On Metacritic: BioShock 2: Inside the reviews
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

November 19th, 2007

Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build

Posted by Mary Jo Foley @ 9:24 am

Categories: Service Pack, Vista, Windows XP, Windows client

Tags: Performance, Microsoft Windows Vista, Microsoft Corp., Microsoft Windows Vista SP1, Microsoft Windows XP Service Pack, Tester, SP1, Microsoft Windows Vista (Longhorn), Microsoft Windows XP, Microsoft Windows

Microsoft has begun rolling out to testers a near-final Release Candidate (RC) build of Windows XP Service Pack (SP) 3.

Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate buildTesters said they began pulling down the bits from Microsoft’s private download site on November 18.

Testers said the new XP SP3 build is designated as a “Release Candidate,” not a preview of a release candidate (as was the case with the new Windows Vista SP1 RC release that went to 15,000 testers last week.

So far, no word back from Microsoft as to how many SP3 testers will be allowed to download the new XP SP3 test build. Last time Microsoft made an XP SP3 test build available — a private build Microsoft delivered in early October — it released the XP SP3 test bits to the same 12,000 folks testing Windows XP SP1.

Looks like my guess on who and how many got the build was good. Here’s a status update from a Microsoft spokesman on the afternoon of November 19:

“Late last week, Windows XP SP3 was made available to about 15,000 beta testers. A broader beta will be available at a later date. We are targeting 1H 2008 for the release of XP SP3 RTM, though our timing will always be based on customer feedback as a first priority.”

Microsoft previously said it plans to release the final version of XP SP3 in the first half of 2008. The final Vista SP1 release is slated to hit in the first calendar quarter of 2008. I’m starting to wonder whether XP SP3 might be released ahead of Vista SP1. “First half” could also mean “first quarter.” From a pure marketing standpoint, I’d think Microsoft would want Vista SP1 out there ahead of XP SP3, so as not to give users one more reason not to move to Vista.

Meanwhile, speaking of SP1, some testers are beginning to weigh in publicly about Microsoft’s latest Vista SP1 test build. And while the verdicts are hardly unanimous — a number of testers are wondering aloud whether SP1 will address Vista performance issues to the extent they hoped.

Microsoft has been positioning SP1, due out in early 2008, as a catch-all build, delivering in one package the various performance, reliability, stability and security fixes that it has been pushing out via Windows Update since Vista was released to manufacturing last fall. A number of the updates included in the test builds of Vista SP1 have been focused on fixing battery life, start up and shutdown time, etc.

Performance is a tough criteria to evaluate, given that every tester has different applications loaded on their machines, not to mention different hardware makes and models. So if you look in the comments of some of the blog posts on SP1 and performance, some testers say they are seeing noticeable Vista performance improvements once they load the SP1 test code.

Anyone out there testing the new XP SP3 RC build and/or the Vista SP1 RC preview? What’s your experience been so far?

Mary Jo FoleyMary Jo has covered the tech industry for more than 20 years. Don't miss a single post. Subscribe via Email or RSS. You can also follow Mary Jo on Twitter.

