On CNET: Update software safe and spyware free
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

February 1st, 2009

Why Microsoft's Killer Instinct Must Return

Posted by Jason Perlow @ 6:55 am

Categories: Apple, Business, Desktop, Microsoft

Tags: test, Apple Inc., Microsoft Corp., Apple Macintosh, Desktops, Hardware, Jason Perlow

thinkingballmer by you.

Last week, the hearts of many Mac fans skipped a beat when the Mactopia web page on Microsoft’s web site disappeared for several hours. As it turned out, it was just a simple glitch, and in a knee-jerk response to blogger Ted Bishop’s inquiry about the health of the Mac Business Unit in general, Microsoft had this to say:

While the group eliminated some positions, the essence of MacBU will not change. We are committed to delivering the industry standard in productivity software on the Mac. We are well under way with development of the next version of Office for Mac, and we recently released a beta version of Entourage for Exchange Web Services and will soon release a private beta of the Microsoft Document Collaboration Companion, both milestones in our product roadmap.

By all accounts, the Macintosh Business Unit does make a decent profit for Microsoft — with an estimated yearly revenue of approximately $350 million. However, when you look at the big picture, 350 million dollars isn’t really a large percentage of Microsoft’s annual revenue, which is around 60.4 billion dollars, according to the most recently reported 2008 figures.

Click on the “Read the rest of this entry” link below for more.

In fact, given the current economy, and the stress that Microsoft is now under to retain market share and preserve its bread and butter business — Windows and Office — that maybe it is time for the company to reconsider whether or not operating a Macintosh Business Unit is really such a good idea.

We’ve all heard about the supposed obsession that Microsoft’s CEO Steve Ballmer has had for “Killing Google“. I think that energy is misdirected — they should be focusing their efforts on Killing Apple instead and hurting them in their worst time of crisis. I know, it’s a reptilian, bloodthirsty, and horrible thing to propose — to pick on Apple when Steve Jobs is sick and everyone is worried about whether or not the company can weather the economic downturn with its luxury products. Exactly. I propose that you return to doing what you do best, Microsoft — being bloodthirsty.

I know, I know, Microsoft made a 5-year commitment back in January of 2006 to Apple to continue to produce Office and other products such as Entourage for Mac until 2011. But 2006 is not 2009, at least in terms of it being an environment in which Microsoft can continue to try to be all things to all people, Even Microsoft is no longer immune to the effects of the economy, and that comes straight from the mouth of the company’s own CEO, Steve Ballmer.  A large portion of the Microsoft Games unit was recently deep sixed, and there are rumors that the Zune division is also going to be eliminated as well. Sure, one could argue that the Mac Business Unit is profitable and the others are not, but profitable at what cost?

How much revenue and resources does operating a Mac Business Unit cost Microsoft? I would imagine that given the current climate, it’s a huge distraction. Those 200-odd employees could be put to work doing other creative projects for the company, in the advancement of Windows and improving other Microsoft products, instead of helping to improve Apple’s market share and making life easier for the users who chose to seek out a different platform than their own. How many Windows systems does Microsoft lose to Apple every year because Mac has their own version of Office as a viable alternative? I’m going to say a lot.

Killing the Mac Business Unit would not only help cut costs and improve focus for Microsoft, and create short-term havoc for Apple and the Mac, but it would also have a very desirable side effect — it would very well cause Apple to re-think its relationship with the Open Source community. By all means, let Mac Office Suites and productivity applications become the Open Source Community’s problem — not Microsoft’s. OpenOffice.org 3.0 for Mac is an excellent office suite, and with Microsoft washing its hands of Mac applications, Apple will be forced to become Open Source’s new best friend — something it should have done a long time ago.

Should Microsoft finally pull the trigger on the Mac Business Unit? Talk Back and Let Me Know.

Should Microsoft eliminate the Mac Business Unit?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Jason PerlowJason Perlow is a technologist with over two decades of experience integrating large heterogeneous multi-vendor computing environments in Fortune 500 companies. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

Follow jperlow on Twitter

Email Jason Perlow

Subscribe to Tech Broiler via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 132 Talkback(s)
Go for it. happy
That same thought was used by IBM. They then lost so much of the
computer market that they sold PCs to Lenovo.

MS had lots of power, but with all those anti-trust trials and losing
ten... (Read the rest)
Posted by: eldernorm Posted on: 02/11/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
You are ignoring the legal ramifications...  Mike Cox | 02/01/09
Somebody steal Mike Cox's ZDNet identity?  j.m.galvin | 02/01/09
It is the real Mike Cox  John L. Ries | 02/02/09
This isn't Mike Cox...OK, *Who* are you?  no_zd_user_name | 02/01/09
I have an idea...  MGP2 | 02/01/09
Actually  Kid Icarus-21097050858087920245213802267493 | 02/01/09
re: Actually  Badgered | 02/02/09
Even still ...  HouseOfZen | 02/02/09
Sounds plausible. And in that case, the commentary is no surprise.  Cayble | 02/02/09
Absolutely right  John L. Ries | 02/02/09
Mike, has M$ axed your position?  Linux Geek | 02/02/09
gobble-de-goop  stone-cutter | 02/02/09
That should read "...been convicted of...  PollyProteus | 02/03/09
Please...  His_Shadow | 02/04/09
Wait a minute Jason  GuidingLight | 02/01/09
Is it a legal commitment or simply a promise?  jperlowZDNet Moderator | 02/01/09
It was just an analogy  GuidingLight | 02/01/09
Another option is...  914four | 02/03/09
Legal implications  merlin747 | 02/01/09
Vision  Chad Strunk | 02/01/09
Short Sighted  Rob Oakes | 02/01/09
re: Vision  rtk | 02/03/09
RE: Why Microsoft  shellcodes_coder | 02/01/09
Two points...  MGP2 | 02/01/09
Good points  Fred Fredrickson | 02/01/09
Exactly happy  eldernorm | 02/11/09
Exactly...  Sleeper Service | 02/02/09
You hit the two nails. Right on the head.  Cayble | 02/02/09
Their own product?  Eleutherios | 02/02/09
Yea they do.  Bruizer | 02/02/09
Excel is a toy, too  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
Are ya sure you're using Office 2008 for Mac?  rtk | 02/03/09
NeoOffice  SaltySkipper | 02/03/09
Only for personal work.  Bruizer | 02/08/09
The MS Web  P. Douglas | 02/01/09
Interesting idea but very bad strategy  Rob Oakes | 02/01/09
I don't think so  P. Douglas | 02/01/09
They tried that  John L. Ries | 02/02/09
Create new web, not extend old one  P. Douglas | 02/02/09
Isn't that what MSN was intended to be?  John L. Ries | 02/02/09
Things should work out fine if MS creates its own web  P. Douglas | 02/02/09
Video and audio in Office...  arminw | 02/02/09
Well they have mastered Viruses/Spyware  Christian_<>< | 02/01/09
Sure they could...  MGP2 | 02/01/09
Just like Windows  Christian_<>< | 02/01/09
Yep...some lost cause  MGP2 | 02/01/09
Re: get your numbers right...  Christian_<>< | 02/01/09
So, where's your argument?  MGP2 | 02/01/09
The argument is right now...  Christian_<>< | 02/01/09
Yeah, no ROI alright...  MGP2 | 02/01/09
@MPG2: Why are you feeding the troll?  Wolfie2K3 | 02/01/09
Question...  ShadowGIATL | 02/01/09
Why feed the troll, Wolfie2K3?  GuidingLight | 02/02/09
Funny  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
You are so right because...  Cayble | 02/02/09
Not quite  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
Definitely not  johnfenjackson@... | 02/01/09
Anti-trusts  jperlowZDNet Moderator | 02/02/09
Really?  George Mitchell | 02/03/09
Could MS afford to dump Office for Mac?  Mac Hosehead | 02/01/09
Flawed Logic  Rob Oakes | 02/01/09
strange blog  martin23 | 02/01/09
Genie is already out of the bottle  Alan Smithie | 02/01/09
Well that would be true...  Sleeper Service | 02/02/09
What women want...  pwatson | 02/02/09
That it may be...  Sleeper Service | 02/02/09
That's laughable  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
This makes me laugh.  bjbrock | 02/02/09
Apple is just an electronic company.  cccjw | 02/02/09
MS was a hair's breath away from being broken up...  doctorSpoc | 02/02/09
It would have been better for MS if it had  John L. Ries | 02/02/09
Go for it. happy  eldernorm | 02/11/09
Valentines Day Massacre  startx.jeff | 02/02/09
The killer instinct is half the problem  John L. Ries | 02/02/09
fear  elllroy | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  3monkies | 02/02/09
Why this is a really bad idea  amywohl | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  pico_D | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  Synthmeister | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  tyelmene | 02/02/09
No they won't...  Sleeper Service | 02/02/09
You don't know how to calc a percentage  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
RE: Why Microsoft  super_J | 02/02/09
Market Share.  joe.smetona@... | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  cesar.bremer@... | 02/02/09
I voted yes  Ole Man | 02/02/09
Being destructive doesn't really pay.  peter_erskine@... | 02/02/09
those 200 plus employees ...  Too Old For IT | 02/02/09
MS should have dropped ALL association  mustangj36@... | 02/02/09
YEAH, baby!  vikingnyc@... | 02/02/09
Since Apple doesn't seem to have anyone  mustangj36@... | 02/02/09
Don't worry...  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
Never going to happen  mustangj36@... | 02/03/09
RE: Why Microsoft  netzd | 02/02/09
Idiot  jimboutilier@... | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  Rick56 | 02/02/09
There can be only one! BULL!!!  Narg | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  Calson | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  Charles Norrie | 02/02/09
This post is a trojan horse for Open Office  payton@... | 02/02/09
Microsoft needs Office on the Mac  pointzerotwo@... | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  GemStone | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  wanderson | 02/02/09
RE: Why Microsoft  Atari800 | 02/02/09
Ha! Good one!  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
check the market caps  rtk | 02/03/09
RE: Why Microsoft  TomMariner | 02/02/09
"Killer Instinct"  macpipkin | 02/02/09
They are  bklooste | 02/02/09
.NOT  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
RE: Why Microsoft  ramnet@... | 02/02/09
Good response...  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
This would backfire.  dkawalec | 02/02/09
shortsighted thinking  rmanbike | 02/02/09
Google Docs beats OpenOffice  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
No company shuts down profitable lines  stephen.montano@... | 02/02/09
Sounds like MS fan-boys are running scared.  Bruizer | 02/02/09
You will NEVER figure me out  jperlowZDNet Moderator | 02/02/09
I have you figured out...  Confused by religion | 02/02/09
Dammit!  jperlowZDNet Moderator | 02/03/09
the only problem is that if they listened to Perlow...  doctorSpoc | 02/03/09
I agree  comp_indiana | 02/03/09
Microsoft?s Killer Instinct - ROTFLMAO!!!  i8thecat | 02/03/09
Microsoft is a Mammoth in the Tar Pits...  bbneo | 02/03/09
I do hope MS stops supporting Entourage  SaltySkipper | 02/03/09
RE: Why Microsoft  bigbinks-22758646162213519565686570707102 | 02/04/09
RE: Why Microsoft  mel@... | 02/05/09
Stupid  Graham Ellison | 02/05/09
Microsoft can't kill off the Mac Business Unit ...  mwagner@... | 02/05/09
Right. When the Killer Instinct was on  GuidingLight | 02/06/09
As I said  jperlowZDNet Moderator | 02/07/09
RE: Why Microsoft  PurplePeoplEater | 02/07/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

SmartPlanet

  • Thought-provoking progressive ideas on diverse topics that intersect with technology, business, and life, and matter to the world at large. Visit SmartPlanet
  • More from IBM
  • Innovate your business' process model, play against the market, compete against others on our scoreboards and WIN! Try INNOV8 2.0: A BPM Simulator
  • Enabling Real-World Business Transformation through IBM Service Management Read the EMA Analyst Report
Click Here