On mySimon: Christian Louboutin Very Prive Pumps
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

May 1st, 2007

Whose is the standard Linux?

Posted by Dana Blankenhorn @ 9:10 am

Categories: General, Linux, Linux Desktop OS, Strategy, mass market

Tags: Desktop, Ubuntu, Linux, Microsoft Corp., Dana Blankenhorn

In Focus » See more posts on: Windows to Linux Chronicles

We know who runs Windows, we know who runs the Mac. We know whose throat to choke when our PCs go ker-flooey. (Picture from Skeptico.)

Who really runs Linux?

By that I mean, which Linux distro is the standard, the one people write to, the one which will really take on Microsoft for dominance of the future?

As we report today, Dell said it's Ubuntu. The newest version, Feisty Fawn, gets a big thumbs-up from our own Adrian Kingsley-Hughes.

Our package today also asks whether Ubuntu now provides "a mainstream Windows alternative."

Whatever does that mean? I think it means, is Ubuntu now a desktop operating system which can go head-to-head with Windows and win? We have standard Linux distros in RedHat and Novell which work well, but they are primarily server products. That's where the money is.

On the other hand, if Ubuntu does win the "Linux desktop" wars, does that make a standard which application developers must write to? And if running your Linux applications through the Ubuntu distribution becomes the standard practice, doesn't that make Ubuntu the "standard Linux."

After a decade pushing this open source rock up the Microsoft hill, are RedHat, Novell, and all the other American Linux distro vendors going to have to bow before the Isle of Man? I don't know if I can learn English at this late date, having spoken American all my life…

Seriously, though, if history is our guide we may indeed have to learn English. (Colour. Labour. Lift. Loo. Lorry. The Larch.) The original deal between Microsoft and IBM (it was 20 years ago today) was that Microsoft would own the desktop and IBM would own everything else. Once Microsoft got the desktop right, there was no everything else to own.

Is there any good footy on the telly? Fetch me the Sun and let's see what those daffy Royals are up to.

Which Linux distro is the standard?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Dana BlankenhornDana Blankenhorn has been a business journalist for 30 years, a tech freelancer since 1983. You can follow Dana on Twitter. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Dana Blankenhorn

Subscribe to Linux and Open Source via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 75 Talkback(s)
standard Linux?
First you equate Linux with a company.This is wrong. You ignore the fact that Linux is basically the kernel that was invented and is maintained by Linus Torvalds, plus the utilities, tools, libraries,... (Read the rest)
Posted by: rnojonson@... Posted on: 02/06/08 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Ubuntu  cyngaines | 05/01/07
The money's on the server.  Anton Philidor | 05/01/07
ANton - you've stopped taking your sedatives again!  bportlock | 05/01/07
Dell doesn't want to bring down Microsoft.  Anton Philidor | 05/01/07
Sorry Anton  bportlock | 05/01/07
There is no standard  epcraig | 05/05/07
And I removed Suse as crap....  linux for me | 05/01/07
I wouldn't refer to any OS as crap  intrepi@... | 05/02/07
Seems like...  D. T. Schmitz | 05/01/07
Anybody'd think you thought this was about the software.  Anton Philidor | 05/01/07
Debian  Yndoendo | 05/01/07
I'd have to say Debian would be the Standard  intrepi@... | 05/02/07
DEBIAN?  mbishop1113 | 05/03/07
SuSE?  Tim Patterson | 05/03/07
I agree  mcwise@... | 05/02/07
Ubuntu is poster child, Debian is standard.  supercalifragilistic | 05/03/07
Maybe  Tim Patterson | 05/03/07
Linux=Choice=Many Distros  Don Collins | 05/01/07
Male Bovine Excrement  Yagotta B. Kidding | 05/01/07
Apparently . . .  jlhenry62 | 05/01/07
Like that! well put  fr0thy2. | 05/02/07
I disagree  Linux User 147560 | 05/01/07
What complete and utter cr*p!  bportlock | 05/01/07
Don't speak for me ...  MisterMiester | 05/01/07
Right heading- wrong assumption  intrepi@... | 05/02/07
And that's is exactly why...  fr0thy2. | 05/02/07
Primary aim?  Freebird54 | 05/02/07
None of the above  Yagotta B. Kidding | 05/01/07
True, but, since it creates less confusion if you can just test to Ubuntu.  DonnieBoy | 05/01/07
The problem with your analogy is...  voyager529 | 05/02/07
I have to agree with you on Standard  intrepi@... | 05/02/07
Ah, the art of language ...  MisterMiester | 05/01/07
Ubantu said, this is just a stepping  No_Ax_to_Grind | 05/01/07
No, Ubuntu will stay in the Desktop to maintain the loyalty of the guys  DonnieBoy | 05/01/07
not quite  TtfnJohn | 05/02/07
Ubuntu = Moving toward desktop 'de facto standard'  Mercutio_Viz | 05/01/07
Enterprise - Small Business - SOHO  pfries@... | 05/02/07
The good thing is that Ubuntu is 100% open, so the other players CAN make  DonnieBoy | 05/01/07
And, all this time I thought it was a "Gringo"  DonnieBoy | 05/01/07
only one kernel.org  ruped24 | 05/01/07
I'm surprised nobody mentioned LSB yet  Tony Agudo | 05/01/07
HDPARM =$(which hdparm)  ruped24 | 05/01/07
Thanks  Tony Agudo | 05/01/07
LSB? what about...  Arm A. Geddon | 05/02/07
That helps too  Tony Agudo | 05/02/07
The Desktop  xstep | 05/02/07
The cost per machine to pre-load the codecs and flash would be minimal. If  DonnieBoy | 05/02/07
LSB is being integrated into Ubuntu...  shryko | 05/02/07
What about Linspire?  pfyearwood | 05/02/07
This article is a Red Herring, indeed  zaine_ridling | 05/02/07
you miss the point!  voyager529 | 05/02/07
which is more important?  four-eyes_z | 05/02/07
There's a certification program?  zaine_ridling | 05/02/07
No  macoafi | 05/03/07
Bingo!  ruped24 | 05/02/07
Your statements are so wrong  intrepi@... | 05/02/07
Oh, I'm wrong all right  zaine_ridling | 05/02/07
Linus  sysop-dr | 05/02/07
I'd say you are right to some extent  intrepi@... | 05/02/07
I prefer Mandriva  TtfnJohn | 05/02/07
Glad to read your post on Mandriva  intrepi@... | 05/02/07
The best positioned ... Novell.  p_msac@... | 05/02/07
Now is the time to strike!  mikifinaz1@... | 05/02/07
desktop, the final frontier NT  ruped24 | 05/02/07
There is no Linux standard  rc76058@... | 05/02/07
simple (if rpm alien) || (if deb alien)  ruped24 | 05/02/07
SUSE anyday  philip.lane@... | 05/03/07
It depends what you're doing  macoafi | 05/03/07
Linux on Dead Badger  D. T. Schmitz | 05/03/07
Whatever Linus Puts Out  tottinge | 05/04/07
Amen!  tottinge | 05/04/07
well written apps are platform-neutral  cls@... | 05/08/07
GoboLinux  eaglet3d | 05/10/07
Will Ubuntu dominate?  ghawkins@... | 05/29/07
standard Linux?  rnojonson@... | 02/06/08

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
Click Here

Recent Entries

Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

Click Here