On CNET: Convertible tablet Netbook
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

May 9th, 2008

Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)

Posted by Mary Jo Foley @ 2:34 pm

Categories: Corporate strategy, Service Pack, Windows XP, Windows client

Tags: Mary Jo Foley

Microsoft isn’t halting Windows XP Service Pack (SP) 3 distribution — so far, at least — in spite of endless-reboot problems reported by AMD-based PC customers, a company spokeswoman said on May 9.

Reports of the reboot problem are cropping up on Microsoft forums and other sites across the Web. Microsoft resumed Windows Update delivery of XP SP3 this week, after temporarily halting its distribution due to an incompatibility involving SP3 and Microsoft’s Retail Management System (RMS).

Microsoft Security Most Valuable Professional (MVP) Jesper Johansson blogged about the SP3 reboot problem on May 8. He has been posting to his blog workarounds for both AMD systems and Intel ones that are affected by the SP 3 problem. My ZDNet blogging colleague Adrian Kinglsey-Hughes also has suggestions of steps cusotmers can take before installing XP Sp3 to potentially avoid installation problems.

This isn’t the first time that a Microsoft service pack caused reboot problems. A Vista SP1 pre-requisite caused endless-reboot problems for some customers, resulting in Microsoft’s temporary suspension of the downloads of that update.

Microsoft is telling XP SP3 customers who encounter installation problems to contact customer support.

“Microsoft is aware of these (SP3) issues and is investigating them further,” the spokeswoman told me on Friday May 9. “We will keep customers informed of the progress.”

Update: On May 12, Microsoft officials shared another update on the cause of the SP3-reboot problem. This is what they told News.com:

“While the root cause of this issue is complex, it results from OEMs improperly placing a Windows XP image created for an for Intel-based computer onto machines with non-Intel chipsets,” Microsoft said in a statement. “Microsoft issued guidance to OEMs advising them to only load Windows XP images onto like hardware in 2004.”

Mary Jo FoleyMary Jo has covered the tech industry for more than 20 years. Don't miss a single post. Subscribe via Email or RSS. You can also follow Mary Jo on Twitter.

Got a tip? Send Mary Jo your rants, rumors, tips and tattles. For disclosure on Mary Jo's industry affiliations, click here or to see Mary Jo's full profile click here.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 43 Talkback(s)
I got endless reboot on Intel
All in the same day, I installed XP SP2 on a freshly formated disk, installed all critical patches, then was presented with option for SP3. What a mistake! I installed SP3 and now i can't even get into safe mode without endless reboots!... (Read the rest)
Posted by: rkelly Posted on: 05/20/08 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
They should  klumper | 05/09/08
Notice how it only seems to be AMD machines?  MGP2 | 05/09/08
You could be onto something  klumper | 05/09/08
Worked for me  M.R. Kennedy | 05/10/08
It's an OEM goof up...  D. W. Bierbaum | 05/12/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  Pooch666 | 05/09/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  We Love XP! | 05/09/08
Microsoft gets paid, either way  Ole Man | 05/09/08
Message has been deleted.  M.R. Kennedy | 05/10/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  atari8bit@... | 05/10/08
XP SP3 has been pulled in another way.  Arm A. Geddon | 05/10/08
Who cares and how wants to hear your lame blogs. write somthing worthy!  groovepoint@... | 05/10/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  pcmooten@... | 05/11/08
SP3 installed just fine on my AMD system  cnfrisch | 05/11/08
HP support solution for HP PCs using AMD Athlon CPU  cnfrisch | 05/11/08
Thank you! That should be a cinch....  Ole Man | 05/11/08
If They Can't Do That  rkuhn040172@... | 05/12/08
Installing XP SP/3 does NOT = learning/using Linux  Ole Man | 05/12/08
HP support solution for HP PCs using AMD Athlon CPU  aussieblnd@... | 05/12/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  alpadilla2878@... | 05/11/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  ZBUM | 05/11/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  jnovickas@... | 05/11/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  chet814@... | 05/12/08
After it was installed it would not activate my software  troubled241 | 05/12/08
Re: After it was installed it would not activate my software  ianlyy@... | 05/12/08
It write I had the choice of telephone, or internet  troubled241 | 05/12/08
re: After it was installed it would not activate my software  MowGreen | 05/12/08
Activation is not always accepted with WinXP SP 3  troubled241 | 05/12/08
You did a no-no and got caught  Ole Man | 05/12/08
re: Activation is not always accepted with WinXP SP 3  MowGreen | 05/13/08
Why should anybody be required to "ACTIVATE"  Ole Man | 05/12/08
After it was installed it would not activate my software  aussieblnd@... | 05/12/08
Same here Microsoft hates XP user's  rascalrat | 05/12/08
So hate them right back  bart001fr | 05/13/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  lcraven@... | 05/12/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  lcraven@... | 05/12/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  linville@... | 05/12/08
RE: Only one thing to do.  nikacat | 05/12/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  tealcat | 05/13/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  djchandler | 05/13/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  l.sarrazin@... | 05/13/08
RE: Microsoft not pulling XP SP3 again (so far)  brossyg@... | 05/13/08
I got endless reboot on Intel  rkelly | 05/20/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Order Microsoft 2.0

Pre-order Microsoft 2.0

Order 'Microsoft 2.0' by Mary Jo Foley at Amazon.com.

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Smartphones

  • Last year, many businesses deferred the purchase of new laptops in favor of smartphones, and why not? Offering phone, calendar, email, IM and Web access, they're arguably the most practical business tools. Check out the latest CNET Reviews of Blackberry devices for all the knowledge you need to make an intelligent choice.
  • Sleek. Thin. Light.
  • With its full keyboard and high-res screen, the BlackBerry® Curve™ 8900 is the perfect fit for your work and your life. Learn more
advertisement
Click Here