On The Insider: Cougar Town Production Postponed
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

October 22nd, 2009

Nokia sues Apple over iPhone

Posted by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes @ 1:44 pm

Categories: Apple, Legal

Tags: Apple iPhone, Nokia Corp., Apple Inc., Wireless, Wi-Fi, LANs, Smart Phones, Wireless And Mobility, Networking, Consumer Electronics

Nokia, the world’s biggest cellphone manufacturer, has said that it is suing Apple for infringing patents on technology used in the iPhone.

The ten alleged patent infringements involve wireless data, speech coding, security and encryption. Nokia claims the infringements apply to all iPhones sold so far.

The specific allegations raised in the lawsuit concern patents relating to three areas of wireless technology.

  • GSM
  • 3G (UMTS or W-CDMA
  • An unnamed wireless local area network (LAN) technology, most likely WiFi.

Nokia claims that Apple is “trying to get a free ride on the back of Nokia’s innovation.”

There’s speculation that Nokia could grab as much as $12 per iPhone sold.

Apple’s shares fell following news of the legal action.

Adrian Kingsley-HughesAdrian is a technology journalist and author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology. He also runs a popular blog called The PC Doctor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations

Want to get in touch? Got a tip? Feel free to drop me a note! I ALWAYS respect anonymity. I'm also on Twitter (@the_pc_doc)

Right to Reply: Should any industry representatives wish to comment on any posts on Hardware 2.0, I will be happy to publish their reply verbatim on this blog.

Subscribe to Hardware 2.0 via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 110 Talkback(s)
This is tiresome
These back and forth accusations of lying and brownosing are immature and tiresome. It should not have to be pointed out that dropped calls not only have to do with what phone you are using, but also ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: pam.rickey@... Posted on: 10/25/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
?trying to get a free ride on the back of Nokia?s innovation.?  T1Oracle | 10/22/09
Apple even invented gestures  NonZealot | 10/22/09
ROTFLMAO!!!!  i8thecat | 10/23/09
LMAO!!!  MalachiV | 10/23/09
3 !  FanaticGeek | 10/23/09
NonZi  GSavage777 | 10/23/09
COMPLETELY Inaccurate.....  mhbowman@... | 10/23/09
Thank you...  Shmeg | 10/23/09
but most people  magallanes | 10/23/09
"Most people"  PacoBell | 10/24/09
Too literal  kaninelupus | 10/23/09
haha... Steve Jobs is Related to Al Gore! wink  i2fun@... | 10/23/09
Expecting the Call from Nobel any Second Now  daves1646 | 10/23/09
Yes Get Your Facts Right.  bkoh | 10/23/09
Nice troll - and everyone missed it! happy  IslandBoy_77 | 10/23/09
Yep!  FanaticGeek | 10/23/09
Idiotic emotionalism  Appreciate-Tech | 10/24/09
Quick correction:  msalzberg | 10/24/09
Apple will settle  Linux Geek | 10/22/09
Will Nokia cross-license the 30% dropped call technique?  NonZealot | 10/22/09
Your nose must be getting pretty long...  msalzberg | 10/22/09
Really?  TekGeek73 | 10/23/09
I will argue this for two reasons...  vulpine@... | 10/23/09
Didn't you forget to mention something?  sakhan100 | 10/24/09
Hardly  vulpine@... | 10/24/09
Blackberry vs. iPhone in dropped calls  tgroom@... | 10/23/09
They already did  bamyclouse@... | 10/23/09
You're forgetting one thing....  kaninelupus | 10/24/09
Tables Turned on Apple  NameRedacted | 10/22/09
Apple is a disgusting bully  NonZealot | 10/22/09
So we can now officially call you...  msalzberg | 10/22/09
We can now officially call you a stalker!  NonZealot | 10/22/09
Again with the personal attacks, rather than answering the question  msalzberg | 10/22/09
We all tried giving you the proof, it didn't make it past your RDF  NonZealot | 10/22/09
There's a touch of desperation in your replies...  msalzberg | 10/22/09
LOL!! Desperation?! LOL!!  NonZealot | 10/22/09
Despite your evasions...  msalzberg | 10/22/09
Have you ever listened to yourself, NZ?  vulpine@... | 10/23/09
Hmmm.. Constantly repeating a lie...  Wolfie2K3 | 10/23/09
I have no contact with Apple's ad agency...  msalzberg | 10/23/09
Yes, Constantly.  vulpine@... | 10/23/09
Remember when,...  seaczar | 10/23/09
memory  DeusExMachina | 10/23/09
Maybe Apple learned from Microsoft that bullies always win  bamyclouse@... | 10/23/09
How do yu know if Nokia accusations have any creditablity?  mathcreative | 10/24/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  XArt | 10/22/09
Nokia already has an iPhone killer  NonZealot | 10/22/09
Maybe if you tell this lie often enough...  msalzberg | 10/22/09
Maybe if you hear it from someone else...  ppeirce@... | 10/23/09
Are you going to post the proof...  msalzberg | 10/23/09
Hell no, because I have better things to do...  ppeirce@... | 10/23/09
No  DeusExMachina | 10/23/09
Here Idiot  bckerr | 10/23/09
You should have followed the link back to the source.  msalzberg | 10/23/09
And perhaps  DeusExMachina | 10/23/09
This is tiresome  pam.rickey@... | 10/25/09
Small point about webkit  balaknair | 10/23/09
Poor Apple (Not!)  rupaa62 | 10/22/09
Stealing...  1djk1 | 10/23/09
One Problem  bckerr | 10/23/09
Copying is not a bad thing  FanaticGeek | 10/23/09
License  Jkirk3279 | 10/23/09
Concurrent development is, then, not possible?  bamyclouse@... | 10/23/09
I believe that Nokia is not American.  Dealing | 10/22/09
That's correct  max@... | 10/23/09
12$ x iphones sold = Big Payday  GetReal-mac.com | 10/23/09
Americans are just cool...  bamyclouse@... | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  dlawson@... | 10/22/09
Xerox didn't invent the mouse...  msalzberg | 10/23/09
Absolutely Correct, and nor did IBM.  ppeirce@... | 10/23/09
Engelbart was at...  msalzberg | 10/23/09
Correcting myself:  msalzberg | 10/24/09
Not stupid (exactly)  OldPoet | 10/23/09
God invented the mouse  bamyclouse@... | 10/23/09
Touch Screens  Jkirk3279 | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  shellcodes_coder | 10/22/09
Oh the irony...  The Star King | 10/23/09
Your missing something  bckerr | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  max@... | 10/23/09
What's next  kburmaster@... | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  fasiosta@... | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  fasiosta@... | 10/23/09
patent  magallanes | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  Gis Bun | 10/23/09
Counter Sue  robertmro | 10/23/09
Ho Ho Ho  GetReal-mac.com | 10/23/09
F___ You Santa Claus  robertmro | 10/23/09
Have you seen how much Apple's shares were affected?  vulpine@... | 10/23/09
What does it matter?  OldPoet | 10/23/09
Not  bckerr | 10/23/09
If You Can't Beat Them.........  robertmro | 10/23/09
but Nokia  magallanes | 10/23/09
Damn Right  bckerr | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  Tonynicholson | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  tjm_mgd@... | 10/23/09
Right on.  bckerr | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  Tony Michener | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  mb4574 | 10/23/09
Seems a little suspicious to wait this long...  paulfox | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  michael@... | 10/23/09
Absolutely brilliant!  chaz15 | 10/23/09
Please Block The Idiots  hellam.horror@... | 10/23/09
Can't Do That !  Jkirk3279 | 10/23/09
Would you mind explaining?  adornoe@... | 10/23/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  bckerr | 10/23/09
Yeah, fail...  Jkirk3279 | 10/23/09
The truth about Apple Vs MS  hellam.horror@... | 10/23/09
Sour Grapes.......  masterurmind@... | 10/24/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  rpsin | 10/24/09
RE: Nokia sues Apple over iPhone  337 | 10/24/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Meet Doc

  • Here to help you with your Document Management Needs
  • Doc is an enigma. Born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer, he grew up in various locations in the United States. He’s seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone.
  • To learn more about this mysterious figure check out his blog on ZDNet and his Workspace on TechRepublic. You’ll be glad you did.
  • Produced by
    ZDNet and