On GameSpot: Black Wii Remote, Nunchuk hit US Nov. 16
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

August 5th, 2009

7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1

Posted by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes @ 11:26 am

Categories: On the test bench, Windows 7

Tags: Microsoft Windows XP, SP3, Microsoft Windows Vista, Microsoft Windows Vista SP1, Microsoft Windows 7, Microsoft Windows, Operating Systems, Software, Adrian Kingsley-Hughes

Over the past few months I’ve talked a lot about the performance side of things with regard to Windows 7. However, I’ve not been able to give you any actual numbers because the EULA for the beta and release candidate versions of Windows 7 prohibited me from doing so. However, now that Windows 7 has hit the RTM I can carry out benchmark tests and provide you with real numbers.

The tests

Rather than dump a whole series of benchmark results on you, I’m going to release them over a few posts. Here I’m going to look at four specific metrics:

  • Boot up speed
  • Shutdown speed
  • Compressing and then extracting a folder contains numerous files and folders (3500 files / 30 folders) totaling 5.15GB

Tests are carried out on 32-bit versions of Windows.

Test systems

I’ve used two desktop systems as the test machines:

  • An AMD Phenom 9700 2.4GHz system fitted with an ATI Radeon 3850 and 4GB of RAM
  • An Intel Pentium Dual Core E2200 2.2GHz fitted with an NVIDIA GeForce 8400 GS and 1GB of RAM

Results/Conclusion –>

Pages: 1 2

Adrian Kingsley-HughesAdrian is a technology journalist and author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology. He also runs a popular blog called The PC Doctor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations

Want to get in touch? Got a tip? Feel free to drop me a note! I ALWAYS respect anonymity. I'm also on Twitter (@the_pc_doc)

Right to Reply: Should any industry representatives wish to comment on any posts on Hardware 2.0, I will be happy to publish their reply verbatim on this blog.

Subscribe to Hardware 2.0 via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 72 Talkback(s)
RE: 7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1
AMD PHENOM SEEMS TO BE SLOWER THEN THE INTEL CORE (Read the rest)
Posted by: rahuldravid634@... Posted on: 10/14/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
64 Bit  djmik | 08/05/09
Can we please stop with the bootup / shutdown focus?  NonZealot | 08/05/09
agreed  Badgered | 08/05/09
agree also.  eqpc | 08/05/09
RTP  Patanjali | 08/05/09
Startup and shutdown...  Ben_E | 08/05/09
Not really.  eqpc | 08/05/09
So, are you implying that XP is more stable because it takes longer?  Patanjali | 08/05/09
I never said that!  eqpc | 08/05/09
Sorry, I inferred it because XP IS the one that is slower  Patanjali | 08/05/09
Sorry also  eqpc | 08/06/09
Depends how fast they become  Patanjali | 08/05/09
You seem to not work in a corporate IT environment.  kd5auq | 08/06/09
Vista vs 7....  JT82 | 08/05/09
Because not everyone uses an OS just for speed  MissingMatter | 08/05/09
Superfecth is one of the reasons it is faster (nt)  NeoGeneration | 08/05/09
Even without those HDD compensating devices, W7 is still faster  Patanjali | 08/05/09
The real story is Vista is faster than XP.  ye | 08/05/09
RE: 7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1  shollomon | 08/05/09
Is Shutdown\Bootup Times Really All That Important  Carlito_Chippy | 08/05/09
remember...  Fark | 08/05/09
And Win 7 needs to be rebooted less than XP  Patanjali | 08/05/09
In the grand scheme of things .....  kd5auq | 08/06/09
Shutdown time is important  pauliusp | 08/05/09
Vista/7 automatically closes those prompts after a few seconds (nt)  MissingMatter | 08/05/09
Win 7 doesn't seem to delay much updates, even big ones  Patanjali | 08/05/09
Why doesn't anyone ever report standard deviations?  MissingMatter | 08/05/09
Probably because it's a level of detail that goes over most peoples' heads  Patanjali | 08/05/09
I Don't Believe You!  serpentmage | 08/05/09
XP displays a picture, but it's still starting services for some time after  Patanjali | 08/05/09
um...  Badgered | 08/05/09
store bought? Let's try clean install on homebuilt  eggmanbubbagee@... | 08/05/09
Vista DID improve a lot of basic performance, but Win 7 makes use of it  Patanjali | 08/05/09
I would expect that these tests WERE done with clean installs  Patanjali | 08/05/09
my reply was to 'serpentimage', not Adrian's article (nt)  eggmanbubbagee@... | 08/05/09
Sorry!  Patanjali | 08/14/09
Adrian, can you compare them to OSX ???  i8thecat | 08/05/09
Probably an issue of time  Patanjali | 08/05/09
Hardware changes over time...  i8thecat | 08/05/09
Geez, and I thought you wanted Mac OS X to have a fighting chance... nt  daftkey | 08/05/09
Re:Mac OS vs Vista x64  dvm | 08/05/09
It is Mac OS x32 vs Vista x64, darling wink  Solid Water | 08/05/09
So test 64 bit Photoshop in OS X!  NonZealot | 08/06/09
Re:  dvm | 08/06/09
You might be on to something here...  daftkey | 08/05/09
Now that wasn't nice!!  NonZealot | 08/06/09
Sure.. I would love to see those results...  i8thecat | 08/06/09
One difference..  daftkey | 08/06/09
Sissy beer???.... LOL  i8thecat | 08/06/09
Ubuntu could be done but...  JasonJD48 | 08/05/09
News to me...  daftkey | 08/06/09
Hackintosh???  i8thecat | 08/06/09
RE: 7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1  Loverock Davidson | 08/05/09
Adrian will you be doing a comparison of 7 to Ubuntu?   Dietrich T. Schmitz | 08/05/09
Nah... happy  Solid Water | 08/05/09
Et tu Adrian?   Dietrich T. Schmitz | 08/06/09
Adrian: Clarify XP startup times  Patanjali | 08/05/09
The bigger story as I see it  Michael Kelly | 08/05/09
Very astute! Looks like they should be swapped!  Patanjali | 08/05/09
The 9700 has the tlb issue.  bjbrock | 08/05/09
They may be lying  alokgovil | 08/05/09
Shouldn't you be using Vista SP2?  kevintxu | 08/05/09
RE: 7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1  greggdov@... | 08/05/09
RE: 7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1  techfix | 08/05/09
how about the crappy display or crashy file transfers  sparkle farkle | 08/06/09
Good Job Adrian...  Kromaethius | 08/06/09
On no planet is Vista Bootup/shutdown faster than XP  jdakula | 08/06/09
RE: 7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1  merumaru@... | 08/06/09
Why you're testing Vista SP1 and NOT Vista SP2?  directory | 08/18/09
Vista w/SP2 64-Bit vs. Windows 7 RTM 64-Bit  cnfrisch | 08/18/09
What's the story with Window extract?  Necrolin | 08/30/09
RE: 7 RTM vs. Vista SP1 vs. XP SP3 - Shootout, Part 1  rahuldravid634@... | 10/14/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More