On TechRepublic: Why Android beats iPhone
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

September 17th, 2009

California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban

Posted by Sean Portnoy @ 7:54 pm

Categories: Home Theater

Tags: California, HDTV, TVs, Tv & Home Theater, Personal Technology, Home Entertainment, Sean Portnoy

California has long been at the leading edge of energy conservation, for better and, sometimes, for worse. Case in point: The California Energy Commission has proposed set power-usage limits on television sets that manufacturers would have to meet in order to sell those TVs in the state. If adopted, the limits would effectively prevent any plasma HDTV larger than 60-inches using current technology from being commercially available in the Golden State.

Needless, mom-and-pop TV shops in California aren’t too happy with the idea, and a recent survey conducted by Zogby International suggests a majority of residents think such regulations go too far. That may not be entirely shocking, but what’s somewhat surprising is that the percentage is lower than you might think: 57 percent oppose the proposal, which means more than two in five Californians agree with the idea that large TVs shouldn’t be sold in the state.

While this feels like regulatory zeal gone a little too far, the green revolution is having an impact on HDTV manufacturing. LCDs and even plasmas have become more energy efficient, thanks in part to more stringent requirements for Energy Star certification. And as LED-backlit LCD HDTVs reach mainstream prices and OLED sets become more prevalent, their energy efficiency will save even more power than conventional LCDs. (I don’t suppose we’ll be seeing a cash-for-clunkers style promotion for less power-thirsty HDTVs, however.)

Do you believe large-screen TVs consume too much power, and therefore should be commercially unavailable if they can’t reach energy-usage limits? Answer the poll question below and let us know your thoughts in the TalkBack section.

Should power-hungry big-screen TVs be banned from being sold?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Sean PortnoySean Portnoy spent several years as an editor at Computer Shopper magazine, most recently serving as online executive editor. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Sean Portnoy

Subscribe to Home Theater via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 64 Talkback(s)
Should BIG SC TVs be banned....
Ahhh, no. Perhaps the better approach would be to raise the bar, provide guidelines, of what power requirements are expected to qualify as GREEN STAR COMPLAINT, and let the public vote with their wallets... just a thought. To buy or not to buy?... (Read the rest)
Posted by: theguru1995@... Posted on: 10/09/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Regulate power, not size  ZStoner | 09/17/09
That's what it says in the article!  Patanjali | 09/17/09
Regulate usage, not size  rick@... | 09/18/09
Power Usage  30bob1 | 09/18/09
Should BIG SC TVs be banned....  theguru1995@... | 10/09/09
Where governments can make a difference  Patanjali | 09/17/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  MrSinatra | 09/18/09
This is lunacy, from a state full of lunatics  chrome_slinky@... | 09/18/09
As an Oregon resident  oncall | 09/18/09
Something in the air or water?  rocketman67 | 09/18/09
There is something in the water in So. CA!  brambeus | 09/19/09
Couldn't agree more.  ccsolutions | 09/18/09
We get the government we deserve...  psquare11 | 09/18/09
This is just large plasmas  Roger Ramjet | 09/18/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  djmik | 09/18/09
"Pressure the manufacturers [...]"  Olivier- | 09/19/09
Do what my state did - produce cleaner power.  CobraA1 | 09/18/09
California already has...  Stuka | 09/18/09
That's 79%...  psquare11 | 09/18/09
You WAY over-estimate your "clean power" stats.  Bruizer | 09/19/09
Yeah, there are other large format technologies  ca1ic0cat | 09/18/09
Ever Seen "Who Killed the Electric Car?"  djzoey | 09/18/09
I' from CA and only visit now also.  JamesDBSR2 | 09/18/09
I wholeheartedly agree  oncall | 09/18/09
Count your blessings and shut up...  psquare11 | 09/18/09
LOL  oncall | 09/19/09
Raising Taxes...  djzoey | 09/18/09
RE: California screenin': Better idea than a big-screen TV ban  dcwest | 09/18/09
Good Idea!  kat313 | 09/18/09
I concur  odcchaz | 09/18/09
I Agree. The solution is simple.  Hates Idiots | 09/18/09
Envy?  wkulecz | 09/18/09
Excellent point: socialism to contain the masses  lalogos | 09/29/09
Waste of legislative Energy is the real problem  bhaydama | 09/18/09
Where is the savings?  gveets | 09/18/09
Like I said above  oncall | 09/18/09
It is lunacy. Build more nuclear plants,  HollywoodDog | 09/18/09
What we need is...  James T. Kirk | 09/18/09
Fast Breeder Reactors  gveets | 09/18/09
If I recall correctly....  James T. Kirk | 09/18/09
fast breeders == terorrist targets  Uncle Stoat | 09/20/09
Nuclear Waste  sboverie@... | 09/18/09
Nuclear waste or wasted fuel?  Uncle Stoat | 09/20/09
Nuclear power: clean, cheap fuel  lalogos | 09/29/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  JamesDBSR2 | 09/18/09
Regulate Government, Not Citizens  davagain | 09/18/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  erglazier | 09/18/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  iouzero | 09/18/09
Rating needed.  Hates Idiots | 09/18/09
Sorry. Can not type today.  Hates Idiots | 09/18/09
RE: California screenin': Too Little too late, again  gscrivner7@... | 09/18/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  Tinman57 | 09/18/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  drkimca | 09/19/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  i-Pete | 09/19/09
Title is inaccurate.  Lester Young | 09/19/09
The only thing that needs limiting is Government itself  Ole Man | 09/19/09
Rising power costs will solve the problem naturally  Uncle Stoat | 09/20/09
Ah but... I suspect that there are people already  James Quinn | 09/20/09
Perhaps this will get us large TV's that use power better?  James Quinn | 09/20/09
California has a non-linear scale for charging you for electricity usage  Qbt | 09/20/09
Anything above 40" is going to be a big little piggie, suckin' the power  HypnoToad72 | 09/20/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  matchstich | 09/20/09
RE: California screenin': Majority of residents oppose big-screen TV ban  mi_erle | 09/22/09
Environmentalism: Front for Socialistic Control  lalogos | 09/29/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Enterprise Applications

  • Check out some of the easiest and most powerful ways to boost productivity while saving money on your application infrastructure. See ZDNet's comprehensive Enterprise Application resource center, now!
  • New Online Dashboard
  • Read about top issues IT decision-makers face every day, plus get cost effective solutions to real life IT problems. Oracle Topline