On The Insider: Celebs in Miami for the Super Bowl
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

April 4th, 2008

Friday Rant: Let XP die!

Posted by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes @ 11:34 am

Categories: Friday Rant, Microsoft

Tags: Microsoft Windows Vista, Microsoft Windows XP, Operating Systems, Microsoft Windows, Software, Adrian Kingsley-Hughes

So, Microsoft has set the XP cut off dateJune 30, 2008. That’s fine with me. It’s time for XP to die.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s not that I didn’t like XP, but that time has passed.  Long passed.  The last few XP installs that I’ve carried out have shown me how painful the process is compared to Vista.  First, the install process demands that you stand around the system for an extended period of time to answer a variety of questions.  With Vista the process has been cut down to a few choices at the beginning of the installations process and afterwards I can walk away and leave it to finish on its own.  Then there’s finding all the necessary drivers.  A system that needs me to find half a dozen or so drivers with XP installed doesn’t need any with Vista.  That’s a hassle I’m happy not to have any more

Also, as I increasingly move over from 32-bit to 64-bit, with Vista I finally have a 64-bit platform that works reliably and allows me to break the 4GB barrier without having to suffer much in the way of downsides.  XP Pro 64-bit couldn’t deliver me that no matter how often I tried.

It seems that XP has, over the years, collected a pretty big fan club.  I guess that’s understandable given how long XP has been around, but all this “Save XP” stuff is starting to sound like little more than a few people howling at the moon.   It’s not as if these people haven’t had clear notice that Vista is on the way in and XP is on the way out.  How long do they realistically think Microsoft should offer XP?  Another six months?  A year?  Two years?  Indefinitely?  Folks, it’s time to let it go and move on.

Maybe SP3 will rejuvenate XP a bit, maybe it won’t.  Either way, I doubt that the service pack will change the fact that XP is long in the tooth on a number of fronts.  It’s time for me to put my XP CDs into the drawer of doom.

Is it time for XP to die?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Thoughts?

Adrian Kingsley-HughesAdrian is a technology journalist and author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology. He also runs a popular blog called The PC Doctor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations

Want to get in touch? Got a tip? Feel free to drop me a note! I ALWAYS respect anonymity. I'm also on Twitter (@the_pc_doc)

Right to Reply: Should any industry representatives wish to comment on any posts on Hardware 2.0, I will be happy to publish their reply verbatim on this blog.

Subscribe to Hardware 2.0 via Email alerts or RSS.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 129 Talkback(s)
Message has been deleted.
(Read the rest)
Posted by: junkmail93@... Posted on: 04/08/08  (Edited: 04/09/08 @ 06:19) You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
I don't see any need to upgrade or downgrade  Michael Kelly | 04/04/08
It's time for Microsoft to die  fr0thy2 | 04/04/08
yes,  rtk | 04/04/08
or Fr0thy2(nt)  ShadeTree | 04/04/08
That's a Universal Constant  Wolfie2K3 | 04/07/08
well thank God a politician agrees  marks055@... | 04/05/08
fr0thy2 don't you go play with your mac.  SO.CAL Guy | 04/07/08
Nothing wrong with DOS or Windows 3 either (nt)  CobraA1 | 04/04/08
That is true, but...  gene_fitz@... | 04/05/08
XP's Murder, Vista's Suicide  Harry Bardal | 04/04/08
Yup, the age of protectionism ..  fr0thy2 | 04/04/08
fr0thy2 from readin your post you have no "IT" knowledge  SO.CAL Guy | 04/07/08
Eloquent troll alert.  James T. Kirk | 04/04/08
switchers  rtk | 04/04/08
RE: switchers  Axsimulate | 04/04/08
Which makes him different  mdemuth | 04/04/08
Re: Switchers.  Arm A. Geddon | 04/04/08
and I agree  rtk | 04/04/08
What 5 reasons??  wackoae | 04/05/08
ummm.  rtk | 04/05/08
Umm...  msalzberg | 04/05/08
edit and replace Macs with Windows  rtk | 04/05/08
You seem be confusing ..  msalzberg | 04/06/08
Wow, what a mistake on my part!!!  msalzberg | 04/06/08
Anecdotes  Harry Bardal | 04/06/08
If you actually look at the trends.  ShadeTree | 04/04/08
...  Linux User 147560 | 04/05/08
what is it supposed to show?  rtk | 04/05/08
Inquiring minds wanna know..  Wolfie2K3 | 04/07/08
The Truth About Cannibalization  Harry Bardal | 04/06/08
do you have a point?  marks055@... | 04/05/08
The Point  Harry Bardal | 04/06/08
Harry... Harry... Harry... Put the crack pipe DOWN...!  Wolfie2K3 | 04/07/08
Who Cares...  wuboyblue | 04/06/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  none none | 04/04/08
What is it with you people?  ye | 04/04/08
Re: What is it with you people?  none none | 04/04/08
They have a modern OS. It's called "WIndows XP"  ye | 04/04/08
Re: They have a modern OS. It's called "WIndows XP"  none none | 04/04/08
Who knows?  ye | 04/04/08
Re: Who knows?  none none | 04/04/08
@none none: How so?  ye | 04/04/08
enough  none none | 04/04/08
Will XP run IE8?  laura.b | 04/04/08
As a matter of fact...  Wolfie2K3 | 04/07/08
just curious  marks055@... | 04/05/08
...  Linux User 147560 | 04/04/08
Which modern OS would that be? Some stripped down...  ye | 04/04/08
...  Linux User 147560 | 04/05/08
Facts are facts  Johnny Vegas | 04/04/08
Ah yes  fr0thy2 | 04/04/08
Re: Facts are facts  none none | 04/04/08
We can make an educated guess. Which leaves out...  ye | 04/04/08
Re: We can make an educated guess. Which leaves out...  none none | 04/04/08
I was talking about Linux users  ye | 04/04/08
Enough  none none | 04/04/08
Well, you do not know much about most Linux users  nilotpal_c | 04/05/08
good point  marks055@... | 04/05/08
Vista installs  bportlock | 04/04/08
re: Vista installs  fr0thy2 | 04/04/08
RE: Vista installs  Axsimulate | 04/04/08
Sounds like...  awasson@... | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  redtrain65 | 04/04/08
Office  laura.b | 04/04/08
RE: Office  Axsimulate | 04/04/08
10 minute learning curve ... don't make us laugh  wackoae | 04/05/08
10 minute learning curve ... don't make us laugh  Narg | 04/07/08
Totally not my fault  laura.b | 04/07/08
10 minute learning curve  marks055@... | 04/05/08
Office dislikes  DannyO_0x98 | 04/05/08
just as a side note...  thx-1138_@... | 04/08/08
I did not like Office 07 either....  BroGnorik | 04/04/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  Quebec-french | 04/04/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  jfp | 04/04/08
Re drivers et al  Rick_R | 04/04/08
And that as been my problem with Linux  BroGnorik | 04/04/08
So I see you don't believe...  bjbrock | 04/04/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!...but not yet  fakejake3 | 04/04/08
Drop Vista and wait for 7.  nix_hed | 04/04/08
Yeah right  gene_fitz@... | 04/05/08
Dropping Vista...  fakejake3 | 04/05/08
You're absolutely right on the money!  awasson@... | 04/07/08
Agreed  Eapache | 04/04/08
Vista SP1  gene_fitz@... | 04/05/08
De-Vista'd laptop says it all for me...  nix_hed | 04/04/08
Your laptop is broken  gene_fitz@... | 04/05/08
...  Linux User 147560 | 04/05/08
....  rtk | 04/05/08
I don't know whats wrong with your laptop  marks055@... | 04/06/08
Just curious....  MGP2 | 04/04/08
Sorry Adrian, Many Corporations And Educational Institutions Will Disagree  itanalyst2@... | 04/04/08
What are you talking about?  gene_fitz@... | 04/05/08
Nope. They'll skip Vista...  awasson@... | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  supra5mge | 04/04/08
Kill XP  jorjitop | 04/04/08
It's alright for you to say...  flobber238 | 04/05/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  claymann39@... | 04/05/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  claymann39@... | 04/05/08
it's one thign to rant and troll  rtk | 04/05/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  Joe Dufflebag | 04/07/08
Solution must fit the need!  terry flores | 04/05/08
My guess  rtk | 04/05/08
Glad to hear someone have the guts to say it  marks055@... | 04/05/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  junkmail93@... | 04/05/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  bwhudgins | 04/06/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  danielarbib | 04/06/08
Viva La Linux  nucrash | 04/07/08
Vista is an advancement on Linux? ...Really?  awasson@... | 04/07/08
Also EeePC users...  agohige | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  ddigennaro@... | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  GuidoMuldoon | 04/07/08
XP's painful install  deano-zdnet@... | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  tim_seabrook@... | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  cne@... | 04/07/08
Kind of Agree...  agohige | 04/07/08
Vista is just better, but folks don't like change...  Narg | 04/07/08
Don't like to change?  agohige | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  e.fiesel@... | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  agohige | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  stephen_throop | 04/07/08
Open Source Windows.  Krish4479 | 04/07/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die! NO WAY SP3 ALL THE WAY  dogrun7@... | 04/08/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die! NO WAY SP3 ALL THE WAY . HELL NO  dogrun7@... | 04/08/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  thx-1138_@... | 04/08/08
Hey smart guy- do you want to buy me Vista?  m38817@... | 04/08/08
Probably not.  rtk | 04/08/08
RE: Friday Rant: Let XP die!  detims | 04/08/08
No Let XP Die! XP still work - Vista Just Suck!  drprodny | 04/08/08
Message has been deleted.  junkmail93@... | 04/08/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads