On TV.com: 2009's Most PIRATED TV Show
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

April 29th, 2008

XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all

Posted by Mary Jo Foley @ 10:21 am

Categories: Service Pack, Vista, Windows XP, Windows client

Tags: Microsoft Dynamics, Microsoft Windows Update, Microsoft Corp., Retail Management System, Microsoft Windows, Microsoft Windows XP, Operating Systems, Software, Mary Jo Foley

Microsoft has decided not to release Windows XP Service Pack (SP) 3 to Windows Update and the Microsoft Download Center as planned on April 29. The reason? A last-minute compatibility issue with a Microsoft application — Microsoft Dynamics Retail Management System (RMS).

Here’s the latest from a company spokesperson:

“I wanted to update you on today’s planned release to web (RTW) (of XP SP3). In the last few days, we have uncovered a compatibility issue between Microsoft Dynamics Retail Management System (RMS) and Windows XP SP3 and Windows Vista Service Pack 1 (SP1).

“In order to make sure customers have the best possible experience we have decided to delay releasing Windows XP SP3 to Windows Update and Microsoft Download Center.

“To help protect our customers, we plan to put filtering in place shortly to prevent Windows Update from offering both service packs to systems running Microsoft Dynamics RMS. Once filtering is in place, we expect to release Windows XP SP3 to Windows Update and Download Center.

“Until we have published a fix for this issue, we advise Microsoft Dynamics RMS customers to not install either service pack. Microsoft Dynamics RMS customers running Windows XP SP3 or Windows Vista SP1 should contact Microsoft Customer Support Services for additional information.

“The fix is currently in testing and will be available as soon as that process is complete.”

That’s all we know so far. No new date as to when Microsoft will release XP SP3 to the Web. Microsoft released to manufacturing XP SP3 last week — and after outcry for its paying TechNet and Microsoft Developer Network (MSDN) subscribers — released the update to them shortly thereafter.

Update No. 1: One reader noted that he downloaded SP3 today via a direct link to the executable (which my ZDNet blogging colleague Adrian Kingsley-Hughes pointed to earlier today). A Microsoft spokeswoman said the company is advising users against doing this. The official response:

“Customers should not download Microsoft software from links posted on non-Microsoft websites, when those links point directly to the executable as is the case here. Customers should always download from a page on Microsoft.com that provides all relevant download details, installation instructions, and release notes. In this particular case, it’s possible that some 3rd party websites are linking to the Windows XP SP3 software that we have published for MSDN and TechNet subscribers. Since we cannot confirm the source of every link that 3rd parties provide, out recommendation is that customers wait until we’ve published Windows XP SP3 to Windows Update and the Download Center.”

I have to admit: I’m somewhat surprised Microsoft decided to delay the release of SP3 for RMS. RMS is a retail-chain-management app for small/midsize users. I know very few customers who are using it.

Update No. 2: As a result of this RMS glitch, Microsoft also is temporarily halting the Automatic Download of Vista SP1, as it is affected, as well. But Microsoft is not pulling Vista SP1 from the Download Center or Windows Update.

From a Microsoft spokeswoman:

“Microsoft is temporarily holding any additional automatic distribution of Windows Vista SP1. However, they continue to offer Windows Vista SP1 via Windows Update for interactive installation. While we are recommending that customers running Microsoft Dynamics RMS should not install SP1, there are many other customers who can benefit from installing Windows Vista SP1 immediately, so we are maintaining availability via WU.”

This isn’t the first time Microsoft has temporarily halted distribution of Vista SP1 via Automatic Updates; it did so earlier this year when a pre-requisite for the service pack resulted in problems for some Vista users.

Mary Jo FoleyMary Jo has covered the tech industry for more than 20 years. Don't miss a single post. Subscribe via Email or RSS. You can also follow Mary Jo on Twitter.

Got a tip? Send Mary Jo your rants, rumors, tips and tattles. For disclosure on Mary Jo's industry affiliations, click here or to see Mary Jo's full profile click here.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 151 Talkback(s)
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all
convert swf to avi with swf to avi converter is the best choice to do the conversion with good picture and sound quality.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: slionnmelissa Posted on: 11/10/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  Loverock Davidson | 04/29/08
all bugs?  jnk_zdnet | 04/29/08
MS has released more buggy...  bjbrock | 04/29/08
i couldn't agree more ...  jnk_zdnet | 04/29/08
acceptance of mediocrity  am@... | 05/02/08
Ah, but...  CreepinJesus | 04/30/08
Let me understand this...  thx-1138_@... | 04/30/08
It's Loverock "Windoze Bigot" Davidson - WHAT do you expect?  drprodny | 05/02/08
bugs and bloatware  jrfoleyjr@... | 05/03/08
pc act atack  pc cat atack | 05/26/08
Bwahahahaha!!!!  ejhonda | 04/29/08
But Vista SP 1 is...  jasonp@... | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  tworivers1 | 04/29/08
Oh, it probably *installed* OK  Mahegan | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  jay@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  mtrltd@... | 04/29/08
No (nt)  roaming | 04/30/08
But ZDNET put a link to it...  ceo@... | 04/29/08
What gives the link is still live !!  kchahal | 04/29/08
SP3 already installed on my machine  glenn_primm@... | 04/29/08
"doesn't work properly"  Holger178 | 04/29/08
LOL!  thx-1138_@... | 04/30/08
PLEASE TELL US THE URL of your Download?  estonijaan | 04/29/08
Here ...  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 04/30/08
Probably not the actual RTW file...  ruprick_z | 04/29/08
Downloaded and installed...  jmiller1978 | 04/29/08
*The* quickest and easiest here  goyta | 04/29/08
WHERE do you download XP SP3  estonijaan | 04/29/08
pc cat atack  pc cat atack | 05/26/08
WHERE did you get XP SP3?  estonijaan | 04/29/08
The contents of that file ...  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 04/29/08
Oh No !!!  ralphdb@... | 04/29/08
Bloggers in general a very unprofessional.  bjbrock | 04/29/08
A few points ...  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 04/29/08
English, again  oregonnerd13 | 05/02/08
Yes! Thank you for catching that, Glenn! happy  drprodny | 05/02/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  caryyy | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  davey23 | 04/29/08
some would argue  rtk | 04/29/08
Others would argue  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 04/30/08
Monopolistic practice???  cholzwarth | 05/02/08
windows xp sp3  santu makal | 06/16/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  lrwagner@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  Bryce White | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  fallout330@... | 04/29/08
Can we get UAC??? Huh, huh, huh??????  Starderup | 04/29/08
Better way than disabling it, i think.  April May | 04/29/08
April May you will find on zdnet a lot of the talkback posters like to  SO.CAL Guy | 04/30/08
Exaggerate?  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 04/30/08
You know....  BitTwiddler | 04/29/08
hahahaha!  Hobyx | 05/02/08
Oh groan...bunch of morons up there  roger@... | 04/29/08
Lack of understanding.  April May | 04/29/08
No shuch experience with Linux  Ole Man | 04/29/08
Out come the MS apologists  Richard Flude | 04/29/08
True that...  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 04/30/08
Thanks for the laugh  bobd08 | 04/30/08
So . . .  zclayton2 | 04/30/08
Maybe not 8.04 just yet....  kandyass@... | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  salliemander63@... | 04/29/08
Question on Vista  rhomp2002@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  ZombyWulf | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  bob.g.brooks@... | 04/29/08
NOT suprised as I will NOT be applying it ......  carlsf@... | 04/29/08
Did anyone understand what he just said?  jmiller1978 | 04/29/08
It is just that way  green alien | 04/29/08
i think he said  SO.CAL Guy | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  Leap44Bedford | 04/29/08
XP SP3  natemark@... | 04/29/08
XP SP3  natemark@... | 04/29/08
No problems with XP SP3 here either  BlueCollarGeek | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  bigbob06010@... | 04/29/08
What did I download?  Barry ZA | 04/29/08
I thought you were ANTIM$  No_Ax_to_Grind | 04/29/08
How's That Yahoo Takeover Coming Bitty?  itanalyst2@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  wcbark@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  Pooch666 | 04/29/08
Yeah, good job. After all, we ALL run that application...  BitTwiddler | 04/29/08
It's not that simple  Michael Kelly | 04/29/08
They have there hands in too many cookie jars  Randalllind | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  robinsonky | 04/29/08
RMS rock-solid. What's the " incompatibility?"  archetuthus | 04/29/08
Probably something else  Samun56 | 04/29/08
RMS Incompatibility  me06108 | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  tenrun@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  ai193@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  earthgiant@... | 04/29/08
Switching to Apple because of one crash?  jmiller1978 | 04/29/08
re: Switching to Apple because of one crash?  Gis Bun | 04/30/08
This is about Microsoft Dynamics Retail Management System  LilBambi_z | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  tedrad@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  Pooch666 | 04/29/08
Some of this FCC scanning is working  BALTHOR | 04/29/08
Affects RMS?? What about third-party products?  smqadri@... | 04/29/08
I Was Kinda Wondering That Myself  dumptux | 04/30/08
In responding to BitTwiddler, it got me thinking  Michael Kelly | 04/29/08
Perhaps testing...  Anton Philidor | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  leigh@... | 04/29/08
Any more details on that problem?  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 04/29/08
"M$ is fudging the truth here"  Ole Man | 04/29/08
about as many times as you ole man lol  SO.CAL Guy | 04/30/08
i've installed it on 43 computers so far with no issues at all  SO.CAL Guy | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  ritchingsrj@... | 04/29/08
Windows XP SP3  BClark31@... | 04/29/08
Sorry to hear that  TheGooch1 | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  MichaelG@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  atari8bit@... | 04/29/08
So whats the big deal, I can wait a bit longer  toviz@... | 04/29/08
Missing the point.  bobd08 | 04/30/08
Who Cares About this  TheGooch1 | 04/30/08
well said TheGooch1  SO.CAL Guy | 04/30/08
Another M$ shill heard from  bobd08 | 05/04/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  ralphdb@... | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  billland | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  medusa88@... | 04/29/08
Is it me, or does this poster....  dcbarry | 04/29/08
RE: XP SP3 not ... No big surprise ...  TiggerTom | 04/29/08
SP3 Installed, then deleted  cosmicfoole@... | 04/29/08
Undocumented / Hidden APIs  rlehan@... | 04/30/08
It's a secret, silly (classified as a "trade secret")  Ole Man | 04/30/08
To Everyone Questioning  Rnadmo | 04/30/08
Linux has a multitude of problems  TheGooch1 | 04/30/08
Having trouble staying on topic?  Ole Man | 04/30/08
Interesting  bobd08 | 05/02/08
Hey! Mary Jo!  n0lxx-mark@... | 04/30/08
Sounds like Vista type problems are coming with SP3  ron@... | 04/30/08
"Users" need to understand  Ole Man | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  SurfRover | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  richard.misson@... | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  davidlaska@... | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  lazarus0@... | 04/30/08
Just Tell MS to call both RMS users and tell them not to update  Uber Dweeb | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  ingber@... | 04/30/08
Dying relics and the birth of exuberance and innovation  puterg33k | 04/30/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  becabill@... | 05/01/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  becabill@... | 05/01/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  becabill@... | 05/01/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  becabill@... | 05/01/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  kerryp24 | 05/02/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  JohnWBruce | 05/02/08
delay for bugfix? good!  Hobyx | 05/02/08
RE:Microsoft and some problems with, eh, English  oregonnerd13 | 05/02/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  jrfoleyjr@... | 05/03/08
Actually, what drives defects is the method...  jdickey | 05/03/08
RE: XP SP3 DRM install  do it yourself IT | 05/05/08
Need I say I told you so?  Ole Man | 05/05/08
hr hr hr  do it yourself IT | 05/06/08
You're one up on them now  Ole Man | 05/06/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  fasill | 09/06/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  maxjohn4 | 11/28/08
RE: XP SP3 not generally available yet, after all  slionnmelissa | 11/10/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Order Microsoft 2.0

Pre-order Microsoft 2.0

Order 'Microsoft 2.0' by Mary Jo Foley at Amazon.com.

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here