Got a tip? Send Mary Jo your rants, rumors, tips and tattles. For disclosure on Mary Jo's industry affiliations, click here or to see Mary Jo's full profile click here.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 79 Talkback(s)
some problems that i hope are straightened out
there were a lot of problems such as use of firefox on certain websites and such
i have changed back but SP3 did run a lot smoother despite the major setbacks
i hope they straighten these out before final release... (Read the rest)
Posted by: harrisonmguk@... Posted on: 02/22/08 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Mixed results  Adrian Kingsley-HughesZDNet Moderator | 11/19/07
Won't Vista graphics performance will always be behind XP?  Heatlesssun1 | 11/19/07
Re: Mixed Results  Bill4 | 11/19/07
Performance is fine now in XP  RJ59 | 11/19/07
XP still more stable than Vista  bshirosky@... | 12/04/07
exactly  bshirosky@... | 12/04/07
i game on vista and have tested games on xp and vista and i see no  SO.CAL Guy | 11/21/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  tcole@... | 11/19/07
Windows XP SP3  jbaviera@... | 11/19/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  de9wa645@... | 11/19/07
Already Installed XP SP 3  itanalyst | 11/19/07
DUMB!  TTGIT Guy | 11/19/07
ILLITERATE!  itanalyst | 11/19/07
ROFL  theoxygenthief | 12/18/07
RE: Already Installed XP SP 3  x3@... | 12/07/07
Tip: When doing a story about XP don't talk about Vista  Randalllind | 11/19/07
How True!  janmar4765 | 11/19/07
I agree  BillPStudios | 11/20/07
Add me to the band wagon...  mrOSX | 11/20/07
Errr...  thx-1138_@... | 11/22/07
Here's why Vista need fixed in SP1  Bill4 | 11/19/07
Fire Fox?  Thralni | 11/19/07
Same Mac Mini  Bill4 | 11/19/07
Why's it taking so long  voska | 11/20/07
Please tighten your english.  mbkelly@... | 11/21/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  oreo102007@... | 11/19/07
Pick one or the other  twright@... | 11/19/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  erniem1970@... | 11/19/07
So go with progress, or simply get left behind  jbaviera@... | 11/19/07
You sound crazy, dude...  Chippolus | 11/20/07
Better yet, get off the merry-go-round  Ole Man | 11/20/07
Umm  theoxygenthief | 12/18/07
All the more reason not to get vista.  kraterz | 11/19/07
Wanna bet this will happen?  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 11/20/07
Done already happened  Ole Man | 11/20/07
Good story, too bad it's not true.  rtk | 11/20/07
My computer tells the story  Ole Man | 11/20/07
Most things are lost on you  rtk | 11/20/07
You are correct, except that logic makes sense  Ole Man | 11/21/07
With XP you can get away with it  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 11/21/07
The future is ahead of you  Ole Man | 11/21/07
Like I said...  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 11/21/07
A little secret (to some folks)  Ole Man | 11/21/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  anisahsmith@... | 11/20/07
wahuh?  rtk | 11/20/07
Longer than that  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 11/20/07
So what's in XP 3???  techboy_z | 11/20/07
Good question  itpro_z | 11/20/07
all the patches since SP2 I would say.  Randalllind | 11/20/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  cardinal33 | 11/20/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  marysduby | 11/20/07
Good news  John Musbach | 11/20/07
Windows Me on steroids??  sh_young@... | 11/20/07
Let me get this straight...  itpro_z | 11/20/07
Apoligies, apoligies, apoligies........  Ole Man | 11/20/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  nseshasai@... | 11/21/07
The explanation could be (probably is)  Ole Man | 11/21/07
According to Peter Gutmann so called therory  Michael L Hereid Sr | 11/24/07
Yes, and according to those who were slandering Peter Gutmann  Ole Man | 11/24/07
VISTA migration  SecurityExpert | 11/22/07
Good luck  rtk | 11/22/07
Sorry, you forgot to read the release clause  Ole Man | 11/23/07
RE: VISTA migration  x3@... | 12/07/07
Better Analogy  SecurityExpert | 11/22/07
Sticking with the car analogy.  rtk | 11/22/07
In real life  nizuse | 11/24/07
what i don't understand about EULA's  theoxygenthief | 12/18/07
Comparing your Vista to your new car is easy  Ole Man | 11/23/07
Hilarious - and true  nizuse | 11/24/07
have installed sp3  davidcorley@... | 11/26/07
HOW'D IT WORK ?  denkile | 11/28/07
It breaks RDP  pgm554 | 12/13/07
VisDuh, Need anymore be said?  rossnorrie | 11/27/07
could or couldn't  wayman.holcomb@... | 12/03/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  paulhinz | 12/04/07
RE: Testers get Windows XP Service Pack 3 Release Candidate build  MichaelJB | 12/15/07
one problem  theoxygenthief | 12/18/07
monolopy  theoxygenthief | 12/18/07
some problems that i hope are straightened out  harrisonmguk@... | 02/22/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Order Microsoft 2.0

Pre-order Microsoft 2.0

Order 'Microsoft 2.0' by Mary Jo Foley at Amazon.com.

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads