On The Insider: Coroner's Findings on McQueen's Death
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

December 15th, 2008

Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps

Posted by Ryan Naraine @ 10:41 am

Categories: Adobe, Anti Virus, Apple, Arbitrary Code Execution, Browsers, Firefox, Flash, Mozilla, Patch Watch, Responsible disclosure, Symantec, Vulnerability research, Zero-day attacks

Tags: Mozilla Firefox, Attacker, Vulnerability, JRE, Arbitrary Code Execution, Buffer-overflow, Security, Viruses And Worms, Ryan Naraine

Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable appsMozilla’s flagship Firefox browser has earned the dubious title of the most vulnerable software program running on the Windows platform.

According to application whitelisting vendor Bit9, Firefox topped the list of 12 widely deployed desktop applications that suffered through critical security vulnerabilities in 2008.  These flaws exposed millions of Windows users to remote code execution attacks.

The other applications on the list are all well-known and range from browsers to media players, to VOIP chat and anti-virus software programs.  Here’s Bit9’s dirty dozen:

  1. Mozilla Firefox:  In 2008, Mozilla patched 10 vulnerabilities that could be used by remote attackers to execute arbitrary code via buffer overflow, malformed URI links, documents, JavaScript and third party tools.
  2. Adobe Flash and Adobe Acrobat:  Bit9 listed 14 flaws patched this year that exposed desktops of arbitrary remote code execution via buffer overflow,“input validation issues” and malformed parameters.
  3. EMC VMware Player,Workstation and other products:  A total of 10 bugs introduced risks ranging from privilege escalation via directory traversal, ActiveX buffer overflows leading to arbitrary code execution and denial of service.
  4. Sun Java JDK and JRE, Sun Java Runtime Environment (JRE):
    Inability to prevent execution of applets on older JRE  release could allow remote attackers to exploit vulnerabilities of these older releases. Buffer overflows allowing creation, deletion and execution of arbitrary files via untrusted applications.  10 patched vulnerabilities listed.
  5. Apple QuickTime, Safari and iTunes:  In QuickTime, the list includes nine vulnerabilities that allow remote attackers to execute arbitrary code via buffer overflow, or cause a denial of service (heap corruption and application crash) involving malformed media files, media links and third party codecs.  The Safari for Windows browser was haunted by three flaws that could be lead to arbitrary code execution and  denial of service involving JavaScript arrays that trigger memory corruption.  Apple’s iTunes software was susceptible to a remote improper update verification that allowed man-in-the-middle attacks to execute arbitrary code via a Trojan horse update.
  6. Symantec Norton products (all flavors 2006 to 2008): Stack-based buffer overflow in the AutoFix Support Tool ActiveX exposed Windows users to arbitrary code execution.
  7. Trend Micro OfficeScan: A total of four stack-based buffer overflows that opened doors for  remote attackers to execute arbitrary code.
  8. Citrix Products: Privilege escalation in DNE via specially crafted interface requests affects Cisco VPN Client, Blue Coat WinProxy, SafeNet SoftRemote and HighAssurance Remote. Search path vulnerability, and buffer overflow lead to arbitrary code execution.
  9. Aurigma Image Uploader, Lycos FileUploader:  Remote attackers can perform remote code execution via long extended image information.
  10. Skype:  Improper check of dangerous extensions allows user-assisted remote attackers to bypass warning dialogs.Cross-zone scripting vulnerability allows remote attackers to inject script via Internet Explorer web control.
  11. Yahoo Assistant: Remote attackers can execute arbitrary code via memory corruption.
  12. Microsoft Windows Live (MSN) Messenger: Remote attackers are allowed to control the Messenger application, “change state,” obtain contact information and establish audio or video connections without notification.

See Bit9’s full report (.pdf) for information on how the list was put together, including criteria for inclusion.

* Image source: Channy Yun’s Flickr photostream (Creative Commons 2.0)

Ryan NaraineRyan Naraine is a journalist and security evangelist at Kaspersky Lab. He manages Threatpost.com, a security news portal. Here is Ryan's full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.


Email Ryan Naraine

For daily updates on Ryan's activities, follow him on Twitter.

Subscribe to Zero Day via Email alerts or RSS.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 168 Talkback(s)
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps
Some of the die hard folks for MS and against FF needs to read thru these comments. Some of these comments made more sense than this "report".

SysHop spells it all out beautifully, btw.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: jmcb74 Posted on: 01/11/09 You are currently: a Guest | | Terms of Use
Curious Bill and the Monkeys...  tburzio | 12/15/08
Google, not Microsoft  GuidingLight | 12/15/08
It must have been paid for by Microsoft and Google, oh and the Tooth Fiary  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Well, it's an end of year report.  seanferd | 12/16/08
That's exactly what  OldGuru | 12/16/08
Obviously,  Greenknight_z | 12/17/08
Very odd...  InAction Man | 12/15/08
Sensationalist title  forrestgump2000@... | 12/15/08
Talk about misleading statistics....  techvet | 12/15/08
Exactly! All this proves is that Firefox is the MOST secure.  T1Oracle | 12/16/08
Stings a little I guess...nt  USTechHead | 12/17/08
FireFox had more patches than IE in 2008  dunn@... | 12/19/08
Grasping at straws  Speednet | 12/30/08
How is it functionally possible IE is not on the list?  TripleII | 12/15/08
Good question. On my screen, I have the following:  olePigeon | 12/15/08
how about this one... it's getting CRITICAL  SaltySkipper | 12/19/08
Hold on to your hat.....  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
"realize how bad FireFox really is"??? Very bad joke.  InAction Man | 12/15/08
10 vulns allowing remote code execution is what is not funny....  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
I never found one  InAction Man | 12/15/08
You can lock down IE.  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
Make me laugh. Not.  Cayble | 12/15/08
Let's see that happen  hasta la Vista, bah-bie | 12/16/08
Lucky  rjacksix | 12/19/08
Facts??? That's highly debatable!  InAction Man | 12/15/08
Ok, IE was excluded due to b9's requirements as it's aimed at sties  xuniL_z | 12/16/08
You miss the point.  TripleII | 12/15/08
While you're posting those vulns...  storm14k | 12/15/08
This blog does not claim to do that.  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
Thats not what I asked...  storm14k | 12/16/08
LOL - n  USTechHead | 12/17/08
Reason why IE isn't on that list  mone_dog | 12/16/08
You are losing all credibility, Ryan, for such nonsense  Narr vi | 12/15/08
Exactly right, Narr.  Lerianis | 12/15/08
Honestly it should read "12 most Responsible Windows apps" nt  T1Oracle | 12/16/08
Honestly? LOL!!  xuniL_z | 12/17/08
In terms of vulnerability patching  T1Oracle | 12/17/08
And...  thx-1138_@... | 12/16/08
I Have to Agree  rjacksix | 12/19/08
I Know  rjacksix | 12/19/08
Even the biggest MS lover will call this BS  wackoae | 12/15/08
Looks like remote execution vulns are weighted most heavily.....  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
Are ActiveX controls counted separately.  TripleII | 12/15/08
From the bit9 pdf with requirements for inclusion.:  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
Funny how the report was released in PDF form  WiredGuy | 12/16/08
acrobat isn't the only way to read .pdf files  Dutchie027 | 12/16/08
Or Windows Update?  T1Oracle | 12/16/08
Yep!  mone_dog | 12/16/08
Yes.  xuniL_z | 12/16/08
Then why?  rjacksix | 12/19/08
WSUS  rtk | 12/19/08
Aurigma was ActiveX, but MS set killbit....  dunn@... | 12/19/08
BS answer  wackoae | 12/15/08
I was speculating at that time... clearly i said "must be" they weight....  xuniL_z | 12/16/08
Award for best quote of this thread  Speednet | 12/30/08
The responses thus far have been funny and predictable..  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Very predictable indeed  InAction Man | 12/15/08
Yep, that's me...  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Breath some fresh air for moment  T1Oracle | 12/16/08
That doesn't make their opinions accurate.  ye | 12/16/08
dumb and dumber  do it yourself IT | 12/16/08
Yep, your right...It was the lawyers who let us down  rs_jr | 12/16/08
Very predictable indeed  Cayble | 12/15/08
You can see my posts above.  TripleII | 12/15/08
I understand you disbelief...but, what if it's true..  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.  TripleII | 12/15/08
Let me try it a different way....  rs_jr | 12/15/08
There's nothing extraordinary about the claim.  ye | 12/16/08
Actually...  storm14k | 12/15/08
That's a good point...  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Once again....  storm14k | 12/16/08
Its not the outrage. Thats just FUD.  Cayble | 12/15/08
So you are claiming...  storm14k | 12/16/08
rofl  do it yourself IT | 12/16/08
re: The responses thus far have been funny and predictable..  none none | 12/15/08
Good catch...  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Wow...  storm14k | 12/15/08
Better analysis matched to source report makes a better article  jlang@... | 12/16/08
Interesting that IE doesn't make the list....  k12IT | 12/15/08
So, is that the minimum requirement? IE must be on the list?  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Do you think this list is accurate without IE?  storm14k | 12/15/08
I honestly don't know...I treat it as if it were..but that's not the point  rs_jr | 12/15/08
I think you misjudge the reaction.  storm14k | 12/15/08
I hear what you are saying...  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Yes  coreyb42 | 12/15/08
No...but it would have been more true  k12IT | 12/15/08
IE more bugs right now.  bjbrock | 12/15/08
OK...I'll bite....  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Once again....do you believe this list is accurate?  storm14k | 12/15/08
Again, I am not saying that the list is accurate...  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Then if you can't say whether its accurate or not...  storm14k | 12/16/08
Too many useless features, too little design  terry flores | 12/15/08
So, why shouldn't they all hang their heads in shame?  rs_jr | 12/15/08
Hall of Shame  terry flores | 12/16/08
I see your logic...uh, I think...  rs_jr | 12/16/08
A simple test for you ...  terry flores | 12/16/08
Now I understand...at least part of what you are saying.  rs_jr | 12/16/08
Most vulnerable apps are unpatched apps  Vektor_ | 12/15/08
Wow. Look at all the rabid iBoi's and M"$" haters  Gnutella | 12/15/08
You throw a fake report out and they go crazy!  WiredGuy | 12/15/08
Thank You! This explains it all!  TripleII | 12/15/08
Even if that is true.....how is it a "fake report"?  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
Not "fake", but ZDNET should clearly state "MS software not included"  Basic Logic | 12/15/08
If you read it all....you'd have found this....  xuniL_z | 12/15/08
A slice of recent history:  rikasa | 12/15/08
I've got to tell you......  xuniL_z | 12/16/08
this is how  WiredGuy | 12/16/08
Oh dear. FF finally gets called out.  Scrat | 12/15/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  cynic | 12/15/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  darheim | 12/15/08
This is a BS report --- Criteria #5 & #6 eliminate all MS software !!!  Basic Logic | 12/15/08
Vulnerabilities who cares.. What are the most dangerous apps?  doctorSpoc | 12/15/08
Are These Vulnerabilities Running On Windows?  itanalyst2@... | 12/15/08
Bwa-ha-ha-ha...In your face OSS fanatics...nt  transposeIT | 12/15/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  stone-cutter | 12/15/08
yep, agreed..  dinosaur_z | 12/16/08
MS Office isn't on the list either. Coincidence?  V@... | 12/16/08
HAHAHAHA  Alan Smithie | 12/16/08
Does this survey take into account pre patched or  James Quinn | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  mrlinux | 12/16/08
could you be bit critical?  patibulo | 12/16/08
Another unpatched serious security flaw found in IE  wackoae | 12/16/08
Explicitly excluded? Are you one of those people who believes...  ye | 12/16/08
Again?  MisterMiester | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  richard.gardner@... | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  floodman | 12/16/08
Assessing vulnerabilities by number of patches is flawed.  D. W. Bierbaum | 12/16/08
Misleading Headline and Intro  tomqhawk | 12/16/08
Were is IE in light of this flaw ...  MisterMiester | 12/16/08
Read the .pdf and you'll see why IE Is missing  Dutchie027 | 12/16/08
Most Microsoft apps use update ...  MisterMiester | 12/16/08
Finally got to number 6...  Dan0man | 12/16/08
Read the .pdf and you'll see why IE Is missing  black-jack | 12/16/08
.pdf  Cooter2001 | 12/16/08
309 vs 145  Dan0man | 12/16/08
Only 12? And what about IE? How many hundreds did they get?  ghawkins@... | 12/16/08
Ryan - you need to amend your introduction  midgeuk | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  dieseltaylor | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  m7842g@... | 12/16/08
Read #2 Adobe had 14 so bias reporting?  Randalllind | 12/16/08
Not a bad idea to remind people FF is not perfect  butler360 | 12/16/08
Actually nothing is perfect, but...  D. W. Bierbaum | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  Furiousrog | 12/16/08
The #1 & #6 criteria of this study....  dinosaur_z | 12/16/08
Link to why I would trust Firefox over IE...  D. W. Bierbaum | 12/16/08
Another link disproving this article  dansen926 | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  paul.finelt | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  bucca36 | 12/16/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  jameshorton4@... | 12/16/08
And where were Microsoft?  pico_D | 12/16/08
re: And where where Microsoft?  /dev/random | 12/16/08
One MS product on the list, here come the flammers - nt  USTechHead | 12/17/08
Timing of article of certainly interesting  walterbyrd@... | 12/17/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  ITSa341@... | 12/17/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  cyrilc | 12/17/08
Criteria discussion  SysHop | 12/17/08
Hit the nail on the head, this study is just PR  icebox93 | 12/17/08
Ryan, you can do better.  clareJ | 12/17/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  edwin.uy@... | 12/17/08
Official response from Mozilla, paraphrased: study is completely flawed  ronapt | 12/18/08
Two things I noticed about the "study"  jbroche18 | 12/19/08
GROW UP!!!!!!!!  mlambert890@... | 12/19/08
Yada, yada ...  thx-1138_@... | 12/21/08
Getting on the Bit9 List ?Huh?  daves1646 | 12/20/08
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  junkmailstone@... | 12/26/08
Secunia states "no unpatched Secunia advisories" for Firefox 3.x ?  ~doolittle~ | 12/30/08
Quick Bug patches??  Crogon | 01/07/09
RE: Firefox tops list of 12 most vulnerable apps  jmcb74 | 01/11/09

What do you think?

SponsoredWhite Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads