On TechRepublic: Why Android beats iPhone
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

June 24th, 2009

Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it

Posted by Mary Jo Foley @ 1:37 pm

Categories: App Compatibility, Corporate strategy, Exchange Server, Office, Office 2007, Office 2010/Office 14

Tags: HTML, Microsoft Corp., Microsoft Outlook, E-mail, Microsoft Office, Groupware, Microsoft Word, Word Processors, Office Suites, Software

Microsoft’s decision to change the rendering engine in its Outlook mail client from HTML to the Word rendering engine back in 2007 wasn’t one of its most popular moves. In fact, there are still more than a few Outlook users who are hoping against hope that an online campaign might result in Microsoft backtracking with Outlook 2010 and going back to HTML rendering.

Microsoft’s response: Outlook isn’t broken and Outlook 2010 will include the Word rendering engine, just like Outlook 2007 does.

The Outlook team posted its response to the Twitter-based campaign designed to convince the company to go back to the HTML rendering default on the Outlook Team blog on June 24. From that post:

“First, while we don’t yet have a broadly-available beta version of Microsoft Office 2010, we can confirm that Outlook 2010 does use Word 2010 for composing and displaying e-mail, just as it did in Office 2007. We’ve made the decision to continue to use Word for creating e-mail messages because we believe it’s the best e-mail authoring experience around, with rich tools that our Word customers have enjoyed for over 25 years. Our customers enjoy using a familiar and powerful tool for creating e-mail, just as they do for creating documents. Word enables Outlook customers to write professional-looking and visually stunning e-mail messages.”

The post, authored by William Kennedy. Corporate Vice President of the Office Communications and Forms Team, goes on to say that there is no consensus in the industry around which subset of HTML would be appropriate for e-mail. He blogged:

“There is no widely-recognized consensus in the industry about what subset of HTML is appropriate for use in e-mail for interoperability. The ‘Email Standards Project’ does not represent a sanctioned standard or an industry consensus in this area. Should such a consensus arise, we will of course work with other e-mail vendors to provide rich support in our products.”

Microsoft reiterated the reasons it moved from HTML to Word for e-mail rendering in athis white paper.

What do you say, Outlook users? Do you think Microsoft is right in sticking with Word as the default e-mail rendering engine for Outlook 2010?

Mary Jo FoleyMary Jo has covered the tech industry for more than 20 years. Don't miss a single post. Subscribe via Email or RSS. You can also follow Mary Jo on Twitter.

Got a tip? Send Mary Jo your rants, rumors, tips and tattles. For disclosure on Mary Jo's industry affiliations, click here or to see Mary Jo's full profile click here.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 135 Talkback(s)
outlook is a resource hog and a virus spreader stop using it problem solved
outlook is just another example of how poorly microsoft codes things. every application is reliant on something from another application.
outlook itself is a massive resource hog. stop using it and... (Read the rest)
Posted by: bspurloc Posted on: 07/16/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
the Customer, the Choice! or NOT!  AndyG-Van | 06/24/09
Ha ha ha  justthinking | 06/24/09
If Microsoft said it's not broken, then it's not broken.  AdventTech67 | 06/24/09
Kind of like an Apple computer...  Cayble | 06/24/09
Would have been nice to point out Gmail and Notes do this also  midcapwarrior@... | 06/25/09
if is a popular software then critic it.  magallanes | 06/25/09
Market  MetaPhaze | 06/28/09
MetaPhaze: If You Have No Need for Microsoft Product  jeff.walton.mn | 06/28/09
re: religeous[sic] people  notsofast | 07/10/09
Outlook's not broken....  jeverettk | 06/25/09
if it's not broken ... it's "F.A.D."  Ron_007 | 06/25/09
The "10% features" argument works against MS here..  dave.leigh@... | 06/24/09
Backwards commentary doesn't work.  Cayble | 06/24/09
You don't get the math...  Metronome49 | 06/25/09
So take your own advice and stop using backwards reasoning.  dave.leigh@... | 06/26/09
Less On  medezark@... | 06/25/09
Really? None?  daengbo | 06/25/09
Check your facts  grail@... | 06/25/09
I already did  dave.leigh@... | 06/26/09
That's just about the dumbest analogy I've ever read online. !  BitTwiddler | 06/25/09
that's right, it would be so hard to give users choice  stevey_d | 06/25/09
Umm - from or too Outlook?  spacecase2 | 06/24/09
Standards are limited  John Zern | 06/24/09
Nice theoretical plug.  nizuse | 06/24/09
hey, feel free to send outlook mails to the 1% of people out there with it  stevey_d | 06/25/09
hey, feel free to send outlook mails to the 1% of people out there with it  ICUR12 | 06/25/09
more than 50% of the top 100 US firms use Lotus Notes - Jan 2009  stevey_d | 06/25/09
not true  paul.froehle@... | 06/26/09
Forced?!?!?!  cornpie | 06/24/09
I'd say 95% that use Outlook are forced to do so by their company  BitTwiddler | 06/25/09
Forced?????  thbarnhill | 06/25/09
Forced  jasmo380@... | 06/25/09
could it be that non-evil corps still don't have YOUR interests at heart?  stevey_d | 06/25/09
strawman - he said "users are forced"  stevey_d | 06/25/09
I am in no way condoning Outlook  SamCPP | 06/28/09
They could improve Word's HTML rendering, but it does raise a good question  LeoD | 06/24/09
Most users do not care  pauliusp | 06/24/09
The issue is Outlook cannot display CSS email from other clients  LeoD | 06/24/09
CSS Email  PedroTabs | 06/24/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  golstat2003 | 06/24/09
Can I have some drugs too?!!  HypnoToad72 | 06/24/09
Maybe if you learned how to support it?  wolf_z | 06/24/09
why not move to Google apps - no need for support staff  stevey_d | 06/25/09
No software is perfect...  SamCPP | 06/28/09
That's a scary thought  notsofast | 07/10/09
Sounds to me like someone needs training  tech@... | 06/25/09
Eliminate Word  Rick_R | 06/24/09
Wait a minute...  Wolfie2K3 | 06/24/09
And Return to Steam Trains Too ?  RightPaddock | 06/26/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  dave.leigh@... | 06/24/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  oaf357 | 06/24/09
Same here...  Dave32265 | 06/24/09
Yes but will be nice when calendar is integrated properly N/T  SamCPP | 06/28/09
Here's some thoughts...  GoodThings2Life | 06/24/09
You want one example? I've got hundreds.  dave.leigh@... | 06/24/09
That was "from", these are "to"  dave.leigh@... | 06/24/09
Sorry...  GoodThings2Life | 06/24/09
Right... limit yourself instead of asking Microsoft to change.  Metronome49 | 06/25/09
"frivolous marketing-type email" Are you kidding?  Spats30 | 06/25/09
The length you're going to justify your point is crazy  stevey_d | 06/25/09
I see...  dave.leigh@... | 06/27/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  MyBlueRex | 06/24/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  Unc Al | 06/24/09
"abends" ?  MyBlueRex | 06/24/09
Outlook is broken  nizuse | 06/24/09
Incorrect  MyBlueRex | 06/24/09
Correct  nizuse | 06/24/09
Incorrect  midcapwarrior@... | 06/25/09
WRONG:  stevey_d | 06/25/09
AND HERE: How to tell OUTLOOK not to send windat  stevey_d | 06/25/09
Wow...  jasonp@... | 06/25/09
yeah I know. If you use Outlook and you want others to read your mails...  stevey_d | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  ron@... | 06/24/09
Users should vote with their dollars  chrome_slinky@... | 06/24/09
So then, MS is no different then anyone else  John Zern | 06/24/09
Name one company  nizuse | 06/24/09
We Hate Microsoft!  thbarnhill | 06/25/09
using the same mail format as the rest of the world isn't a minor thing  stevey_d | 06/25/09
It's not the users doing the voting when it comes to Office  BitTwiddler | 06/25/09
Yeah, but why is that?  thbarnhill | 06/25/09
Bingo!  ejhonda | 06/25/09
yeah, let MSFT protect - ahem, kill - their sacred cash cows  sheeskebab | 06/24/09
Outlook is an e-mail app?  register@... | 06/24/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  Xeon21 | 06/25/09
Outlook IS broken but in so many other ways!  c_grey@... | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  sevans26 | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  gllincoln | 06/25/09
!!! the most popular email client in the world??!!  stevey_d | 06/25/09
Instead of worrying about rendering...  OrganGrinderEleven | 06/25/09
sounds like IMAP is going away in  xXSpeedzXx | 06/25/09
re: thunderbird  brutallyfrank | 06/25/09
IMAP TBird & OL  RightPaddock | 06/26/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  rgbigel | 06/25/09
Microsoft continues making decisions FOR us  BitTwiddler | 06/25/09
What ribbon in 2007 version  tm2guy@... | 06/26/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  Doug0915 | 06/25/09
everyone else is using it happily  stevey_d | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  jgurtz | 06/25/09
I Prefer Word  payton@... | 06/25/09
Use the most widely recognized open standard.  brutallyfrank | 06/25/09
Microsoft Outlook.. Really?..  SystemVoid | 06/25/09
Because of Exchange  robert_rowe@... | 06/25/09
why use awful legacy products like exchange?  stevey_d | 06/25/09
Who really cares?  No_Ax_to_Grind | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  paul.simpson@... | 06/25/09
Doesn't work with Gmail  midcapwarrior@... | 06/25/09
See there, you do have a choice  polar_bare | 06/25/09
perhaps you're ignoring a large anger in your staff  stevey_d | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  mlevison | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  bcclendinen@... | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  1djk1 | 06/25/09
RE: GMail... here I come  Olderdan | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  dobick@... | 06/25/09
Microsoft in denial again?  comp_indiana | 06/25/09
Breaking the Web: The Document War between HTML and OOXML  gary_edwards | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  Kim Greve | 06/25/09
Good  Resuna | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  lawryll@... | 06/25/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  athaki | 06/25/09
Using Word isn't the problem, that Word is not standards compliant...  pico_D | 06/26/09
I will change to an external search tool.  dan.biggs@... | 06/26/09
Send email in formats anyone can read  cquirke | 06/26/09
This is all I want  RightPaddock | 06/26/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  jfreedle2@... | 06/26/09
I've had it crap out on me....  storm14k | 06/26/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  MetaPhaze | 06/28/09
Does this mean I will not be able to ...  mwagner@... | 06/29/09
Still can read Outlook mail on your blackberry  LizaJay | 06/29/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  Cardhu | 06/30/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  Chrissd | 07/02/09
True to form  Ole Man | 07/03/09
RE: Microsoft: Outlook's not broken and we aren't 'fixing' it  motorhead1979@... | 07/06/09
Microsoft OOXML: Dead Format Walking  Ole Man | 07/06/09
HTML loops can crash email clients  rwgreene | 07/15/09
outlook is a resource hog and a virus spreader stop using it problem solved  bspurloc | 07/16/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Order Microsoft 2.0

Pre-order Microsoft 2.0

Order 'Microsoft 2.0' by Mary Jo Foley at Amazon.com.

Recent Entries

Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors
advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Enterprise Applications

  • Check out some of the easiest and most powerful ways to boost productivity while saving money on your application infrastructure. See ZDNet's comprehensive Enterprise Application resource center, now!
  • New Online Dashboard
  • Read about top issues IT decision-makers face every day, plus get cost effective solutions to real life IT problems. Oracle Topline