On mySimon: Peg Perego John Deere Utility Tractor
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

August 3rd, 2007

Has Ubuntu clinched the desktop Linux market?

Posted by Dana Blankenhorn @ 7:15 am

Categories: Distributions, General, Hardware, Linux, Linux Desktop OS, Strategy, mass market

Tags: Desktop, Ubuntu, Linux, Desktop Linux, Dana Blankenhorn

Dell Ubuntu Linux from IndiecomOn the surface a two-month delay in Red Hat’s release of Global Desktop Linux is no big deal. (Picture of a Dell laptop running Ubuntu from Indiecom.)

The aim of the project is not just to deliver an operating system, but a complete environment, including applications, aimed at the mass market.

Some feel there are too many Linux distributions, and in the server area I disagree, since the distros are basically compatible. But in the desktop space things may be different. To beat Windows we may need unity.

And increasingly I’m seeing desktop Linux coalesce around Ubuntu. Dell now sells Ubuntu. Acer is selling it in Singapore. No other distro has these kinds of big company endorsements. Whether they’re worthwhile is another question.  

That’s mainly because Ubuntu specializes in desktops. Its key advantage is localization. You can get Ubuntu in more languages than you can Windows, with local language support. Canonical has worked hard to make this happen.

For companies like Red Hat, on the other hand, desktop Linux is a project, a loss-leader, a sideline. The success or failure of its desktop Linux initiative will not make-or-break Red Hat.

That’s the problem. Dedication is the key to success in everything. It’s rare that you find great success in a sideline.

Were this a breakfast plate, Red Hat would represent the eggs and Ubuntu the bacon. The chicken’s involved but the pig is committed.  

So are the desktop Linux wars over?

Dana BlankenhornDana Blankenhorn has been a business journalist for 30 years, a tech freelancer since 1983. You can follow Dana on Twitter. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Dana Blankenhorn

Subscribe to Linux and Open Source via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 188 Talkback(s)
Rally Around Ubuntu
As a User of the the Sister O.S., Kubuntu, I see no reason to rally around this dostro any O.S. with "Ubuntu" in the name. Twice, while upgrading, the upgrade application deleted EVERYTHING!... (Read the rest)
Posted by: The Rifleman Posted on: 08/27/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Why should there be a war?  John L. Ries | 08/03/07
Because war sells  John Zern | 08/03/07
War sells  Boot_Agnostic | 08/06/07
This is...  cashaww | 08/06/07
Competition leads to improved products ...  mwagner@... | 08/06/07
Preinstallation fallacy  Update victim | 08/06/07
True, but...  John L. Ries | 08/06/07
Ultimately, Linux vendors ...  mwagner@... | 08/06/07
Disagree with this  Update victim | 08/06/07
why do we have the "Geek Squad"  bmore_bro69@... | 08/06/07
According to what we've been hearing on ZDNet  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Most are Average Users  jkaiserling@... | 08/06/07
The "Why" of Geek Squad and Firedog...  Wolfie2K3 | 08/06/07
Average Users  aallord | 08/06/07
MS help sucks  Greenknight_z | 08/07/07
Because there are 100's of millions of Windows users  Cayble | 08/07/07
Computer hardware WAS expensive  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Ms vs Ubuntu Vs Save Tucker  user@... | 08/06/07
One problem there  gene_fitz@... | 08/08/07
Linux is Linux, now which Distro do you prefer?  steve@... | 08/06/07
RE: Linux is linux, ....  GreyGeek | 08/06/07
Desktop Linux wars?  Anton Philidor | 08/03/07
Ubuntu only makes money off selling premium support  maldain | 08/03/07
Well...  Anton Philidor | 08/03/07
Since you asked  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/03/07
Good thing...  Anton Philidor | 08/03/07
Epistemology  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/03/07
Quotes  Anton Philidor | 08/03/07
Hate to be critical, Anton  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Software Sales and Rumors of War  DannyO_0x98 | 08/04/07
Thank you Anton  Update victim | 08/06/07
RE: Suppose you recieved a bill ...  GreyGeek | 08/06/07
Linux!  cheesyone | 08/07/07
I have a problem with the word "war"  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 08/03/07
Well, it's your word.  Anton Philidor | 08/06/07
Why?  cashaww | 08/06/07
The BIG THREE were hung out to dry ...  mwagner@... | 08/06/07
Don't forget Toyotas in Kentucky!! happy (nt)  JLHenry | 08/06/07
What has your message got to do with Linux and Distributions  zczc2311 | 08/06/07
HEy!! THis is . . .  JLHenry | 08/06/07
Bragging rights ...  mwagner@... | 08/06/07
Prize not worth winning.  Anton Philidor | 08/06/07
"Red Hat monopoly"?  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Microsoft isn't in the Linux server business...  Anton Philidor | 08/06/07
Yadda yadda yadda  Ole Man | 08/06/07
, and sometimes....  handydan918 | 08/06/07
Nobody wants support anyway  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Did I miss something?  cheesyone | 08/07/07
Wrong Attitude  Real World | 08/03/07
As soon as you understand...  Confused by religion | 08/03/07
right  Real World | 08/03/07
Sources  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/03/07
Just because  Real World | 08/03/07
What's the use of being dismissive...  John L. Ries | 08/03/07
What frustrates me  Real World | 08/03/07
Which is ironic really...  odubtaig | 08/03/07
To RealWorld  John L. Ries | 08/03/07
In response to John L Ries  GuidingLight | 08/03/07
to John L. Ries  Real World | 08/06/07
I never dismiss views with valid opinions -  Confused by religion | 08/03/07
Milly....  LazLong | 08/03/07
Cognitive dissonance  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/05/07
they flourish when they have successfully eradicated any competing theolog  deaf_e_kate | 08/05/07
eclectic religion  reedjjjr | 08/06/07
Now you are just...  cashaww | 08/06/07
Behind the "religion"  Craigerjack | 08/06/07
In this case victory means survival  maldain | 08/03/07
When Microsoft agreed to sell Linux...  Anton Philidor | 08/03/07
Well, now they are.  odubtaig | 08/03/07
Live with the companies that produce Linux.  Anton Philidor | 08/03/07
Religosity of both sides  owner@... | 08/06/07
When you forget the crimes one has commited  Ole Man | 08/06/07
I completely...  cashaww | 08/06/07
Think again  Real World | 08/08/07
What is meant by "beating Windows"  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Win the desktops, and you wil win the servers  tristanrhodes | 08/03/07
This is something I always assumed...but..  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 08/03/07
Not so simple  zoroaster | 08/04/07
Different Distros for different purposes.  russell@... | 08/03/07
Ubuntu, most popular  xstep | 08/03/07
How about application support?  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 08/03/07
RE: How about application support?  ruped24 | 08/03/07
There's the Debian repositories, all 14 CDs worth.  odubtaig | 08/04/07
Application support  cheesyone | 08/07/07
RE: Ubuntu, most popular  GreyGeek | 08/06/07
It's the Year of Linux...  frgough | 08/03/07
it will never be the year of linux  rabbitnightmare | 08/04/07
You are correct  Linux User 147560 | 08/06/07
Windows?  cheesyone | 08/07/07
The trademark  alaniane@... | 08/08/07
For now, maybe  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/03/07
absolutelly not  rabbitnightmare | 08/03/07
huh?  zoroaster | 08/04/07
driverhunt?  rabbitnightmare | 08/04/07
Because I too have had to fight tooth and nail  Linux User 147560 | 08/06/07
Every version of windows that I  alaniane@... | 08/08/07
Hello Mr. 180  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Getting programs in the stores  BroGnorik | 08/03/07
ubuntu is overrated and so is this article  Someguy2 | 08/03/07
Ubuntu is the easiest Linux ever.  BroGnorik | 08/03/07
wireles fixed  srobtjones@... | 08/03/07
re wireless  owner@... | 08/06/07
Message has been deleted.  tombalablomba | 08/03/07
Message has been deleted.  odubtaig | 08/03/07
Message has been deleted.  DarthRidiculous | 08/03/07
Message has been deleted.  Chad_z | 08/06/07
...and Linux is better for it  Guilden_NL | 08/11/07
To beat Windows we may need unity?  srobtjones@... | 08/03/07
Vlivhed a market that doesn't exist? Yeah, maybe  No_Ax_to_Grind | 08/03/07
RE: Has Ubuntu clinched the desktop Linux market?  joe6pack_z | 08/03/07
fortunately  zoroaster | 08/04/07
Really? What is it missing?  fencer | 08/06/07
RE: Really? What is it missing?  joe6pack_z | 08/08/07
Get Real  docbillnet | 08/04/07
It is a philosophical difference  docbillnet | 08/04/07
the statistics say yes  stevey_d | 08/04/07
Outlook 2007  ParrotHeadFL | 08/06/07
And..  firehound | 08/04/07
Debian is/has been My personal preference for more than 5 years.  LazLong | 08/04/07
Ridiculous socialism  Omch'Ar | 08/04/07
exactly the point  srobtjones@... | 08/06/07
Um, yeah  Omch'Ar | 08/06/07
Windows 98 not desktop material nor is linux  tek@... | 08/05/07
Thank you for your "opinion" and that is all it is...  fr0thy2. | 08/06/07
How do I change?  Karl42 | 08/05/07
It's difficult, when you're chained to Microsoft  zaine_ridling | 08/05/07
Thanks for your suggestions  Karl42 | 08/06/07
To start with..  firehound | 08/05/07
Comments appreciated  Karl42 | 08/06/07
I think Novell released OpenExchange as Evolution.  heres_johnny | 08/06/07
Outlook Equivalent  pj_mouse | 08/06/07
Looking for Open Xchange by any chance?  odubtaig | 08/06/07
You must work for Mike Cox.  LazLong | 08/05/07
Close but no cigar  Karl42 | 08/06/07
It seems to me...  LazLong | 08/06/07
Probably quite a few  odubtaig | 08/06/07
Oops,  odubtaig | 08/06/07
Sooner or later  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Vertical Applications  mswift@... | 08/06/07
Press are idiots  persia | 08/06/07
OEM support is the key ...  mwagner@... | 08/06/07
Nonsensical War  nydas | 08/06/07
Not by a long shot  phillfri | 08/06/07
No other distro has these endorsements...?  CxO_trainee | 08/06/07
uBunThu, et al - all over reaching - space cadets !!!  jack-daniels@... | 08/06/07
As long as somebody does...  Narg | 08/06/07
and when YOU get real, I might take some notice of your posts  mdsmedia | 08/10/07
Angry Person + Linux = IDIOT  Guilden_NL | 08/11/07
Ubuntu still too hard to use...but it's getting better.  The_Curmudgeon | 08/06/07
Think for just a minute, what you're saying  mdsmedia | 08/10/07
Ubuntu little brother  mikeholli | 08/06/07
sheep  johnson12 | 08/06/07
baaaaaaaaaaaaa  mikeholli | 08/06/07
Since I switched from . .  JLHenry | 08/06/07
Sheep Run PCLinuxOS 2007?  Guilden_NL | 08/11/07
Anyone remember 2001  mindwave@... | 08/06/07
I'm pleased that you don't represent my opinion  mdsmedia | 08/10/07
Do you really want to change?  georgeslacombe@... | 08/06/07
Your average user  alaniane@... | 08/06/07
edit: average user  alaniane@... | 08/06/07
There is no war, it's a matter of personal choice  intrepi@... | 08/06/07
linux vs windows  merc2dogs` | 08/06/07
Alternatively  odubtaig | 08/06/07
Your JOKING, right?  mikeholli | 08/06/07
No.  odubtaig | 08/09/07
Mandriva  calsoft | 08/06/07
Others well work looking at  intelliginix@... | 08/06/07
IBM Lenovo to be preloaded with SLED  smoring | 08/06/07
What makes U*buntu so special is beyond me  pcguy777 | 08/06/07
Ubuntu Cool....  mikeholli | 08/06/07
KDE does much more than that.  T1Oracle | 08/07/07
Im just mad at dell because  pcguy777 | 08/06/07
To many distro's is definitely the problem  keeppace | 08/06/07
Lenovo bundling Novell Linux  bmeacham98@... | 08/06/07
Ubunyu  mcfeeeb@... | 08/06/07
BLA BLA BLA  co-eddy | 08/06/07
Devide and conquer  ursulus | 08/06/07
You are the farce  Ole Man | 08/06/07
Ubuntu is not harder than Windows  bobsherrill@... | 08/06/07
It is easy to use  alaniane@... | 08/08/07
There is no IntraLinux war  kordoniss@... | 08/06/07
Linux is ready for Desktop!  Samuel C. | 08/07/07
Windows Easy, Linux Hard. Ubuntu, not bad !  Jeff_Toronto | 08/07/07
Windows is not necessarily easy to use  alaniane@... | 08/14/07
Lonovo Goes with Novell Linux  phillfri | 08/07/07
The true beauty of linux  gene_fitz@... | 08/08/07
You don't use Linux, right?  A.Lizard | 08/10/07
Rally Around Ubuntu  The Rifleman | 08/27/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More