On mySimon: Samsung 55" LED TV
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

August 30th, 2007

Can Microsoft's open source problem be solved?

Posted by Dana Blankenhorn @ 6:15 am

Categories: Applications, General, Internet, Microsoft, Strategy, business models, marketing, mass market, support

Tags: Software, Maintenance, Open Source, Microsoft Corp., Dana Blankenhorn

Forrester chart about software moving to maintenance revenuesIn his recent piece about how Microsoft should be afraid of open source, our own Matt Asay stumbles on a solution to the problem.

He offers this nifty Forrester chart (right) showing how software revenues have changed in the last few years, from licenses to maintenance, with services declining as well.

There are good reasons for this. Open source is one. The need for continual updates on, say, anti-viral programs is another.

All of which leads to my cunning plan.

Stop selling Microsoft software. Rent it.

Microsoft is doing this already in the enterprise space. Contracts routinely include maintenance on server software. So why not do that in the consumer space?

Instead of selling Windows for, say, $150, through an OEM, sell one year of it for $99. Require registration for updates, and then charge $75/year for maintenance, just like the anti-virals do.

The same thing with Office. Don’t sell it for $500. Sell it for $300, but for one year only. Then ask for another year of maintenance. Or, even better, get their credit card and charge $30/month for the whole shebang, Windows, Office and all.

Now you’ve got recurring revenue, you’re actually getting more than retail (because people keep PCs for three years, not two), and you’ve got constant access to the customer’s PC in order to provide the service that customer is paying for. 

Plus there’s constant customer contact and the ability to upsell. Companies like-y the upsell.

Instead of sending out a yearly service pack, you can send out daily or weekly updates, just like the anti-viral guys do. And now your money is coming from maintenance, not license sales.  

This isn’t rocket science, it’s merely adapting what already exists in the enterprise space to the consumer market, using online channels Microsoft and its ISVs already use.

Sure, Microsoft will have to make sure it continually pleases customers, lest they cancel their contracts. It will have to take responsibility for the customer’s set-up working.

But that seems like a small price to pay.

So, tell me I’m crazy here.

Dana BlankenhornDana Blankenhorn has been a business journalist for 30 years, a tech freelancer since 1983. You can follow Dana on Twitter. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Dana Blankenhorn

Subscribe to Linux and Open Source via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 209 Talkback(s)
Sorry...
Haven't logged on in a while... Here you go...

http://www.download.com/AVG-An... (Read the rest)
Posted by: dialated8 Posted on: 10/04/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
only one problem  christopher@... | 08/30/07
Very true, so, Microsoft MUST resort to lock-in and FUD. It is all they  DonnieBoy | 08/30/07
Alternative  joe.smetona@... | 08/31/07
Let me get this...  aulax@... | 08/30/07
I think he was really just trying to be funny. If this was a speech, he  DonnieBoy | 08/30/07
Exactamundo!  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
You make good jokes!  pjotr123 | 08/30/07
I'll be here all week  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 08/30/07
WHAT?!?  dialated8 | 08/31/07
The problem is you,  pjotr123 | 08/31/07
Uh  dialated8 | 08/31/07
What planet you on  Rocker452 | 08/31/07
Linux?????  Information_z | 09/01/07
What bugs?  p0figster | 08/31/07
---  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Mmmm Hmmm...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
depends entirely on distro and windows version  reugen | 08/31/07
yeah  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Windows is far too "Microsoftee"  Ole Man | 08/31/07
See...  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Still.... you have exaggerated about number of Linux bugs  Ole Man | 08/31/07
Yes, Microsoft's predicament is rather funny. The problem the categories  DonnieBoy | 08/30/07
Why say mature? Why not just say old?  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 08/30/07
Well, yes, you could say old and that might fit a bit better. The point is,  DonnieBoy | 08/30/07
This all goes back to 640K of RAM...  dansen926 | 08/31/07
Excuse me...  RealAusTech | 08/31/07
Check again  Mitch 74 | 08/31/07
Gates said that, but he didn't cause the original problem...  RealAusTech | 08/31/07
Actually, BG *Didn't* Say That  dumptux | 09/01/07
Collections of Gates quotes  Ole Man | 09/01/07
Not quite true, ole man  GuidingLight | 09/03/07
Not quite true, ole man  Ole Man | 09/04/07
As long as we're quoting history...  cheesyone | 08/31/07
And...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Okay...  cd2_z | 08/30/07
Well, sounds simple, cut the price. But, MS is accountable to shareholders  DonnieBoy | 08/30/07
Elasticity of Demand  cd2_z | 08/31/07
Why Should we Pay anything for it until it is FIXED?  rickpant@... | 09/01/07
Y TY Rick :^)  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
This may work for apps. But since...  bjbrock | 08/30/07
Who reads fine print?  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/30/07
My experience exactly.  joe.smetona@... | 08/31/07
That is a problem integrating apps into the OS  TDWinfo | 08/31/07
What Are You Smoking?  DaffyDuck | 08/30/07
Exactly  Yellowbird7 | 09/01/07
Perfect..then everyone will see OpenSource isn't free  GeiselS@... | 08/30/07
Somehow I am just not buying your study...  Linux User 147560 | 08/30/07
missing the big picture  GeiselS@... | 08/31/07
What are your choices indeed?  zkiwi | 08/30/07
lol  dialated8 | 08/31/07
"at the company we work at"  Ole Man | 08/31/07
That makes sense???  carlino | 08/31/07
It's Free As In Freedom, Not Necessarily Free As in Donuts  dumptux | 09/01/07
Also...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Not a chance  jfp | 08/30/07
Yeah... do that and watch Linux and Apple skyrocket into the lead.  James T. Kirk | 08/30/07
Dana, Your math is way off  osreinstall | 08/30/07
Food for thought...  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Keep it as a thought.  osreinstall | 08/31/07
wink  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Keep winking  osreinstall | 08/31/07
yeah  dialated8 | 08/31/07
You bet.  osreinstall | 08/31/07
I used retail prices  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 08/31/07
I assumed OEM because all retail versions are over $200  osreinstall | 08/31/07
Wow...Microsoft selling software!!!!!  Nocturna | 08/30/07
Better Idea...  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Hogwash  Seenidog | 08/31/07
Everyone is...  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Doesn't it depend on the price?  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 08/31/07
Point Taken  Seenidog | 08/31/07
Somebody ripped your A** off!  cheesyone | 08/31/07
Crazy  CodeBubba | 08/31/07
Rent Windows  lesauteur | 08/31/07
no more money to Microsoft  ghall54@... | 08/31/07
ROFLMAO!!!  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Okay, you're crazy.  zd_cheryl | 08/31/07
Or...  macbill | 08/31/07
Absolutely  rolf.ernst@... | 08/31/07
They Already Rent It  wpenrose | 08/31/07
Lets try and understand this.  padronw@... | 08/31/07
This has got to be the stupidest...  ginsengprod | 08/31/07
Just send the writers to Symantec for work!  vmeck@... | 08/31/07
Pay continually for Windows use  wrfloyd@... | 08/31/07
Why Buy or Rent. Use Free Open Source  cpr2345 | 08/31/07
Yes, M$ is a joke  mannyamador | 09/03/07
And...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Open source ain't free  schratboy@... | 08/31/07
Do you think there is NO learning curve.....  cheesyone | 08/31/07
And more than that...  mannyamador | 09/03/07
Just one question?  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Their competition would love to see Microsoft do this.  Resuna | 08/31/07
More Proprietary Junkware  ceh4702 | 08/31/07
dumbest. idea. ever.  cheryl.monroe@... | 08/31/07
AVG is great...  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Errr..  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Sorry...  dialated8 | 10/04/07
Per your request!  fcwilt@... | 08/31/07
Windows is NOT the same as antivirus  jacob_pennington | 08/31/07
Exactly! Fatal Flaws in the logic here  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Does the writer work for Microsoft or what?  jnclague@... | 08/31/07
Onward to 1955!  critic-at-arms | 08/31/07
Death Knell for Microsoft  beroean@... | 08/31/07
OK, you are crazy  Jim Johnson | 08/31/07
Go for it Microsoft  danm_50@... | 08/31/07
EXCUSE ME!!! Rent the softare required to use a pc, RETARD!  masterxtds | 08/31/07
hmm  shane@... | 08/31/07
Excuse you, but...  Swiss Army Bud | 08/31/07
Now that you've got your load off your chest  Ole Man | 08/31/07
The reall problem with the EULA is...  cheesyone | 08/31/07
Thanks for pointing out  Ole Man | 09/01/07
Forget it  Dr_Zinj | 08/31/07
Some deep changes are happening  olivier veyrac | 08/31/07
linux would then rule my world  paulwalter@... | 08/31/07
People may laugh at your notion now...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Commercial Nirvana for Seller - Technical Hell for Buyer!  rvjcallanan | 08/31/07
Are you out of your $%#*& mind?  Crabby Guy | 08/31/07
Great Idea!  DLYOUNG | 08/31/07
SAAS  ScratchCA | 08/31/07
Microsoft already do this ...  Steve4Fluff | 08/31/07
Good arguments - but...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
PAY OVER AND OVER FOR WINDOWS  scrippen | 08/31/07
Microsoft Would Already Be Doing This If They Could Get Away With It  chessmen | 08/31/07
Oh HELL no.  Ginevra | 08/31/07
ZDNet adding to MS FUD is irresponsible!  Ralph Afatania | 08/31/07
It's only fair!  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Certifiable  shanedr | 08/31/07
Because...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
maybe if M$ paid me $200K/year I'd use Windoze  Professor8 | 08/31/07
...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
It's an OPERATING SYSTEM  Olderdan | 08/31/07
$75 a year for what?  Randalllind | 08/31/07
Doesn't really matter...  dialated8 | 08/31/07
Another scenario  itpro_z | 08/31/07
hmmm...  dialated8 | 08/31/07
That's Great Genius! Why didn't I think of that???  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Why is it a problem?  timmeh64 | 08/31/07
zzzzzzzzzzzzzz....  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
You are Crazy! Rotate This!  vmeck@... | 08/31/07
piracy threat will be severe  avnirambhia | 08/31/07
Microsoft out of Business  wturgeon | 08/31/07
No FAir!!!  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
I'll ask again, what are you smoking?  suemccartin | 08/31/07
UR NOT Crazy:,just STUPID; BAD BAD idea  archimedez@... | 08/31/07
Instead of paying for Microsoft software  PCcritic | 08/31/07
Rent MS Operating system  dlwc@... | 08/31/07
Hah  dialated8 | 08/31/07
???  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Apologies  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Microsoft rent  mike.bourne@... | 08/31/07
Ok. You're crazy here.  Dr. John | 08/31/07
Love to see MS buried and your suggestion is the proverbial coffin nail  ca_ellis@... | 08/31/07
The enterprise would prefer such an ...  mwagner@... | 08/31/07
You know....  dialated8 | 08/31/07
People don't update AV software because ...  Steve4Fluff | 08/31/07
Nice Analogy  dialated8 | 08/31/07
...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
based on the cash in the bank ...  kmr214@... | 08/31/07
was meant as a reply to:  kmr214@... | 08/31/07
Like NOT ......  chaz15 | 08/31/07
Dumb idea in SPADES  proton_z | 08/31/07
Microsoft Hello wake up  manofnight | 08/31/07
What kind of drugs are you on???  SirCatlord | 08/31/07
Microsoft Cannot Mimick OpenSource  cslape@... | 08/31/07
Egads! You have lost it!  richard@... | 08/31/07
So you think we could afford that price?  shohom67 | 08/31/07
Renting Windows  Ronspruell | 08/31/07
you must be crazy ...  isiria@... | 08/31/07
It will cost the consumer more.  stan@... | 08/31/07
Say What????  KeithAu001 | 08/31/07
Hang on there!  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
$300 a year!! yeahh  ignacio.rodriguez@... | 08/31/07
What does this have to do with the problem?  maxsnorkel | 08/31/07
It doesn't - but...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Small price to pay???  jwalradt@... | 08/31/07
What problem? Bloatware, bugs, cashflow? what?  dockc | 08/31/07
Anyone notice the similarity?  Old Timer 8080 | 08/31/07
Opensource is evil anyways!  FSB | 08/31/07
No way...  mikifinaz1@... | 08/31/07
I thought it was the plan  Kai Ahnig | 09/01/07
You want to hear somrthing really scary...  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
This guy s completely crazy  emk | 09/01/07
Sell it just like antivirus?  Ronchogrande | 09/01/07
Switching to renting software.  Spaedie | 09/01/07
rent  ceazevedo@... | 09/01/07
Read the EULA  chrisl317 | 09/01/07
Bingo!  Ole Man | 09/01/07
Apple declined to post their EULA online  GuidingLight | 09/03/07
I did not mention Apple's EULA  Ole Man | 09/04/07
Dumb  kitekrazy | 09/01/07
How long ago did you fall off the wagon?  chefwylie1@... | 09/01/07
please don't give them any more ideas  jaybyrd | 09/01/07
turnip truck?  jaybyrd | 09/01/07
nahh not really  royalstream | 09/02/07
not to mention the rotating cube  royalstream | 09/02/07
Your cunning plan????  Fujikid2 | 09/02/07
I support it!  kannan32@... | 09/02/07
This was a paid advertisement from MS  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Isn't that what they already do?  balaknair | 09/02/07
I support it! (spelling errors corrected)  kannan32@... | 09/02/07
Apologies from MS  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Fatal Error! Network Processing Aborted  thx-1138_@... | 09/05/07
Now we are complete.  Peluchin | 09/03/07
This is a Dangerous Idea!!!  wwwsupport | 09/03/07
Always amazed...  alistair.joy@... | 09/03/07
don't spend my money for me  pete_w_flynn@... | 09/04/07
Renting MS products, NOT  rgeiken@... | 09/04/07
I'd switch to Linux right away too.  wellsoul2@... | 09/04/07
Like online apps you pay for-No way!  wellsoul2@... | 09/04/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement
Click Here

Recent Entries

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

  • Smart Tech Expert advice on innovations in healthcare and the green technologies that make it happen. Find out more
  • Smart Business Discussion and advice on management issues that revolve around making your world smarter and more useful. More Smart Advice
  • Smart People The best and worst moves in the management and strategy trenches. Learn More