On last.fm: Listen to Michael Jackson on Last.fm
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

May 21st, 2009

Pop quiz - Which would you choose?

Posted by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes @ 2:25 pm

Categories: Poll of the Day

Tags: Adrian Kingsley-Hughes, Apple Mac OS X, Notebooks, Microsoft Windows, Operating Systems, Software, Apple Mac OS, Hardware, Notebooks & Tablets

Watching all those Microsoft “Laptop Hunter” ads got me thinking - if I offered you $2,000 to spend on either a Windows based or Mac OSX based notebook (don’t get all excited, it’s a hypothetical question!), which would you choose?

Which would you pick?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Why?

Adrian Kingsley-HughesAdrian is a technology journalist and author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology. He also runs a popular blog called The PC Doctor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations

Want to get in touch? Got a tip? Feel free to drop me a note! I ALWAYS respect anonymity. I'm also on Twitter (@the_pc_doc)

Right to Reply: Should any industry representatives wish to comment on any posts on Hardware 2.0, I will be happy to publish their reply verbatim on this blog.

Subscribe to Hardware 2.0 via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 146 Talkback(s)
@pard
?It is right, that UEFI support is only included in the x64 release of Vista, but that's no problem, because in my opinion there is exactly zero reason for a usual home desktop user to use a 32b Vista... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Axsimulate Posted on: 05/27/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  T-Rexx | 05/21/09
And it seems some of us Mac users agree  A Grain of Salt | 05/21/09
Kind of...  Sleeper Service | 05/22/09
That's true but..  yschoo1@... | 05/22/09
Exactly  daengbo | 05/22/09
Wrong choices  A.Sinic | 05/25/09
What the hell are you going on about  Kaiwai | 05/22/09
The money still matters...  bhartman36 | 05/23/09
Less Computer  Kaiwai | 05/24/09
Getting Work Done  bhartman36 | 05/24/09
I ended the message a little early.. happy  bhartman36 | 05/24/09
Again, who cares  Kaiwai | 05/24/09
Macs vs. PCs, not OSX vs. Windows...  bhartman36 | 05/24/09
Mac - B/c Windoze Wasta is a Worthless PoS  drprod@... | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  AySz88 | 05/21/09
On whichever would make the best Linux machine for the money, of course.  Zogg | 05/21/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  maskman01 | 05/21/09
Wow...  superbus | 05/21/09
Hello?  devlin_X | 05/21/09
A notebook? I'll go with service quality  Ken_z | 05/22/09
Buying vs Using  Harry Bardal | 05/21/09
wha-huh?  bmonster | 05/22/09
Stop wasting bandwidth you pathetic POS  Kaiwai | 05/22/09
LOL!  ITLeader | 05/22/09
Results  Harry Bardal | 05/22/09
The poll is hardly scientific  soonerproud | 05/22/09
They won for the same reason why videos get flagged on youtube  Kaiwai | 05/22/09
Dude, stay of the coffee...  Sleeper Service | 05/23/09
A Mac sale is rarely a lost Windows license  LiquidLearner | 05/24/09
Mac, simply out of need  superbus | 05/21/09
Of course you can run  macadam | 05/21/09
Vista 64 bit and Windows 7  soonerproud | 05/22/09
There should be other options such as  no_zd_user_name | 05/21/09
Love the idea...  Dave32265 | 05/21/09
Advertising $$ would certainly raise product awareness  no_zd_user_name | 05/22/09
I totally agree...  Dave32265 | 05/22/09
That is partially true  soonerproud | 05/22/09
Though I use an alternative OS as well...  devlin_X | 05/21/09
Yes, they have a choice but they promptly returned it when its not Windows.  transposeIT | 05/22/09
You are being sarcastic and making a stereotype  no_zd_user_name | 05/22/09
He's right  NStalnecker | 05/22/09
What you failed to mention was...  Dave32265 | 05/22/09
Sabotaging?  NStalnecker | 05/22/09
ASUS CEO says return rates for Linux vs Windows the same  no_zd_user_name | 05/23/09
I disagree  soonerproud | 05/22/09
That option is not needed  soonerproud | 05/22/09
Hey Superbus!  maskman01 | 05/21/09
Play on the lawn is right!  Nookhoek | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  tk1@... | 05/21/09
Macbook Pro  kitko | 05/21/09
My guess  voyager529 | 05/21/09
I'll take the Vista Machine  NStalnecker | 05/21/09
Add to that Windows 7  nothingness | 05/22/09
Indeed.  NStalnecker | 05/22/09
The mac.  TripleII | 05/21/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  Big Lug | 05/21/09
Desktop ornament against a workhorse. I'll choose Vista since my work...  transposeIT | 05/21/09
I'll take..  Dave32265 | 05/21/09
Something wrong here  tonymcs@... | 05/21/09
You can fool all of the people some of the time  Ole Man | 05/23/09
Missing a choice.  linux for me | 05/21/09
Actually, it's a hardware question. (NT)  Zogg | 05/22/09
PC with Win7  karnok.d@... | 05/22/09
Only Two Choices?  arbiter26 | 05/22/09
Adrian's talking about relevant OS here. Linux doesn't qualify...nt  transposeIT | 05/22/09
doesn't matter about the OS...  Dave32265 | 05/22/09
Still not buying Vista  arbiter26 | 05/22/09
The Vista machine, and then pump Linux on it mighty quickly  pjotr123 | 05/22/09
But you've still lost some of the "bang"  Zogg | 05/22/09
Not if...  Dave32265 | 05/22/09
I'll take the PC over a shiny paperweight any day  Scrat | 05/22/09
Liked your comment  Ken_z | 05/23/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  meelder | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  Badgered | 05/22/09
Macbook  Linkager | 05/22/09
They can and do but  soonerproud | 05/22/09
you stick with ethetics  desamuelson | 05/22/09
I'd take the Mac  Michael Kelly | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  Thomas Gentry-Funk | 05/22/09
Vista laptop running Linux, probably...  gigglypuff | 05/22/09
No brainer.....  James Quinn | 05/22/09
Who buys a 2 or 3 year old laptop?  djchandler | 05/22/09
No brainer  GeiselS@... | 05/22/09
without a desktop pc at home the Vista notebook, but  pard | 05/22/09
PC -- tool of my trade  bmonster | 05/22/09
Can i keep the change?  RobVT | 05/22/09
....  Badgered | 05/22/09
MacBook Pro  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
Vista does not run faster...  Sleeper Service | 05/22/09
EFI most definitely makes it BOOT faster  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
No, it does NOT make it boot faster  pard | 05/22/09
Well then  Michael Kelly | 05/22/09
no, the POST on my uefi board is as slow as with BIOS  pard | 05/22/09
Except as I use Vista x64 and OS X...  Sleeper Service | 05/22/09
No question  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
Windows Vista is an inconsistent piece of crap  Kaiwai | 05/22/09
oh, mac's not that much better  pard | 05/23/09
windows vista runs well on (Unified) EFI  pard | 05/22/09
Uh-huh, like you are going to buy Vista outright...  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
oh, I'm german, windows is cheap for me  pard | 05/22/09
Good for you, but...  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
LOL!  Sleeper Service | 05/22/09
No troll  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
So what you're saying is...  Sleeper Service | 05/23/09
OEM licenses are sold in the US to individuals.  soonerproud | 05/22/09
Ever heard of System Builders licenses? (OEM)  soonerproud | 05/22/09
@pard  Axsimulate | 05/22/09
that's right, and no problem  pard | 05/23/09
@pard  Axsimulate | 05/27/09
Latest Laptop Hunter ad just out!  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  DannyO_0x98 | 05/22/09
Don't you mean $2000 Mac and $1000 PC?  No_Ax_to_Grind | 05/22/09
It's not hard to find a $2000 notebook PC at all  Michael Kelly | 05/22/09
$2000 Notebook vs $2000 MacBook Pro  WarhavenSC | 05/22/09
ummmm ... LOL  gigogogogown | 05/22/09
Limited Apple choice  djchandler | 05/22/09
There is really only ONE PC though...  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
Yup. Another troll.  Sleeper Service | 05/22/09
Google Dell Adamo  soonerproud | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  durrstein@... | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  durrstein@... | 05/22/09
I'll take the one that can run OS X and Windows  gregory.dworak@... | 05/22/09
Totally agree  comp_indiana | 05/22/09
What a load of bull  soonerproud | 05/22/09
You miss the point...  gregory.dworak@... | 05/25/09
Take no notice; such people are capable of only two-dimensional thinking.  HypnoToad72 | 05/25/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  Linux uSer | 05/22/09
Where's my $2000 option for XP or Win7?  nhudd | 05/22/09
Buy the Vista PC in June  soonerproud | 05/22/09
I'll just have a $2000 laptop thanks  Alan Smithie | 05/22/09
More Software Choices For Vista! Crysis On A Mac???  dennyc5@... | 05/22/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  waybj | 05/22/09
2 $1000 windows laptops  julians@... | 05/22/09
And they break down more often...  HypnoToad72 | 05/22/09
That is a myth  soonerproud | 05/22/09
Blah Blah Blah Blah  Kaiwai | 05/22/09
You are wrong  soonerproud | 05/22/09
How old are your Macs? shocked  pico_D | 05/25/09
Well, since I use my computer for computing and not gaming,  HypnoToad72 | 05/22/09
you misunderstood  pard | 05/23/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  bregant2 | 05/22/09
My Pick...  zak89 | 05/23/09
How about if I pocket $800 and get a $1200 PC?  georgeou | 05/25/09
Neither...  pico_D | 05/25/09
RE: Pop quiz - Which would you choose?  jperlowZDNet Moderator | 05/25/09
It's only an appliance  nrkmann@... | 05/25/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads