling about some of the issues raised.  Before I do that though, I just want to share with you the best TalkBack entry I read.  It was posted by Uranus65:

Dude, here’s my prediction: Now that you have decided to use Linux to some extent, you will become obsessed. Some days you will throw your arms up and say your done with it. But you will be back, spending hours trying to burn a CD or something. We’ve all been there before and we are still here, using Linux.

:-)

Next page –>

Pages: 1 2 3 4

Adrian Kingsley-HughesAdrian is a technology journalist and author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology. He also runs a popular blog called The PC Doctor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations

Want to get in touch? Got a tip? Feel free to drop me a note! I ALWAYS respect anonymity. I'm also on Twitter (@the_pc_doc)

Right to Reply: Should any industry representatives wish to comment on any posts on Hardware 2.0, I will be happy to publish their reply verbatim on this blog.

Subscribe to Hardware 2.0 via Email alerts or RSS.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 261 Talkback(s)
RE: Why Linux will never go mainstream on the desktop
I put the Windows XP CD in and all I get is a crash. At work, we installed Windows XP Pro x64 on an older machine, and it REQUIRED us to insert a floppy disk with drivers for our Intel SATA controlle... (Read the rest)
Posted by: jbo5112 Posted on: 12/29/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Narrow scope  Yagotta B. Kidding | 11/08/06
Footnote [1]  Yagotta B. Kidding | 11/08/06
Not quite correct  Confused by religion | 11/08/06
Details, Milly  Yagotta B. Kidding | 11/08/06
I don't believe that a crackdown on piracy will help Linux  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 11/08/06
Windows is pirated because it is the de-facto standard and it is all they  DonnieBoy | 11/08/06
You answered your own question.  A_Pickle | 11/10/06
Relative pricing  Yagotta B. Kidding | 11/08/06
Relative costs  Anton Philidor | 11/08/06
Why bother with an alternative to Windows?  Anton Philidor | 11/08/06
Good point  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 11/08/06
Software on the shelf  A.Sinic | 11/08/06
Re: Software on the shelf  Linux User 1 | 11/08/06
What do you mean? COULD  andypiesse@... | 11/10/06
But not everywhere  Jxn | 11/11/06
You ignore the growing anti-american environment world wide. Also do not  DonnieBoy | 11/08/06
DonnieBoy, you live in a  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
He's right on the Anti-Americanism  j.m.galvin | 11/08/06
Jealoucy will always be a factor.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
It isn't Jealousy, No-Facts-To-Grind  Castanet | 11/11/06
So much for "interdependence"  Mark Miller | 11/12/06
Resignation  Yagotta B. Kidding | 11/08/06
Reactions to operating systems.  Anton Philidor | 11/08/06
Reputation vs Mindshare  enduser_z | 11/08/06
imho  Badgered | 11/08/06
Server AND desktop  Jxn | 11/11/06
This really is it.  enduser_z | 11/08/06
Because  Richard Flude | 11/08/06
Accepting.  Anton Philidor | 11/08/06
Hmmm, not quite correct.  maldain | 11/10/06
Not just home systems  kamensk | 11/10/06
Matter of Perspective.  LazLong | 11/10/06
Why Linux will never go mainstream on the desktop  rfennimore@... | 11/08/06
Fixed in Vista  A.Sinic | 11/08/06
But broken in most (all?) MS Windows XP and older  Jxn | 11/11/06
Why Linux will never go mainstream on the desktop  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
But Security is about education!  mustang_z | 11/10/06
Wait for it............  XJRider | 11/08/06
People dont want Windows  A.Sinic | 11/08/06
There is no need to GPL on software running in Linux  Jxn | 11/11/06
I want Windows, I do!  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
You are ironic, arn't you?  Jxn | 11/11/06
The vast majority of workers only need browser, email, basic word  DonnieBoy | 11/08/06
Bogus argument.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
Exactly. (NT)  James T. Kirk | 11/08/06
Bogus argument...  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
GnuCash vs. Quicken  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
Umm....NO  Darkgeek | 11/10/06
In that case  pkrdk | 11/12/06
Again...  Badgered | 11/08/06
Just curious,  swoopee | 11/08/06
Again...  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
A two tier structure means people at the bottom have a barrier to job devel  stevey_d | 11/08/06
Joe public has little need to know about  swoopee | 11/08/06
in turnkey applications sure this works but  stevey_d | 11/09/06
All True... But  Code Poet | 11/08/06
It's changing, but not how you would like it to  John Zern | 11/09/06
vast majority of workers only need browser, email, basic word  gmortensensprint@... | 11/10/06
In that case  pkrdk | 11/12/06
It will happen...  Jim888 | 11/08/06
When applications are developed  Linux User 1 | 11/08/06
Already...  mustang_z | 11/10/06
Not Any Time Soon...  IT_Guy_z | 11/08/06
On if the solutions was a boxed set  Linux User 1 | 11/08/06
Let's say Linux were perfected...  Anton Philidor | 11/08/06
Scary.  enduser_z | 11/08/06
Well hardware and software are both important!  mustang_z | 11/10/06
I can see the point - just do not agree.  Jim888 | 11/08/06
I agree, but for other reasons  Tyler_Durden | 11/08/06
Apple's problem  DarthRidiculous | 11/08/06
Yep.  A_Pickle | 11/10/06
Much better article  TripleII | 11/08/06
Oh yeah, DRM  TripleII | 11/08/06
Who needs it....  petteyg359 | 11/10/06
If I changed today, what would I get?  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
Snort ....  Linux_4u! | 11/08/06
Wow, what a well thought out and articulated responce.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
Ax, Ax, Ax.....  James T. Kirk | 11/08/06
I think you missed the point  Badgered | 11/08/06
Where are you taking classes?  B.O.F.H. | 11/08/06
Message has been deleted.  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
Message has been deleted.  B.O.F.H. | 11/08/06
There are advantages...  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
Mmm ...  fredsmith6 | 11/10/06
It depends on what you want  Patrick Jones | 11/08/06
You make my point nicely  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
Almost  Patrick Jones | 11/08/06
So then the question is still  No_Ax_to_Grind | 11/08/06
True  Patrick Jones | 11/08/06
Support Red Herring  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
Missing the point  pkrdk | 11/08/06
WGA, Activation, etc.  Spikey_Mike | 11/09/06
Re: Almost  Linux User 1 | 11/08/06
Get...  todbran@... | 11/10/06
You would waste $$$$$$$$$  Zolar | 11/10/06
So Linux isn't for them...  TripleII | 11/10/06
Kontact, Konquor, GnuCash, sounds so geeky  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
Too used to them  TripleII | 11/11/06
Linux'll never go mainstream  mtsharp | 11/08/06
The only way is if they stop being "Us too!"  Steve Summers | 11/08/06
Actually,  Patrick Jones | 11/08/06
Actually Steve there are more...  Linux User 147560 | 11/08/06
More file systems. Wow.  Steve Summers | 11/08/06
Never say Never.  teddybairs1 | 11/08/06
Only with collusion  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
Adrian,  tombalablomba | 11/08/06
BTW  tombalablomba | 11/08/06
tombalablomba  D-T-Schmitz | 11/08/06
_dietrich  tombalablomba | 11/08/06
I dont agree with everything you have to say  zzz1234567890 | 11/08/06
File storage  jshaw4343 | 11/08/06
Exactly  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
No one ever said...  Henry Miller | 11/08/06
Never say never ...  George Mitchell | 11/08/06
PS3  30otsix | 11/08/06
so you can put a faster processor or  Joeman57 | 11/08/06
Unknown how modular it is and it doesnt matter anyway.  Jim888 | 11/08/06
Linux and the demise of MSFT  kevinclosson | 11/08/06
My Story  vsenso@... | 11/08/06
A tale from real life  pkrdk | 11/12/06
Another tale from real life...  Dreamer.fithp | 11/12/06
Both of your are Right  tuqui | 11/12/06
I agree, games aren't going away for PCs.  CobraA1 | 11/08/06
Complex games are only for the PC  TonyMcS | 11/08/06
Why "never" is meaningless...  jasonp@... | 11/08/06
Adrian: NEVER say Never  D-T-Schmitz | 11/08/06
Currently the desktop Linux user base stands at about 1%  swoopee | 11/08/06
I have a dream...  Tyler_Durden | 11/08/06
Linux is too hard...........  XJRider | 11/08/06
'The hard drive is missing...  pkrdk | 11/09/06
I agree with you  jackie40d@... | 11/10/06
Good Bookeeping System????  tomcotexas@... | 11/12/06
Book Keeping...........  XJRider | 11/13/06
Stick with windows then  XJRider | 11/13/06
Linux will never go mainstream...  bportlock | 11/08/06
Linux may go mainstream  mdemuth | 11/08/06
If they're so smart....  bportlock | 11/09/06
No, because Linux users are arrogant and foolish  Zuel | 11/09/06
Command line?  bportlock | 11/09/06
arrogant  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
You've obviously never uesd Linux applications.  petteyg359 | 11/10/06
I have and was underwhelmed....  PJ29 | 11/10/06
That cuts both ways  avajadi | 11/12/06
hahaha ! I agree  jackie40d@... | 11/10/06
Linux desktop in a nutshell  pabranchaud@... | 11/08/06
A newbie  mjk1971 | 11/08/06
What Linux Distro?  D-T-Schmitz | 11/08/06
We all were once  TripleII | 11/08/06
Oops, dv8000z no 800z  TripleII | 11/08/06
And now, a brief commercial from our sponsors...  D-T-Schmitz | 11/08/06
Nice picture  pkrdk | 11/08/06
Linux recently went mainstream on my desktop PC  geneven | 11/08/06
Help Barriers  TucsonGuy | 11/08/06
denial  Stan_Krute | 11/09/06
Barriers? Obstacles?  LazLong | 11/09/06
it's the whole ecosystem  alpha_server | 11/10/06
Agreed?.  LazLong | 11/11/06
Ubuntu  alpha_server | 11/12/06
This subject is a lightning rod for fanboys of both religions  BeGoneFool | 11/08/06
Uninformed  zetetic | 11/08/06
As long as they don't write adware...  epcraig | 11/08/06
Enough with OS cheerleaders!  TerryNT | 11/08/06
You just don't get it.  bjb1959 | 11/08/06
OpenSuse 10.2 is the answer  Arabian | 11/09/06
It never ceases to amaze me  davidsarmstrong | 11/09/06
Missing a button on the poll  russofris | 11/09/06
Please go throught this site this should help you more regarding the linux  arbind | 11/09/06
Funny  navinsylvester | 11/09/06
Cars and Taxes  Brent R Brian | 11/09/06
Adrian is a "technology" author :-P  navinsylvester | 11/09/06
Linux is more secure than Windows  tuqui | 11/09/06
Audience relevance....  techboy_z | 11/09/06
Agree with the Author  Right_Hand_of_god | 11/09/06
Because they can, and it's fun  TripleII | 11/09/06
Good rant..wrong conclusion, though  TtfnJohn | 11/11/06
GEEKS will never let LINUX go MAINSTREAM  rh0 | 11/09/06
You've never used it have you  TripleII | 11/09/06
Perhaps happy  Right_Hand_of_god | 11/09/06
Opps - Wrong Place  Right_Hand_of_god | 11/09/06
Live CDs are great  TripleII | 11/09/06
Add Ubuntu/Kubuntu to that  goyta | 11/10/06
The Computer is the key  carlino | 11/09/06
The success of anything in life  mrjonno | 11/10/06
Never say Never!  dacap06@... | 11/10/06
Why Linux Will Not Become the Next Windows Replacement  Evisscerator | 11/10/06
You really haven't seen the distros in the  pberry26@... | 11/10/06
obscene language  macbill | 11/10/06
But, language evolves!  pberry26@... | 11/10/06
History  MistDaemon | 11/10/06
That's it, I've had enough of your writing, now I remember why I hate ZDNET  rhasselbrink@... | 11/10/06
Have you tried...  rhasselbrink@... | 11/10/06
Biggest problem with Linux is the mindset of the community  Langalibalene | 11/10/06
Good point, now you just need to write something...  rhasselbrink@... | 11/10/06
Not everyone wants to be a developer  Mark Miller | 11/12/06
Not everyone wants to use Linux  rhasselbrink@... | 11/13/06
I agree with the author  barracudaguy@... | 11/13/06
The topic of the article was...  Mark Miller | 11/15/06
Hardware support  mackerel | 11/10/06
The 64-bit conundrum  goyta | 11/10/06
P.S.  goyta | 11/10/06
Get a Die hard windows user and you get  jackie40d@... | 11/10/06
Lack of apps  wjgrimm | 11/10/06
Actually, a wealth of apps  TripleII | 11/10/06
this article is so 8 years ago  rm9999 | 11/10/06
bean counting at home and work  alan.m@... | 11/10/06
Which one you can't do without  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
I am the mainstream  Zanymuse2@... | 11/10/06
Will Linux be able to give me what I need?  TripleII | 11/10/06
information I can use!  Zanymuse2@... | 11/10/06
I Am Mainstream - Reply From Linux Convert  The Rifleman | 11/13/06
Actually you could have probably  Linux User 147560 | 11/14/06
Linux  novice_1 | 11/10/06
No secrets, actually,  pberry26@... | 11/10/06
typical response from the linux crowd  novice_1 | 11/12/06
Linux/Microsoft  marianne.popp@... | 11/10/06
What's the point?  code_flogger | 11/10/06
Right on  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
Apples to apples  code_flogger | 11/11/06
China - the 1,000 pound gorilla  artworks12 | 11/10/06
Dream on  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
So you want simplicity?.?.?  jreidthompson | 11/10/06
Will desktop linux ever go mainstream.  danm50 | 11/10/06
Slam Dunk  TN-Limey | 11/10/06
New User's Opinion  fondy | 11/10/06
Windows Philosophy  BlueLancer | 11/10/06
Who was it who said, "thats the stupidest thing I have ever heard"?  WinnebagoBoy | 11/10/06
Mainstream was 40 years ago...and now  ClaudeRenaud | 11/10/06
Linux will make the desktop and this is why.  moffett.john@... | 11/10/06
They just don't get it!!!  pberry26@... | 11/10/06
Interesting thoughts but you give yourself away  hoiatl | 11/10/06
Impressions from a 3rd-World half-geek who uses both  goyta | 11/10/06
Better done than the original article  xf10036@... | 11/10/06
I Disagree with your assessment of Apps....  LazLong | 11/10/06
user freindly Linux  gregzdnet | 11/10/06
"Hardware support" is apples and oranges...  handydan918 | 11/10/06
With standards and 95%+ commercial driver/app support yes  jimk_z | 11/10/06
Of course you are right.  ukstar@... | 11/11/06
What's wrong with Linux  richard@... | 11/11/06
Ubuntu  simanek | 11/13/06
What's wrong with Linux  richard@... | 11/11/06
The real reason  plumnilly | 11/11/06
But you can't fix XPPro or Vista!  Embedded_z | 11/11/06
Linux project does not have the Mozilla focus  Mark Miller | 11/12/06
Excellent post  novice_1 | 11/12/06
Linux issues hit power users first  avajadi | 11/12/06
linux  joemo692000@... | 11/12/06
It's all about the money  Fujikid2 | 11/12/06
Price is established  novice_1 | 11/12/06
O/S support for lazy People  k.kraaij@... | 11/13/06
Why will linux go mainstreem  simanek | 11/13/06
Why will linux go mainstream  simanek | 11/13/06
No DESKTOP Linux will not ...  mwagner@... | 11/13/06
Ubuntu is already better than Win XP Pro  DigitalCode | 11/14/06
Re: Linux on the Desktop  smdeep | 11/15/06
hardware isn't a problem  Bushta | 11/16/06
Linux will become widely accepted on the desktop  randall.shimizu@... | 11/17/06
The Very Long Term Viability of Microsoft is questionable  wwm1234 | 11/19/06
people pay for simplicity? Maybe, maybe not...  patibulo | 11/19/06
Microsoft owns Linux now  IronCladChicken | 11/20/06
Microsoft Won't Do That?  xademosx@... | 02/03/07
RE: Why Linux will never go mainstream on the desktop  jbo5112 | 12/29/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here