On BNET: Gen Y: Your degree doesn't cut it
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

October 19th, 2009

Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect

Posted by Zack Whittaker @ 4:53 am

Categories: Discussion, Events, Microsoft, Next-generation technology, Productivity, Security, Skills development, Windows 7

Tags: Operating System, Microsoft Windows Vista, Microsoft Corp., Computer, Microsoft Windows 7, Microsoft Windows, Microsoft Windows Vista (Longhorn), Operating Systems, Software, Zack Whittaker

For my 400th post on ZDNet, this is one mass response in reply to a barrage of emails I have had to suffer over the course of the last couple of weeks.

It seems as though I, and the just-over ten thousand students on my university campus, are not the only ones complaining even still about the abomination that their respective university IT department, hand in hand with the devil itself, Microsoft, have bestowed upon us: forced through product lifecycle periods to upgrade our campus to “the latest and greatest”. Feel free to detect any element of sarcasm in the last sentence.

Only short two weeks ago, I had high hopes for the upgrade. I genuinely thought that a new lease of life could be drawn through the lungs of Microsoft’. I was not only wrong, but overly optimistic.

For those who have been reading since day one, I started with a touch of empathy towards the then-new operating system. Over time, and predominantly over the course of Windows 7’s beta cycles, I became more attached to the lack of resource hogging, sluggishness and a general freshness which could only be rivalled by that of a gentle breeze on a summer’s day in the countryside.

But I did start off with a very good point. Vista back in the day was perfectly fine. Only in comparison to a better benchmark of Windows 7 do we start slating the former operating system. Something that widely popular blogger, Long Zheng, mentioned earlier on this morning on Twitter was this:

To begin, I start with the question as mentioned in the title. From there I hypothesise the potential failure of Windows 7 and look into the few people we can blame for the potentially epic failure of Microsoft’s next operating system.

Who do we blame for Vista, and Windows 7’s potential failure? –>

Pages: 1 2

Zack Whittaker, the youngest in the ZDNet network, is a British student at the University of Kent, Canterbury, where he studies BA (Hons) Criminology and Social Policy. His insight into the next-generation is unique and first-hand, sharing his knowledge of the here and now but more so what's next and how to get there.

You can read his public biography and his work disclosures of his current and past industry affiliations.

Fire off an email if you feel like sharing a story or insight, or leave a voicemail. You can also follow him on Twitter to keep up to date with his ramblings.

Subscribe to iGeneration via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 80 Talkback(s)
Ignorance
It seems the Red Scare is still haven't it's effect on this country. Communism is what has failed not socialism. There have been many socialist countries world wide that have been very successful. ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Greenman76 Posted on: 11/09/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Windows is a failure  Christian_<>< | 10/19/09
great and then you will tell us that...  Ceridan | 10/19/09
No, it isn't.  CobraA1 | 10/19/09
Correction...  storm14k | 10/19/09
well . . .  CobraA1 | 10/19/09
1%...hmmmm!  GOTBO | 10/19/09
waay more than one percent.  crabbypup | 10/19/09
desktops  CobraA1 | 10/19/09
Not True  mlbslugger | 10/19/09
Pure ignorance on display...  adornoe@... | 10/19/09
OMG  GOTBO | 10/19/09
If you have a disagreement, then "OMG" is not sufficient...  adornoe@... | 10/19/09
Obviously you do but obviously not eloquently. nt  socialism=nowhere | 10/19/09
Nicely done - ty - nt  socialism=nowhere | 10/19/09
I was with you about Linux having 1% but then I got lost...  HaknGolfer | 10/19/09
What the M$ FUDsters fail to take into account is that...  UAC nanny screen | 10/19/09
What the Linux shills fail to understand  rtk | 10/19/09
What M$ tools like rtk fail to understand...  UAC nanny screen | 10/20/09
And desktops aren't servers, servers aren't desktops.  rtk | 10/20/09
But they are still Linux  UAC nanny screen | 10/21/09
Yeah, but there's a handful of them in comparison.  rtk | 10/21/09
I'm not american ...  stewymelb | 10/20/09
Ignorance  Greenman76 | 11/09/09
Phew - I was afraid you wouldn't chim in with a dim  socialism=nowhere | 10/19/09
wow...  g-ssg | 10/19/09
Come back down to this planet  denzcam | 10/19/09
Are the TROLLS really THAT hungry??  kaninelupus | 10/20/09
On Linux and Mac  pjotr123 | 10/19/09
Macs require maintainence too  Rob Oakes | 10/19/09
Ahh, WTF?  kaninelupus | 10/20/09
Yes, yes, yes  walnut186 | 10/20/09
if you write a paragraph like this....  deaf_e_kate | 10/19/09
The fault lies with MS and Driver manufacturers  User 13 | 10/19/09
Well not really manifacturers but...  Ceridan | 10/19/09
Vista SP1/SP2 works just fine  Tom12Tom | 10/19/09
I agree  Ceridan | 10/19/09
Count me as well  nothingness | 10/19/09
Yes, but what hardware do you have?  jgpeters | 10/19/09
I disagree....  GOTBO | 10/19/09
Vista DOES work just fine!  jromyt@... | 10/19/09
Agreed, Vista does work just fine!  PrestonSK | 10/21/09
Saw you post elsewhre about no MS phone  Boot_Agnostic | 10/19/09
Less drinking, more thinking  johnfenjackson@... | 10/19/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  ilovenudism | 10/19/09
Corrupt files?  Narg | 10/19/09
WTF?  merddyin@... | 10/19/09
Internet 8 and silverlight corrupts??  Franciscus101 | 10/19/09
silverlight kicked my dog!  rtk | 10/19/09
Vista was great for me...  Narg | 10/19/09
Version 6 to 6.1....  b12sklfck | 10/19/09
Vista or Ballmer?  Silex | 10/19/09
XP Upgrade "Path/Ordeal"  bgrh | 10/19/09
Vista back in the day was perfectly fine?  awasson@... | 10/19/09
Then why was XP not a 'failure' in retrospect?  jgpeters | 10/19/09
Vista in perspective: I think it sucks  Get-Smart | 10/19/09
Awesome post  b12sklfck | 10/19/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  cosuna | 10/19/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  dcolbert@... | 10/19/09
Computer Science Gone STUPID....  anthony@... | 10/19/09
Great Post - I Agree!  stillgolfing | 10/19/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  zdn4lee | 10/19/09
Vista was a train wreck  b12sklfck | 10/19/09
Half my Vista installs have 1GB  rtk | 10/19/09
Vista ... perfectly good OS  dhamilt01@... | 10/19/09
Except, they're not  rtk | 10/19/09
Linux servers are  UAC nanny screen | 10/19/09
Yeah, except they are...  awasson@... | 10/19/09
Yes, I've never understood that...  UAC nanny screen | 10/20/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  Masari.Jones | 10/19/09
Windows 7 is a Great OS  PrestonSK | 10/19/09
What about the consumer!  denzcam | 10/19/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  jayb1@... | 10/19/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  programit@... | 10/19/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  bigtom2_z | 10/20/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  troubled241 | 10/20/09
Beta is the key word  PrestonSK | 10/21/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  kevinf@... | 10/21/09
Failure only in retrospective? My rosy red backside!  Heimdall222 | 10/21/09
Win 7 already ahead  3dguru | 10/21/09
RE: Windows 7 puts Vista into perspective: Only a 'failure' in retrospect  bb_apptix | 10/22/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads