On CHOW: Sexy vampire party
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

May 30th, 2007

Do you want a Surface computer?

Posted by Mary Jo Foley @ 6:23 am

Categories: Code names, Corporate strategy, Windows Mobile, Xbox, Zune

Tags: Mary Jo Foley

Microsoft went public at 12:01 a.m. on May 30 with the name of its “Milan”/PlayTable technology. The combined hardware/software device is now known as the Microsoft Surface and is due to debut in November.

In one of many press releases on Milan and surface computing on Microsoft’s PressPass site this morning, there is a Q&A with Tom Gibbons, the corporate VP in charge of Microsoft’s Productivity and Extended Consumer Experiences Group. Gibbons describes the move Microsoft is expecting to surface computing being “as significant as the move from DOS [Disk Operating System] to GUI [Graphic User Interface].”

Wow. That’s a pretty big claim for something that currently seems very niche to me. Even though the first set of announced customers for Surface are big businesses (T-Mobile, Starwood, Harrah’s), ultimately, Microsoft seems to see the Surface Computer as a consumer product.

But do I really need a table at a restaurant (or in my home) to tell me the best food pairings for my wine choice? Or to generate for me a customized version of a map of local attractions?

Unless there are some surface-computing form factors that don’t look like a chunky coffee table or a retail-store kiosk, I have zero interest in a Surface. For now, the first iterations of Microsoft’s Surface Computer seem a lot to me like the first “Origami” ultra-mobile PCs: Products in search of a market. (And not very well-designed products, at that.)

Even though Microsoft isn’t talking publicly about how and where else the Milan surface/multi-touch technology may figure, Long Zheng over at istartedsomething.com discovered some interesting hints. Zheng found hidden in a Flash file that’s part of Surface collateral an intersting reference: “Microsoft’s New Milan Media Player on Store Shelves on Nov 14.” Sure sounds like a Zune with a multi-touch display to me….

I’m curious. Am I the only one out there who sees the Surface computer as about as cuddly as a point-of-sale terminal?

[Poll=9]

Mary Jo FoleyMary Jo has covered the tech industry for more than 20 years. Don't miss a single post. Subscribe via Email or RSS. You can also follow Mary Jo on Twitter.

Got a tip? Send Mary Jo your rants, rumors, tips and tattles. For disclosure on Mary Jo's industry affiliations, click here or to see Mary Jo's full profile click here.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 110 Talkback(s)
I think Microsoft's surface computing is very forward thinking
I generally take the side opposite Microsoft at just about every opportunity I can. In this case I think they got something. Not so much with the angle of the monitor but with the software behind th... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Sijanus Posted on: 06/28/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
No surface for me ...  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
My neck hurts already  Viddy.Roberts | 05/30/07
Surface Video  Alber1690 | 05/30/07
My arms are hurting just watching that demo !  raycote | 05/30/07
Think of the fun you could have with it...  lisacate@... | 06/01/07
A whole new way to play Galaga!  jkinner | 05/30/07
Very Significant Innovation  samirsshah@... | 05/30/07
But it's not a Microsoft innovation  filipiak | 05/30/07
Here is the actual technology ...  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
You are looking at only 1 piece  NonZealot | 05/30/07
Implementation yes, Innovation no ...  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
Innovation  toadlife | 05/30/07
Which dictionary?  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
Trolling 101 by NonZealot ___formerly known as PC-Zealot - NT  raycote | 05/30/07
Wondered how long it would be for Linux zealots to want one  lisacate@... | 06/14/07
For a more accurate history of this technology  marksashton | 05/30/07
That is known ...  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
Apple loses this round  Qbt | 05/30/07
Apple and Microsoft already beaten ....  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
Once again...  Qbt | 05/30/07
it's not the table that recognizes the camera ...  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
What does it matter?  NonZealot | 05/30/07
Wrong!  Qbt | 05/30/07
Though I'm late to the party here...  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
Come on BedWetter, we had the table PacMans in restaurants 20 years ago.  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
I think...  Qbt | 05/30/07
Again, touch screen, table top, image reconition, auto detecting devices,  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
Oh Donnie Boy  Blogsworth | 05/30/07
Ok, tell us what MS invented here??  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
In case you didn't know  toadlife | 05/30/07
Table PacMans  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
iPhones all around doesn't sound like Apple's lost anything  YinToYourYang-22527499 | 05/30/07
Toll compares pocket sized iPhone to table sized PC - NT  raycote | 05/30/07
Ring-ring, ring-ring  Len Rooney | 06/04/07
Apple didn't invent anything here....  marksashton | 05/30/07
Sigh. The Strawman still lives  frgough | 05/30/07
frgough is right  NonZealot | 05/30/07
So your point is - there is no such thing product innovation cause DUH! -NT  raycote | 05/30/07
He is not redefining anything  toadlife | 05/30/07
Strawman, indeed  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
Apple envisions the future and creates it  YinToYourYang-22527499 | 05/30/07
Apple envisions overpriced hardware  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
And neither did Microsoft ...  George Mitchell | 05/30/07
Hey, I posted the link  marksashton | 05/30/07
The iPhone is an affordable hand held device immediate useful to many ! NT  raycote | 05/30/07
Define "Affordable" Please...  Wolfie2K3 | 06/01/07
MS Surface  markhayakawa | 05/30/07
This is FAR better than the iDumbPhone  NonZealot | 05/30/07
Yes, FAR bigger than the iPhone...  MacCanuck | 05/30/07
I rest my case  NonZealot | 05/30/07
Please do -REST YOUR CASE- it is very tired! - NT  raycote | 05/30/07
You're still delusional but no surprise  MacCanuck | 05/31/07
And it only...  msalzberg | 05/30/07
At least we'll be using iPhones in a matter of days  YinToYourYang-22527499 | 05/30/07
This is a HUGE innovation ...  George Mitchell | 05/30/07
Innovate? Ha, ha, ha  YinToYourYang-22527499 | 05/30/07
OK ... I surrender ...  George Mitchell | 05/30/07
It's not even Apple technology ...  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
Didn't Microsoft say that?  filipiak | 05/30/07
Bob and Clippy are genuine innovations!  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
First Demonstration of Multi-Touch Interface  john.murray@... | 05/30/07
No keyboard ?  chuckleberry | 05/30/07
Get real! Totally impractical  robmacleay | 05/30/07
re: Get real! Totally impractical  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
My cat is licking its chops  Viviana Wong | 05/30/07
It's not for "personal computing"  georgeou | 05/30/07
Touch screens, table top computers, auto recognition of devices, were NOT  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
Regarding innovation  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
I thought "mobile computing" was the wave of the future  Userama | 05/30/07
I think the idea has leggs, but at the $1,000 price point, NOT 5-10 grand.  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
any step closer to 'minority report'  leriksen71 | 05/30/07
Has Microsoft jumped the shark? Seems to me this has way to many fancy  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
One only has to watch...  msalzberg | 05/30/07
Perceptive Pixel is preferred ...  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
I agree that the idea of a table top computer is ripe to be exploited.  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
Yes, the possibilities of other people's innovations. MS has deep pockets  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
I would not be to quick to criticize this product ...  George Mitchell | 05/30/07
Great product ... unfortunately just a clone of Apple Multitouch ...  George Mitchell | 05/30/07
Seriously  Qbt | 05/30/07
No innovation here from either Apple or MS. Just one company with deep  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
OK then  Qbt | 05/30/07
Object recognition has been around for years. The camaras attach wirelessly  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
Nobody said  Qbt | 05/30/07
The communication is established when you turn on the camara. If you do NOT  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
It doesn't matter who invented it  Michael Kelly | 05/30/07
Very true, MS is welcome to capitolize on that in the public domain, it is  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
Please  Qbt | 05/30/07
re: Please  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
Question  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
I'm just always on the lookout for something nice to say about Microsoft ..  George Mitchell | 06/01/07
Obvious misunderstanding  M.R. Kennedy | 06/02/07
Still, multi-touch, table top computing, touch screen, have been around for  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
FOR CRYING OUT LOUD PEOPLE...  toadlife | 05/30/07
There is no exact agreement on the definition of "innovation", see  DonnieBoy | 05/30/07
(nt)My point is that it is not interchangable with invention  toadlife | 05/30/07
Of course there is always the possibility ...  George Mitchell | 05/30/07
Ding! Ding! Ding! We have a winner!  MisterMiester | 05/30/07
Innovation  M.R. Kennedy | 05/31/07
Look at them Apple fanboys go!  Qbt | 05/30/07
Not Cunsumer ready yet  daMan25 | 05/31/07
I decide when it is real  mames1701 | 05/31/07
Will you please tell us what of all of this has not been in the public  DonnieBoy | 05/31/07
You continue to be an idiot  M.R. Kennedy | 06/01/07
MS Will Give Them Away as Gifts ...  dhettinger | 05/31/07
it's what I wanted for CAD 20 yrs ago  57ford | 05/31/07
In the order of things . . .  wgraue | 06/01/07
I've seen this before, in a Black Angus Resterant.  starcd53@... | 06/08/07
I can see it's place  spyro17@... | 06/11/07
Amendment  spyro17@... | 06/11/07
I think Microsoft's surface computing is very forward thinking  Sijanus | 06/28/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Click Here
advertisement

Order Microsoft 2.0

Pre-order Microsoft 2.0

Order 'Microsoft 2.0' by Mary Jo Foley at Amazon.com.

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads