On CHOW: His burger will EAT your burger
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

December 29th, 2008

Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?

Posted by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes @ 4:47 am

Categories: Windows 7

Tags: Kubuntu, Microsoft Windows 7, KDE, Microsoft Windows, Open Source, Operating Systems, Software, Adrian Kingsley-Hughes

When I started posting screenshots of the new Windows 7 desktop several people commented both in the TalkBack and via email on how similar the Windows 7 taskbar is to the KDE 4 taskbar. Not being familiar with KDE (I’m more of an Ubuntu user rather than Kubuntu) I didn’t think much of this. After all, if you look closely enough, anything can look a bit like something that performs a similar function.

However, the other day a reader asked me to compare these two images, one of Windows 7 that I posted, and another of Kubuntu 8.10 which runs the KDE 4.0 desktop:

Windows 7:

Win7

Kubuntu 8.10:

Kubuntu 8.10

Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Yeah, I’ll admit that there are a few similarities there. That said, there are plenty of differences too.

Personally, I think that the new Windows 7 taskbar will be one of those things that people either love or hate. Initially I hated it but I’ll admit that it’s grown on me the more I use it (although I do feel that some aspects of it are somewhat vague and counter-intuitive and rely too much on tiny visual cues that are easy to overlook). However, I predict that there’ll be a lot of people who’ll instantly take a dislike to it and dismiss the entire OS based on this.

Adrian Kingsley-HughesAdrian is a technology journalist and author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology. He also runs a popular blog called The PC Doctor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations

Want to get in touch? Got a tip? Feel free to drop me a note! I ALWAYS respect anonymity. I'm also on Twitter (@the_pc_doc)

Right to Reply: Should any industry representatives wish to comment on any posts on Hardware 2.0, I will be happy to publish their reply verbatim on this blog.

Subscribe to Hardware 2.0 via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 78 Talkback(s)
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?
I don't see what the fuss is. Both the open source community and Microsoft got their ideas from Apple. Apple had the widgets, docked shortcuts, and effects. ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: vahnx Posted on: 05/03/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Tomato Tomato  honeymonster | 12/29/08
Considering that KDE 4  Linux User 147560 | 12/29/08
Oh really?  N_L_D | 12/29/08
FAIL!  honeymonster | 12/29/08
Well on the final release you are correct  Linux User 147560 | 12/29/08
Also not true  ShadeTree | 12/30/08
Shade the only person that can't face the truth is you.  Linux User 147560 | 12/30/08
and LU147560 also cant  ariesghost | 12/31/08
I dare you  daengbo | 12/31/08
Backwards.  TripleII | 12/29/08
I voted No.  fr0thy2 | 12/29/08
re: I voted No  Badgered | 12/29/08
Wrong!  fr0thy2 | 12/29/08
Not Wrong!  Badgered | 12/29/08
lulz were to be had.  ariesghost | 12/31/08
KDE Is abusive?  GuidingLight | 12/29/08
KDE is free, Windows is expensive.  fr0thy2 | 12/29/08
And that affects appearance how?  wolf_z | 12/29/08
KDE pretty much copies Windows . . .  CobraA1 | 12/29/08
Linux Stereotyping  Paradigm_Shift | 12/29/08
Dead Right..  Carion | 12/29/08
You haven't got a clue, do you ?  devilmaster | 12/29/08
RE: You haven't got a clue stick, do you ?  n0neXn0ne | 12/29/08
Here are a few clues for you.  Paradigm_Shift | 12/29/08
Re:  dvm | 12/29/08
All I Want is a Perfect OS  Paradigm_Shift | 12/29/08
You shouldn't continue  LiquidLearner | 12/29/08
If you made factual statements I would.  Paradigm_Shift | 12/30/08
Very Educational Comments  PMC-CON | 12/31/08
"You don't have to defrag in Vista or 7. Thanks."  tmsbrdrs | 12/31/08
Solution is a bit non Windows-standard  KimTjik | 12/31/08
Vista Runs Defrag By Default ...  PMC-CON | 01/01/09
Wow - you REALLY believe half the stuff you said?  CobraA1 | 12/29/08
No need to be upset  KimTjik | 12/30/08
The reason you wont go into multi-tasking  andrewjg | 12/30/08
Actually...  thenetavenger | 12/30/08
Wow  avluis | 12/30/08
Have you double checked your info?  KimTjik | 12/30/08
Keeping the Discussion Open  Paradigm_Shift | 12/30/08
Don't presume too much  KimTjik | 12/30/08
Invented Problem  Paradigm_Shift | 12/30/08
Talk about stereo types!  ShadeTree | 12/30/08
What they say about assumptions...  Paradigm_Shift | 12/30/08
KDE4 predates Windows 7  Theli | 12/29/08
You don't use linux much, do you......  linux for me | 12/29/08
Gnome sucks and is unstable  wackoae | 12/29/08
Gnome isn't (yet) an ideal desktop...  Omega Master | 12/29/08
Wrong  Tim Patterson | 12/29/08
Gnome/KDE3  1djk1 | 12/29/08
Tried it, several times.  CobraA1 | 12/29/08
default gnome...  doh123 | 12/29/08
Precisely why it will never be popular.  CobraA1 | 12/29/08
Linux copies everyone else  LBiege | 12/29/08
So easy to use Linux  LinuxandMacforlife | 01/02/09
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  DannyO_0x98 | 12/29/08
Why bother with these comparisons?  V@... | 12/29/08
That would mean..  Loverock Davidson | 12/29/08
ROFL!  B.O.F.H. | 12/29/08
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  Loverock Davidson | 12/29/08
*** BREAKING NEWS ***  no_zd_user_name | 12/29/08
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  Loverock Davidson | 12/29/08
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  jimmsta | 12/29/08
And it matters to who?  No_Ax_to_Grind | 12/29/08
It matters to some people ...  George Mitchell | 12/29/08
It looks like KDE 3 not 4, and turn on transparencies nt  T1Oracle | 12/29/08
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  tikal26 | 12/29/08
It is the vista task bar.  progon | 12/29/08
If MS started offering free software again, then OSS and the EU would  transposeIT | 12/31/08
KDE As Currently Configured is Copy of Windows GUI  PMC-CON | 01/01/09
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  fdsdfsd | 12/30/08
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  dragonbite | 12/30/08
KDE4 runs on Vista.  perspectoff | 12/30/08
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  droid137 | 12/31/08
KDE4 and Where Ubuntu is headed  fwarren | 12/31/08
Mac OS X's Dock  EmperorDarius | 01/01/09
Copier or Copyee ...  PMC-CON | 01/01/09
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  mlgoff_59 | 01/02/09
RE: Does the new Windows 7 taskbar look like the KDE 4 taskbar?  vahnx | 05/03/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Meet Doc