On BNET: Vote: How will Apple blow it?
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

September 17th, 2007

Is Linux still too geeky?

Posted by Dana Blankenhorn @ 5:51 am

Categories: Apple, Applications, General, Linux Desktop OS, Microsoft, Software as a Service, marketing, mass market

Tags: Desktop, Linux, Software-as-a-service, Internet, Antitrust, New York Times Co., Dana Blankenhorn

Walt Mossberg reviewing Ubuntu laptop from DellThe word for today is disappointment.

The New York Times says Apple is blowing its desktop opportunity, ignoring the channel, despite its incredible awesomeness.

As to Linux, it’s still too geeky. This final verdict, issued by Walt Mossberg of The Wall Street Journal concerning a Dell laptop he reviewed with Ubuntu, has been spreading like wildfire on the Internets, even hitting some political blogs.

Trouble is, Mossberg admits in his story that he talked to Canonical’s Mark Shuttleworth who admits the current version of the software is not really aimed at mainstream users. He found it’s not something it admits it’s not, and somehow that’s a headline.  

Zonbu, which Mossberg did not review, is aimed at mainstream users. And early reviews on Zonbu are quite promising.

So what gives? Despite Microsoft’s proven vulnerability with Windows Vista, and its continuing antitrust problems, so-called “mainstream desktop users” are being told they have no choice, that they must surrender to the Redmond borg.

Must they? Between simple, SaaS-based clients such as Zonbu and ubiquitous Internet broadband, I’m not so sure. I strongly suspect we’re leaving the PC era behind, that between the Internet, SaaS and virtualization the question of which OS you run will mean less and less.

But maybe it’s me who’s too geeky.

Dana BlankenhornDana Blankenhorn has been a business journalist for 30 years, a tech freelancer since 1983. You can follow Dana on Twitter. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Email Dana Blankenhorn

Subscribe to Linux and Open Source via Email alerts or RSS.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 109 Talkback(s)
What I care about
is getting as many people to use and understand the basics of my favorite distro so that I can get them to donate There by letting the ones who do understand keep developing it full time.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User Posted on: 09/27/07 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Linux has become less geeky  cyber_rigger@... | 09/17/07
Bull...  No_Ax_to_Grind | 09/17/07
Oh here you are!  Linux User 147560 | 09/17/07
Ironic  NonZealot | 09/17/07
Not in the least.  Linux User 147560 | 09/17/07
What's that have to do with it?  voska | 09/18/07
hidding .....hahahhahahha  Quebec-french | 09/17/07
Less geeky does not mean not geeky  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 09/18/07
Geeky is state of mind  voska | 09/18/07
Good analogy  balaknair | 09/18/07
geeky?  pavka@... | 09/18/07
Some Linux users too geeky, even scare off other geeks.  russell@... | 09/17/07
MS Windows IS geeky  cyber_rigger@... | 09/17/07
Synaptic - have to down load and install...isn't that geeky in itself  ItsTheBottomLine | 09/18/07
I assume you haven't tried Linux  balaknair | 09/18/07
if you'd ever used Linux you'd know  A.Lizard | 09/18/07
Translation needed  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 09/18/07
What "most"?  russell@... | 09/18/07
Dana: new headshot?  AtlantaTerry | 09/18/07
Excuse me?  mikeholli | 09/18/07
Not all have the problem.  joe.smetona@... | 09/18/07
More techie details...  russell@... | 09/18/07
Actually  balaknair | 09/18/07
There are many levels of linux geekdom  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 09/22/07
Computer are too geeky  voska | 09/17/07
Ubuntu not intended for mainstream?!  Vesicant | 09/17/07
Marketing!  THEE WOLF | 09/17/07
Ubuntu is headed for the mainstream  masinick@... | 09/18/07
I make a living off writing Linux how-to articles  A.Lizard | 09/18/07
couldn't sell such an article now because it's a few points-and-clicks  Ole Man | 09/18/07
" Even having to type: # aptitude install nvidia..."  handydan918@... | 09/18/07
It can be much geekier  Protector | 09/17/07
i haven't had a problem with media formats  stevey_d | 09/17/07
That's what it does  balaknair | 09/18/07
geek squad?  A.Lizard | 09/18/07
It will be a sad day...  Henrik Moller | 09/17/07
Getting near the sad day  andycher | 09/17/07
and then... God created Gentoo. =)  startx.jeff | 09/18/07
Yes, but...  handydan918@... | 09/18/07
yeah.  merc2dogs` | 09/18/07
What I care about  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 09/27/07
I don't see any reason why Linux can't  A.Lizard | 09/18/07
Sorry no comment  oliver.widder@... | 09/17/07
An OS is an OS, is an OS ...  kd5auq | 09/17/07
Because...  ItsTheBottomLine | 09/18/07
Not Geeky but Different  kmatzen@... | 09/17/07
Bottom line, if I have to use a command line  No_Ax_to_Grind | 09/17/07
No, GUI's are just easier for the inept to do something  Linux User 147560 | 09/17/07
Yeah, I need the "power" of a command  No_Ax_to_Grind | 09/17/07
Command line has it's place  voska | 09/18/07
Well stated!  Linux User 147560 | 09/18/07
I agree  balaknair | 09/18/07
This reminds me of work...  jgsilva@... | 09/19/07
That my magic  maalmike@... | 09/21/07
Oh really?  Shelendrea | 09/18/07
then you'll be pleased to know that  A.Lizard | 09/18/07
bogus  lucky 13 | 09/18/07
Precisely the problem.  russell@... | 09/18/07
Not a problem....But a different perspective  LazLong | 09/18/07
Bottom line,  jacarter3 | 09/18/07
I use the command line  swoopee | 09/18/07
ROFLMAO (nt)  Update victim | 09/18/07
No, but...  handydan918@... | 09/18/07
who cares if it's geeky or not?  Shelendrea | 09/17/07
Really?  Linux User 147560 | 09/17/07
YES REALLY  Shelendrea | 09/17/07
Geek is a state of mind not a physical object  voska | 09/18/07
I think you missed the point  Shelendrea | 09/18/07
It's possible you're both right  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 09/18/07
I'm not saying that they aren't  Shelendrea | 09/18/07
My state of mind  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 09/25/07
My head looks like an ice cream cone. [NT]  swoopee | 09/18/07
Let's turn this around  THEE WOLF | 09/17/07
A bit different  Sabz5150 | 09/18/07
RE: Is Linux still too geeky?  jpr75_z | 09/17/07
Yeah,  handydan918@... | 09/18/07
Linux will always be Geeky  jpr75_z | 09/17/07
RE: Is Linux still too geeky?  sberry@... | 09/17/07
In a culture where...  handydan918@... | 09/18/07
RE: Is Linux still too geeky?  zaine_ridling | 09/17/07
Any operating system you have to install  mrjonno | 09/18/07
I see a new comedy routine coming.....  startx.jeff | 09/18/07
Really? So can you explain why  jacarter3 | 09/18/07
You calling me a geek?  balaknair | 09/18/07
You calling me a geek?  balaknair | 09/18/07
Windows crashes?  A.Lizard | 09/18/07
My grandmother uses Linux.  noisecraft | 09/18/07
My newborn uses Linux and finds it easier than Vista  ItsTheBottomLine | 09/18/07
If you use Linux...  DanaBlankenhornZDNet Moderator | 09/18/07
My parents run Linux  russell@... | 09/18/07
It's about the outlets  whisperycat | 09/18/07
right said  balaknair | 09/18/07
Yep...  User-01 | 09/18/07
You are correct, sir  mswift@... | 09/18/07
Too geeky?  sysop-dr | 09/18/07
Nice.  handydan918@... | 09/18/07
Exactly  masterxtds | 09/19/07
It could always be simpler  jaszman | 09/18/07
RE: Is Linux still too geeky?  lucky 13 | 09/18/07
Linux is NOT geeky  Ole Man | 09/18/07
RE: Is Linux still too geeky?  notsofast | 09/18/07
automatically patch itself  Ole Man | 09/19/07
Linux is in Growth Mode  phillfri | 09/19/07
Linux is misunderstood by most  masterxtds | 09/19/07
lInux & geeky  jns_45K@... | 09/19/07
Do me a favor  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 09/25/07
What's controversial about that?  Absolutely | 09/19/07
Let's try this again  Hrothgar - PCLinuxOS User | 09/25/07
RE: Is Linux still too geeky?  Chiatzu | 09/21/07

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads