On mySimon: Toothbrush Sanitizer
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

April 23rd, 2008

Why I won't be buying a "Hackint0sh" system

Posted by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes @ 10:53 am

Categories: Thoughts

Tags: Apple Macintosh, Apple Inc., Hackint0sh, Psystar, Apple Mac OS, Apple Mac OS X, Operating Systems, Desktops, Software, Hardware

A few people have been asking me why I’ve not gone to the Psystar website, whipped out my wallet, blown the moths out of it and bought myself an OpenComputer. Well, here’s why …

The idea seems to be that if I slap down my cash and buy one, and I actually get it, and when I get it, the system actually runs Mac OS X like a Swiss watch, I’ve proved both that the company actually intends to ship systems, and that those systems are actually capable of running Mac OS X. Case closed.

Not so fast there Sherlock. Personally, I don’t think it would prove a damn thing. First off, I’ve never once claimed that Psystar is a fake or hoax company, or that it doesn’t have any intentions of shipping systems.

Secondly, there’s a good chance that the system will run Mac OS X just like it says it will on the box. It’s not as though Psystar came up with the idea of the Hackint0sh. If you want a PC that will run Mac OS X, you don’t have to or need to go to Psystar. You can do it yourself. Google is your friend. There’s no magic to it. It’s not easy, but that doesn’t stop people from doing it.

Another reason why I’m not interested in a Hackint0sh is that I’ve no intentions of getting caught up in the crossfire between Apple and Psystar. In much the same way that Apple updates bricked unlocked iPhones, I expect Apple to tweak the Mac OS X code so it breaks the EFI V8 emulation and that’s then going to be a problem not just for Psystar and its customers, but for everyone running a Hackint0sh. Sure, Apple won’t be able to prevent Hackint0sh, but it can make life difficult for owners. Also, let’s not forget that Psystar is making commercial use of the EFI V8 emulator, a move that violates the latest license agreement.

But there’s another reason why I’m not buying a hackint0sh, and that’s because the system is nothing more than a science experiment and I already have enough science experiments going. I’ve already got a Mac and at the moment I don’t really need another, especially not one that could need a lot of hand-holding in the future.

Thoughts?

Adrian Kingsley-HughesAdrian is a technology journalist and author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology. He also runs a popular blog called The PC Doctor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations

Want to get in touch? Got a tip? Feel free to drop me a note! I ALWAYS respect anonymity. I'm also on Twitter (@the_pc_doc)

Right to Reply: Should any industry representatives wish to comment on any posts on Hardware 2.0, I will be happy to publish their reply verbatim on this blog.

Subscribe to Hardware 2.0 via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 137 Talkback(s)
break
? (Read the rest)
Posted by: ylysdexia Posted on: 04/27/08 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Agreed  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
Convicted Criminal  lantzn | 04/23/08
How long do you guys intend to beat this horse? (nt)  ye | 04/23/08
Where do you get that?  DemonX | 04/23/08
So since a company...  tikigawd | 04/23/08
Not criminal - "moral" may be a different matter  fairportfan | 04/23/08
Actually...  tikigawd | 04/23/08
Ok.. everybody call the MOD police  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
Are you a lawyer?  msalzberg | 04/23/08
Holiday Inn Express  jmcabee66@... | 04/23/08
You don't need to be a lawyer  tikigawd | 04/23/08
@tikigawd...  msalzberg | 04/24/08
And suddenly you're an authority on me  tikigawd | 04/24/08
Bogus argument, logical fallacy  bmerc | 04/24/08
Technically....  Michael Kelly | 04/23/08
There's no denying they are a convicted monopolist.  ye | 04/23/08
Trust doesn't get rebuilt overnight  Michael Kelly | 04/23/08
It's been 10 years. Is that your idea of overnight? (nt)  ye | 04/23/08
And in those 10 years  Michael Kelly | 04/23/08
Oops...didn't know who I was responding to. (nt)  ye | 04/23/08
Huh?  BitTwiddler | 04/23/08
You missed his point  cslycord@... | 04/23/08
ah... so your a philosopher now  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
Great, another idiot putting stupid restrictions  bmerc | 04/24/08
Erm...  Spiritusindomit@... | 04/23/08
Message has been deleted.  cmjrees | 04/24/08
Apple is Criminal?  netzd | 04/23/08
I don't know about "Criminal"...  fairportfan | 04/23/08
And..  msalzberg | 04/24/08
Not entirely true...  Wolfie2K3 | 04/24/08
The only place you can get..  msalzberg | 04/24/08
Market?  questionsall | 04/24/08
Having a monopoly isn't criminal.  ajole | 04/23/08
It's all well and good - EXCEPT...  Wolfie2K3 | 04/24/08
I think he meant ...  msalzberg | 04/24/08
mac clone  warpuck@... | 04/25/08
Most people don't buy until 3.0  Michael Kelly | 04/23/08
How Soon We Forget  david@... | 04/23/08
Where there's a will, there's a way  Michael Kelly | 04/23/08
You use our OS and we keep crashing your system.  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
I think its you who may be forgetting somthing?  cornpie | 04/24/08
What are you doing with your Mac?  ye | 04/23/08
Should Be Clear  Harry Bardal | 04/23/08
The flaw in your logic:  GuidingLight | 04/23/08
In Seattle here i know maybe 1 Apple tech  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
Did you intent to respond to someone else?  ye | 04/23/08
I'm sure it's in there  Badgered | 04/23/08
That said...  Taz_z | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  chris.srt@... | 04/23/08
And just what is it, that a MAC really does?  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
HOW DARE YOU ASK SUCH AN IMPERTINENT QUESTION?!?!?  Wolfie2K3 | 04/24/08
google.com/search?q=site:zdnet.com+Version-History  ylysdexia | 04/27/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  garbski | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a Mac Clone  mwagner@... | 04/23/08
Apple is one of the 'good guys' thats the biggest joke i've ever  SO.CAL Guy | 04/23/08
Excellent logic  tikigawd | 04/23/08
Apple is != they  ylysdexia | 04/27/08
You Bad Bad guys!  Mectron | 04/23/08
Mectron is a bad bad poster from top to bottom, as  ylysdexia | 04/27/08
Crack, anyone?  Chippolus | 04/23/08
Anyone is a good guy if you like what they do  Cayble | 04/23/08
It didnt break MS, nor would it ever break apple  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
pcguy777 retard, learn how to spell  ylysdexia | 04/27/08
Oh please, could you make yourself look any more ridiculous?!?  Scrat | 04/24/08
"Apple is one of the good guys"  ylysdexia | 04/27/08
That said... Why grind the axe?  andy@... | 04/23/08
Hardware + Software = Mac Phenomenon  SwitchStories | 04/23/08
Software = Mac Phenomenon  cornpie | 04/24/08
If they're all the same...  msalzberg | 04/24/08
Why Not ZDnet labs then?  Randalllind | 04/23/08
ZDNet buys one to test...  vikingnyc@... | 04/23/08
Where is the ZDNet review?  rolf.ernst@... | 04/23/08
They laid off much of their staff  GuidingLight | 04/23/08
What part of I don't want to don't people understand?  greatbluewhale1@... | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  strubinsky@... | 04/23/08
Of course Mac users object to this machine  rolf.ernst@... | 04/23/08
Nonsense  bdegrande | 04/23/08
That's the Mac Fanboi answer. Non-Mac PC users don't care about that.  ajole | 04/23/08
efficient/compact/clean/snazzy design awards are not for generic hardware  ylysdexia | 04/27/08
... another example sil vous plait, one day after earth day  strubinsky@... | 04/23/08
Earth Day is a good example of a hoax  davagain | 04/23/08
There is more at stake then the microcosm of buying which PC  strubinsky@... | 04/23/08
Good point.  ajole | 04/23/08
break  ylysdexia | 04/27/08
Stupid innuendo: Earth Day (Lenin's birthday)  bmerc | 04/24/08
Also...  msalzberg | 04/24/08
I wouldn't buy it, either!  nancyjones36507@... | 04/23/08
You are outnumbered 100 to 1  rolf.ernst@... | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  douglashowe@... | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  Paul Fletcher | 04/23/08
Just for fun - YES. For serious work - NO !  sloer@... | 04/23/08
No Difference  oldbaritone | 04/23/08
Big Difference !  sloer@... | 04/23/08
You're absolutely right  Spiritusindomit@... | 04/23/08
Are then cheap PC's useful for serious work ?  sloer@... | 04/23/08
WOW YOU HAVE JUST DOOMED PSYSTAR!  jboard@... | 04/23/08
EFI V8 agreement?  MarkHarrison | 04/23/08
This says it all ...  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 04/23/08
Says it all? Yeah, but not what you think it says.  BillDem | 04/24/08
This is not a license.  msalzberg | 04/24/08
There was no 'licensing' of EFI V8.  msalzberg | 04/23/08
I'm a Mac user, and I don't object...  MarkHarrison | 04/23/08
Won't say "never", but...  John L. Ries | 04/23/08
Cool idea, but if it's just about the price,  unclefixer@... | 04/23/08
Follow up...  unclefixer@... | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  Timpraetor | 04/23/08
Commercial abuses of Hackint0sh.ruins it for everyone else.  nix_hed | 04/23/08
What Psystar could have done...  John L. Ries | 04/23/08
EXCELLENT POINTS, John!  Jeff Hayes | 04/23/08
It's a good cheap computer  chadle78 | 04/23/08
It's a good cheap computer  matt@... | 04/23/08
More important than hackentosh, a truly inexpensive mac  matt@... | 04/23/08
$400 versus $3000 ?  sloer@... | 04/23/08
I'm on board with you on this  pikeman666 | 04/23/08
Sure! I'd buy one  slickjesus | 04/23/08
We are asking for a sacrifice!.  magallanes | 04/23/08
RE: Don't want a MAC, but ...  wrfloyd@... | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  strubinsky@... | 04/23/08
NO CROSSFIRE - JUST EXCUSES!  JABBER_WOLF | 04/23/08
Judge Jabber_Wolf  Piot | 04/23/08
Are you a lawyer?  msalzberg | 04/23/08
Are you a moron?  bmerc | 04/24/08
So when someone cites 'the law'  msalzberg | 04/24/08
Greed is Good  warren@... | 04/23/08
EFI Emulator License  daengbo | 04/23/08
And yet another lawyer here.  msalzberg | 04/23/08
JEEZUS will you stop with this "only lawers are allowed to talk" Bulnsense?  bmerc | 04/24/08
since you didn't read the license..  msalzberg | 04/24/08
WE just need the MOBO rom chips to make it happen  pcguy777 | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  gasheme@... | 04/23/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  cyberbull | 04/23/08
I had a Mac clone once;  trm1945 | 04/24/08
Please don't get a Hackintosh...  Mac Hosehead | 04/24/08
I wouldn't Buy one either  tracy anne | 04/24/08
Why average users should avoid Mac clones.  BillDem | 04/24/08
RE: Why I won't be buying a  questionsall | 04/24/08
Not more of this!  networkassault | 04/24/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Meet Doc